The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

3D printers

Bambu Lab X1 Carbon vs Creality Ender

Hacker News owners lean toward the Bambu Lab X1 Carbon.

Bambu Lab X1 CarbonCreality Ender
Owners with an opinion68124
Positive verdicts87% of 6255% of 88
Positive/negative since 202436/626/32
Happy after 3+ years04
Longest happy owner2 yrs5 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and value
Criticized forease of useease of use and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Bambu Lab X1 Carbon: Doesn’t like itCreality Ender: Likes it
Same experience. Wanted to get an X1C after I had saved enough, then I was lucky enough to be able to send it back within the 2 weeks time frame. I live in the EU do I was able to demand the refund. Now I am rebuilding my old Ender 3 with Openbuilds parts into anCoreXY setup, all metal hotend, sturdier metal frame, and the new RAMPS board with a raspberry pi and klipper setup. Don't know enough about the multi tool related things, but maybe I am gonna focus on that afterwards. I am having tons of fun while doing so, it has been quite a while since I rebuilt my Anet A8 into an AM8 with a custom Marlin firmware back then.
Bambu Lab X1 Carbon: Likes itCreality Ender: Doesn’t like it
I stop seeing those issues after starting using Bambulab X1 3d printer, it just works 99 percent of the time. My old ender 3 v2 had those issues due to bed changing its shape during printing(thin metal changing shape in micro level due to temp and mechanical stress with 4 knobs pulling down), not sticking well, not enough fast cooling or cooling effects bed temp profile, way off even with auto level probes. Also open 3d printer with bunch of air flow is a killer for those prints. OP should try Bambulab like enclosed more accurate 3d printer from a local 3d print shop or a hackerspace after locking the design and enclosure iterations.
Bambu Lab X1 Carbon: Likes itCreality Ender: Neutral
I agree entirely with your first two sentences (I like both). But I disagree pretty hard with the rest of it. An X1C spits out prints that are higher quality than my ender 3 would do, in a variety of materials the ender couldn't handle, even with a HUGE amount of time understanding the ender and how it works (incl upgrading or replacing just about every component). Further - I think some of the divide is between the folks printing models, and the folks printing functional parts. When I print nice models (ex: toys for my kids or gifts) then sure - I tweak still because appearances matter. But if I just want a functional print because I need an enclosure for an electronics project, or I want a hanger for my wall, or I need a new footpad for a desk... Mediocre is a-ok. And again... The X1C is not spitting out mostly mediocre parts. If anything - the "learning" you need to do mostly lives in the slicers/models at this point.
Bambu Lab X1 Carbon: Likes itCreality Ender: Doesn’t like it
As someone that went from a janky Ender to a Bambu X1C, I think I can explain the differences. Is your hobby 3d printing? If so a machine that allows you more freedom to tinker and requires more hands on knowledge, but at a slightly lower price makes sense. If you use a 3d printer for your other hobbies, then something more appliance like that just works like the Bambu lines is probably a better fit. I basically never 3d printed before, because every time I wanted to print I spent more time fiddling with the printer than I spent on my actual hobby. Now I spend almost no time thinking about the printer, and I use it almost daily. I think both Prusa and Bambu have great printers and target different demographics, Bambu was a better fit for me and my needs, and I think a lot of people fall into the same general class as me. If you want a 3d printing appliance go with a Bambu, if you want to spend time customizing and upgrading and tinkering with a 3d printer go with another brand like Prusa.
Switched from the Creality Ender to the Bambu Lab X1 CarbonBambu Lab X1 Carbon: Likes it
Yeah... The market is still shifting in response to the X1C. 10 years ago... I would manually level my ender, religiously monitor it, and still deal with a decently high failure rate (esp for anything other than PLA). Tuning the printer took easily as much time as I actually spent printing with it. I upgraded all the things , flashed firmware, ran octoprint, etc... It was like driving - gotta keep the hands on the wheel and maintain alertness at all times. It was an activity that required my attention and focus. Then I caved and got an X1C in 2023. It's... a really, REALLY good machine. It's like flying somewhere. I get on the plane, start up a movie or a book, and someone wakes me up when the flight is over. It's a tool that is doing things for me while I do other stuff. I'm at the point where I'm not really interested in the "middle" all that much. Either go with a Voron and get the "I'm driving" feeling if that's what you want. Or get a Bambu and get chauffeured to successful print.
Switched from the Creality Ender to the Bambu Lab X1 CarbonBambu Lab X1 Carbon: Likes it
This article highlights why Bambu has been eating Prusa's lunch the past few years. Imagine spending over $1000 then needing to print parts to get it to work properly. I swapped my Ender5 for an X1C two years ago, and since then, I have only had to do whatever maintenance the X1C tells me. Using my X1C feels much closer to using my laser paper printer, whereas my Ender5 ended up being a hobby in itself.
Bambu Lab X1 Carbon: Likes itCreality Ender: Likes it
Modern printers are pretty good, now. I have the ender 3 v2 and it was considered a huge upgrade over the original ender 3, but stuff from bambu labs are actually "remove from box, push print, get object" as long promised. The Bambu Lab X1 isn't cheap, starting at about $1200, but it Works As Advertised
Bambu Lab X1 Carbon: Recommends itCreality Ender: Recommends it
If you have money and little time and patience, Bambu labs p1 or x1 series is one of the easiest to set up out of the box, and you can get or add on the AMS (automatic material system) which makes it easier to do multicolor printing. (US $700+) If you have little money and more time and patience, Creality Enders are a good basic introduction to all the nuances, pains and heartaches of 3d printing but will give you a better idea of fundamentals. ($100-300) Expect to lay out another $100 for filament, upgraded bed and other small parts like bed springs. Don't buy a used machine as a starter because you'll just be taking on someone else's headache, but once experienced you can find some craigslist and offerup deals for spare parts or a small print farm, occasional like new "used twice" $50 printers.
Bambu Lab X1 Carbon: NeutralCreality Ender: Neutral
Reality we’re being pretty shady and only acknowledged / released info after the community put up an uproar. The machine performance isn’t bad but I’d still recommend a p1p and just using local lan instead of the cloud. I own two x1cc, and 2 p1p, tons of ender 3 + 5’s, Prusa xl ( it’s a beast but slower than bambu by a decent margin).