The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

3D printers

Bambu Lab P1S vs Prusa

Hacker News owners lean toward the Bambu Lab P1S.

Bambu Lab P1SPrusa
Owners with an opinion43208
Positive verdicts87% of 3977% of 186
Positive/negative since 202433/488/27
Happy after 3+ years08
Longest happy owner2 yrs10 yrs
Praised forease of use and reliabilityreliability and ease of use
Criticized forsoftware and repairabilityvalue and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Bambu Lab P1S: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
I traded a Prusa MK3S for a secondhand Bambu P1S and it was night and day. I believe the prusa could have gotten to a place where it printed well and consistently, but the P1S *just works*. It printed better out of the gate with 0 tinkering than the Prusa did after I had spent hours calibrating, testing, and re-calibrating it. I wanted the Prusa to be just as good, which is why I started with it. I wanted to support the open ecosystem, but not at the expense of not getting to do what I actually set out to (print things nicely). It's a shame! Maybe I was holding it wrong (but again, with the Bambu, I didn't have to worry about it).
Bambu Lab P1S: Recommends itPrusa: Likes it
I have a Prusa i3 Mk3 and a Bambu P1S and I have to disagree. They are in entirely different leagues. The Prusa was a step change improvement from an Ender 3, and the Bambu is a step change from the Prusa i3 Mk3. It definitely depends on what you're printing, but I personally saw all my print failures on the Prusa pretty much go away overnight with Bambu.
Bambu Lab P1S: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
As someone with both an Insta360 camera and a Bambu printer, I feel it, would love to buy GoPro and Prusa, but the value just isn't there. For one, I had a GoPro whose sensor broke after about 20 minutes of recorded. I ended up getting 3 different replacements, all of which also broke. In the end I just forgot about it when my home burnt down in a wildfire. I got an Insta360 with better picture quality that's also been more reliable for a similar cost. And I would have loved to buy a Prusa printer but I got a Bambu P1S combo for $600, an equivalent Prusa plus the $300 shipping to Canada would have been ~$2500 CAD. For making trinkets for my 3 year old son plus the few random other things I'd make it's not worth it to pay 4x the money. Maybe it'll forever be this way due to the differences in cost of living but I do feel as though there's a million barriers to entry to building a business in North America, at least a business that's not fully online.
Bambu Lab P1S: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
> I don’t think they earned it. 1) The people around me who bought a Bambu P1S or P2S weren't swayed by marketing. Some of them even owned Prusa machines. They bought those Bambu printers because they had products they needed printed, and the Bambu got it done while the Prusa failed prints and made them dork around with things. 2) The A1 minis are cheap and look good to consumers; they also work remarkably reliably . Prusa doesn't have anything even remotely in the same class. That is squarely the fault of Prusa. 3) A lot of people who don't know any better can go to Best Buy and buy a Bambu in stock, off the shelf, with a return policy . Again, the fault lies squarely with Prusa. 4) The Bambu printers had fundamentally better components like linear slides and servo motors, for example. Again, fault to Prusa. Prusa got caught with their pants down and refused to adjust for far too long. Bambu did genuine engineering while Prusa rested on its laurels.
Bambu Lab P1S: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
The A1 Mini was my first printer, which is of course biases my opinion of other printers. I've bought many, many other printers since then, and every time I've gotten something other than a Bambu Lab printer I've been disappointed, and ended up returning them or selling them. Creality's K1 Plus was great, but regularly needed the extruder disassembled to get broken filament out. Anycubic Kobra 3 Max regularly failed to keep prints on the bed. I bought 2 Elegoo Centauri Carbons. The first has been out of commission since the extruder went haywire, and I couldn't get replacement parts without going through some random support chat app, and the 2nd one's build plate delaminated the first weekend I had the printer. The Snapmaker U1 I'm pretty happy with, but when I first got it, I learned you have to be very gentle with how you put the spools on, as it can pop an internal plastic panel off with interferes with the Y-axis. Prusas are good, but price and availability are issues (I bought all the above new at my local Microcenter). I do have an older Prusa MK3 that I bought for an pellet extruder conversion, but for a printer with no online capabilities and a need to manually level it via paper, it cost more used than a new Bambu Lab P1S. I'm okay with putting your money where your ideology is, but imagine if the only alternative to an iPhone's walled garden was a $2000 Android.
Bambu Lab P1S: Doesn’t like itPrusa: Likes it
I've extensively used Prusa MK3/MK3+, Creality K1, Bambu A1 and Bambu P1S. The K1 is the fastest but the worst hardware. We were joking they have a half life of about 3 months. The Prusa's are workhorses, they break too but at far longer intervals, they're simple and infinitely more repairable to the point that I've 'remixed' the printers to different sizes (600 mm high, as well as 1x1 meter) modifying the firmware as needed. The Bambu A1 is much better engineered than the Prusa, but the software sucks and the company behind it sucks even more they work, until they break and then they are as often as not complete write offs but it can take a considerable time before they break. The P1S is a better version of the K1 hardware wise but the software and user interface are absolutely terrible, there is no USB port that is normally accessible the one that is there doesn't work and it does not support folders. They are essentially forcing you to use their closed-source cloud based software. You can run the printer in lan only mode but you still have no idea what that cloud plugin is up to and there are multiple reports of large data streams with unknown contents making it to Bambu owned servers.
Bambu Lab P1S: Doesn’t like itPrusa: Likes it
If I were starting today I'd definitely choose the Core One over the P1S (thanks to this rug pull). It's vastly more expensive, and the MMU isn't worth it from what I've heard, and the build volume is significantly smaller, but I don't think I'd go with Bambu after this week.
Bambu Lab P1S: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
For me no, definitely not. The Core ONE is the first Prusa I would actually consider buying. But it's twice as expensive as a Bambu P1S and lacks various features that are optional on the prusa but included on the P1S. Like air filtering, the chamber cam (I know it's bad but good enough for me). And their alternative for the AMS (they call it the MMU) is way less sophisticated, it doesn't do full roll retraction or include a drybox for example. Finally, I have more faith in injection-molded parts than 3D printed ones. They're smoother, more precise, more solid. Now the extendibility is a big feature but it's not something I would use. I want a printer that I can unpack and go and have minimal maintenance and tinkering on. My hobby is about printing things, the printer itself is not my hobby. It's a tool and it should just work. So no, so far Bambu is and remains the the go-to brand for me. I have a P1S + AMS and also an A1 Mini, I think it's amazing how much value you get for your money at 180 euro. I actually use the A1 Mini more lately when I have something small to print due to the easily exchangable hotend (I often print small high-detail stuff on it with the 0,2mm nozzle). And it's a lot quieter than the P1S. And like others mentioned, Prusa is becoming a lot less open source. In the video he mentioned it is because of the Chinese clones which makes some sense but still...
Bambu Lab P1S: Recommends itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
Prusa Core One Build Volume: 250 x 220 x 270 mm Price: 1199 USD assembled, 949 USD kit Bambu Lab P1S Build Volume: 256 x 256 x 256 mm Price: 699 USD assembled (549 USD during sales) The nice features of the Prusa Core One is that it comes with an ethernet port and an integrated NFC reader. However, the bed camera, chamber filter, and hotend accelerometer are all "optional addons." All of those come standard on the Bambu Lab P1S. At that price, the Prusa is a hard sell. I'd rather get two of the Bambu printers, or one printer combo with AMS.
Bambu Lab P1S: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
> You can’t beat Prusa: the printers come out of the box working perfectly At the cost of being old and slow. I wouldn't be throwing roses to Prusa after they effectively ceded the market to everyone else. For $200, you can get a Sovol SV06 that's a smarter iteration on the MK3/MK3S (while also being open-source both in hardware and software); for $500 you can get a Bambu P1P that's much faster and has better vertical integration through the slicer (and for $100 more than that you can get a P1S, which is high-temp ready while also doing all the same things as the P1P).
Switched from the Prusa to the Bambu Lab P1SBambu Lab P1S: Recommends it
I tend to agree. I've built a Prusa previously and my P1S is just so much more reliable, it's the first printer I've been able to recommend to friends and colleagues who I wouldn't expect to enjoy tinkering with a printer but would enjoy printing. I have simply not had a failed print, it's incredible. I have so much confidence in the unit that I now keep two rolls of the same colour loaded and if I find a cool model while out and about, I just print it with full trust it'll be waiting for me by the time I get home. Amazing progress.
Bambu Lab P1S: Recommends itPrusa: Recommends it
Price-wise a P1S will work out cheaper unless you get a really poor quality Trident kit (which I wouldn't do). If you just want to print stuff (like if the printer is to support another hobby, or you have a business) get a P1S/X1C or a Prusa MK4. I wouldn't personally bother with an AMS until down the line when you're sure you need it. VORONs are fantastic if you want a fun and very well documented robot building project, and at the end you get something pretty comparable to a Bambu. It can be a frustrating process at times but you'll learn a lot about a variety of interesting stuff. The printers are also massively hackable and moddable, and they have larger build plate options (although ~250mm^2 is realistically enough for most home users). Bambu is the exact opposite mentality, fully closed source, they work incredibly well but are effectively a black box. Think Linux vs Mac. Another option would be to see if you have a local maker/hackerspace, they will usually have at least one decent printer.