The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

3D printers

Bambu Lab P1P vs Prusa

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Bambu Lab P1P.

Bambu Lab P1PPrusa
Owners with an opinion9208
Positive verdicts100% of 877% of 186
Positive/negative since 20245/088/27
Happy after 3+ years08
Longest happy owner0.33 yrs10 yrs
Praised forease of use and performancereliability and ease of use
Criticized fornoise and designvalue and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Bambu Lab P1P: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
Do other budget brands really print as well as Bambu out of the box with no tinkering? Going from an old Prusa MK3s to a Bambu P1P+AMS was a huge upgrade. Mostly speed, reliable bed adhesion, and easy material swapping, it’s made printing as a hobby much more fun, and at this point I’m more interested in designing things to print than tinkering with the printer itself. I’ve followed the online drama, but so far, not regretting the purchase. Would avoid Bambu if printing comercially/at scale, but the ‘user hostility’ doesn’t have much real world impact on hobbyists with 1-2 printers. Yet.
Bambu Lab P1P: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
Cool, but that's not why people buy things. I don't buy a bike for the pleasure of getting to repair it when I inevitably eat shit on a gravel road. While you're busy ordering parts for your Prusa and taking it apart, people just buy another A1 or P1P for basically nothing. While you're spending 5 hours trying to stabilise your printing plate and ensuring your nozzle isn't vomiting out super melted , the bambulabs go haha printing goes brrr thanks for feeding me shale oil it'll work great. If you're 3d printing enough that your printer breaks, you are 100% making enough money to just eat the costs of another printer.
Bambu Lab P1P: NeutralPrusa: Likes it
Reality we’re being pretty shady and only acknowledged / released info after the community put up an uproar. The machine performance isn’t bad but I’d still recommend a p1p and just using local lan instead of the cloud. I own two x1cc, and 2 p1p, tons of ender 3 + 5’s, Prusa xl ( it’s a beast but slower than bambu by a decent margin).
Bambu Lab P1P: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
> You can’t beat Prusa: the printers come out of the box working perfectly At the cost of being old and slow. I wouldn't be throwing roses to Prusa after they effectively ceded the market to everyone else. For $200, you can get a Sovol SV06 that's a smarter iteration on the MK3/MK3S (while also being open-source both in hardware and software); for $500 you can get a Bambu P1P that's much faster and has better vertical integration through the slicer (and for $100 more than that you can get a P1S, which is high-temp ready while also doing all the same things as the P1P).
Bambu Lab P1P: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
Replaced all 25 MKS3+ machines with 15 Bambu P1Ps and 5 Bambu X1C's about 2 months ago. Sold the last Mks3+ yesterday. They Print 3 Times faster than the MKS3+ with same or better quality in some prints. 24/7 printing almost with zero issues in my print farm. BVery easy to send jobs to it from the Bambu slicer based on the Prusa slicer which is open source and enhanced to make complicated print jobs spread across multiple virtual print beds a beautiful thing! At this point i see ZERO reason to consider a MK4. Bambu hit this out of the ball park and into the neighbouring city as far as I am concerned.
Bambu Lab P1P: Likes itPrusa: Likes it
Prusa may still be king if you're using printers commercially, running them hard 24/7 in a print farm, wanting to be sure your investment has a decent lifespan with readily-available spare parts and upgrade options. But it's a premium brand now. For lighter use by hobbyists, Bambu is the clear winner on price/performance. The 'less open' downside is not a factor to most people, and the printers generally work so well out-of-the-box that repairability isn't as much of a concern as it was on printers of the past. Personally I went from a Prusa MK3s to a Bambu P1P (after looking long+hard at Prusa options), and so far, no regrets. (Although I've kept the old Prusa as a 2nd printer and upgraded it to a MK3.5, but mostly just because I do enjoy a bit of tinkering with them)