The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

3D printers

Bambu Lab A1 vs Prusa

Hacker News owners lean toward the Bambu Lab A1.

Bambu Lab A1Prusa
Owners with an opinion42208
Positive verdicts92% of 3877% of 186
Positive/negative since 202434/388/27
Happy after 3+ years08
Longest happy owner2 yrs10 yrs
Praised forease of use and performancereliability and ease of use
Criticized forsoftware and supportvalue and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Bambu Lab A1: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
The A1 Mini was my first printer, which is of course biases my opinion of other printers. I've bought many, many other printers since then, and every time I've gotten something other than a Bambu Lab printer I've been disappointed, and ended up returning them or selling them. Creality's K1 Plus was great, but regularly needed the extruder disassembled to get broken filament out. Anycubic Kobra 3 Max regularly failed to keep prints on the bed. I bought 2 Elegoo Centauri Carbons. The first has been out of commission since the extruder went haywire, and I couldn't get replacement parts without going through some random support chat app, and the 2nd one's build plate delaminated the first weekend I had the printer. The Snapmaker U1 I'm pretty happy with, but when I first got it, I learned you have to be very gentle with how you put the spools on, as it can pop an internal plastic panel off with interferes with the Y-axis. Prusas are good, but price and availability are issues (I bought all the above new at my local Microcenter). I do have an older Prusa MK3 that I bought for an pellet extruder conversion, but for a printer with no online capabilities and a need to manually level it via paper, it cost more used than a new Bambu Lab P1S. I'm okay with putting your money where your ideology is, but imagine if the only alternative to an iPhone's walled garden was a $2000 Android.
Bambu Lab A1: Doesn’t like itPrusa: Likes it
My A1 has lots of annoying issues. It did print great out of the box, but requires a fair bit of maintenance to keep that up. My prusa has be far more reliable so far. admittedly it’s newer than the a1 so it’s too early to be super conclusive on that, but so far it’s been quite a bit better Of course, it’s quite a bit more money too
Bambu Lab A1: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
What bambulab printers that have the "A1" series nozzle, replacing one is a matter of 3 seconds, just by naked hands. 10x times faster than in the Prusa world (Nextruder included). Being this the single most important thing a printer need from the POV of servicing, this is a huge difference.
Bambu Lab A1: Recommends itPrusa: Likes it
I hate to say this. Bambu A1. I'm operating a farm of mixed plumage: 20 Prusa's, 12 Creality K1s and 24 Bambus. Of all of those the Bambus are by far the least troublesome and I would definitely recommend those to a beginner. That said, Bambu is a crap company and they can't be trusted not to do a rugpull sooner or later. We don't have them connected to wifi for that reason alone and tbh it doesn't really add anything to the experience. I like the fact that they're all stand-alone and as long as the power is up the printers are printing. In the last year we've processed about 3000 Kg total with these. In some more detail: - The Prusa's are real workhorses. They are not the fastest, but they're expensive and they break. But you can always fix them and the degree to which you can tinker with them (especially while they're running) is much higher than the others. I've made a couple of custom ones (one 1x1 meter x 25 cm build volume, five more that are the regular width and length but 60 cm height), with adopted firmware. It's an insanely flexible platform. If you can think of it, handle a hex key and do some minor firmware hacking you can probably make it. - The K1s... well. Initially we were very impressed. Got a couple to test with, decided they work and ordered 10 more. After a few days the first extruder broke. Gears just snapped their teeth right off. Turns out the extruder gears are plastic. So, ordered upgraded extruders. Next, one after the other, power supplies dyin…
Bambu Lab A1: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
Cool, but that's not why people buy things. I don't buy a bike for the pleasure of getting to repair it when I inevitably eat shit on a gravel road. While you're busy ordering parts for your Prusa and taking it apart, people just buy another A1 or P1P for basically nothing. While you're spending 5 hours trying to stabilise your printing plate and ensuring your nozzle isn't vomiting out super melted , the bambulabs go haha printing goes brrr thanks for feeding me shale oil it'll work great. If you're 3d printing enough that your printer breaks, you are 100% making enough money to just eat the costs of another printer.
Bambu Lab A1: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
Excellent article. It is very hard to understand a few things about Prusa, lately: 1. The Nextruder looks 5 years behind Bambulab nozzle switching, without to mention the cost of a new nozzle. A clogged nozzle is a non issue in a Bambulab printer, but it causes me a big cost and more work with my MK4 (which has the same extruder as the Core One). 2. How is it possible that these printers still lack at least a cheap webcam? 3. One of the strengths of Prusa should be support. It used to be very good, years ago. Now the issue the OP is reporting about the app that is not able to detect the principal component in the sound of the belt, is an example of a more extended problem, that one can see in many ways, especially in the MK4 / Core One documentation, that is especially lacking. In general, here the OP is doing the work that Prusa should be doing to provide a better experience, without to mention all the design issues that they are not fixing directly before shipping their printers. I'm also a Bambulab user, and my A1 costed a fraction of my MK4 and it is the printer I always hit because of the zero-issues. It just works. Now companies may have ups and downs, but there is some problem at Prusa: they are still not understanding what's really happening and where their problems are.
Bambu Lab A1: Likes itPrusa: Recommends it
Same here. Now I have an A1 + A1 mini too. It's amazing. This is what I dreamed of when I built my first RepRap. I did get me Ender 3 working eventually but the print quality isn't as good as any of the Bambu printers and it's super slow. The new CoreXY Prusa One is also a very good buy when it comes out but the A1/A1 mini in particular are just such a good deal at the moment.
Bambu Lab A1: Recommends itPrusa: Likes it
Bambu Lab A1 is probably one of the best entry printers right now. There is also Prusa MINI+, they have a bit more parts that are open source. (Though I believe not everything) If you want to go fully open source and all in, you can check out the voron project. For example Voron Trident. But I would only do that if you want to tinker and know a bit about electronics and building.
Bambu Lab A1: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
> So let's discuss Prusa: The Bambu A1 competes with Prusa's MK4 model but is signficantly cheaper, faster and does more. For the price of one Prusa MK4 with shipping I could buy three Bambu A1 printers or two Bambu A2 printers plus the AMS addon which adds multi-color printing. I would argue that was always inevitable, Prusas are laughably overpriced and it's not like they're open source in the sense that you can build your own. They took the RepRap idea and commercialized it with an insane markup, benefiting from open source much more than Bambu probably did. For the longest time their PrusaPrinters model hosting site only supported .gcode files for their printers which was just a large fuck you to anyone with any other printer. Hence why Thingiverse ran circles around them with a half broken site. There is a lot more community value in providing hackable low cost hardware like Creality did with the Ender, becase then people that have time but not money can you know... buy it. And then develop open source software or make models for it with that time.
Bambu Lab A1: Doesn’t like itPrusa: Recommends it
This looks much better than it actually is for a couple of reasons: - Multicolor is not something you actually use often and is horribly slow. Slow like in a 2 hours print becomes 12 hours print if it's colored. And it wastes a lot of plastic (and doing so does a lot of noise, too). - The printer can't print things like ASA. Limited to PLA/PETG/TPU. - While the design of the hotend and swappable nozzle looks nice at a first glance, the printer is a closed design and is not clear how well you can service it when needed. I've a Prusa MK4 and owned different Prusa Minis in the past, to print for a shop 24h, and if you want to print for production and not just for a few weeks hobby, you need to be able to fix those printers. Also Bambulab has a bad track in providing parts, when needed. So yes, competitors like Prusa should do something to improve their printers and adjust the price point a bit (at this point the Mini is too costly, and its hot-end needs to be redesigned, and certain XL/MK4 improvements back-ported to the Mini, like the load cell and the all metal nozzle design). But after the first days of printing colored things, a Prusa Mini is likely a much better printer for somebody that really wants to do something nice with a 3D printer, and not just a few colored miniatures. Also Bambulab behavior in using open source software written by others, at least in the past was very questionable. Anyway: they are doing something good to the market by pushing other vendors to d…
Switched from the Prusa to the Bambu Lab A1Bambu Lab A1: Likes it
'You wanted the Chinese clone that took the ideas, lowered the price and added cloud shit' - two things: 1. Bambu has a lot of innovative hardware pieces that aren't in say Prusa - I wouldn't call it Chinese clone that took the ideas. Bambu is not one of those Prusa clones, let's get that straight. 2. Yup, I appreciate lower price and features that make it easy to use. Yup I appreciate minimal setup time and faster/consistent prints. I am not a 3D printing enthusiast - I am a user, like millions of other 'normal' people in the world. Somehow folks on hackernews always discount this. No one ever really gave a shit precisely because it was expensive and hard to use - Bambu is fixing both of those things. I've seen people who did 3D printing full time, who had Prusa farms and extensive knowledge of repairing them completely give up Prusas and switch to Bambu. Bambu seems to be a better product for a lot of audience. I don't see anything wrong with influencers taking up 3D printing - they have the reach and I'd love to see 3D printers in the hands of more people. What makes you think influencers/people wouldn't use 3D printers to bring their ideas to life? That's precisely why I want 3D printers to be more accessible (both in terms of usability and cost).
Bambu Lab A1: NeutralPrusa: Neutral
I've put 10's of thousands of hours on MK3s and the PINDA works fine as long as it is mounted well (which isn't always the case) and set to the right height relative to the nozzle. The automatic calibration routine - on a well built printer, which also isn't always the case, runs exactly once after you've built the printer. Fine tuning is possible, and can be quite useful if you want to play around with the degree to which your prints stick to the bed, for instance for automatic print release tricks (and bed temp as well). The fact that you have all this control comes at a price compared to say a Bambu A1: you need to know a bit more about how a printer works. But that knowledge will come in very handy when sooner or later you want to do something that isn't in the manual. The MK4 loadcell is a solution for some problems and a the cause of some others, it is not the best implementation of a loadcell either but it is smarter than the way for instance the Creality K1 and variations are set up (they have four, underneath the bed). I would recommend against the Creality series printers by the way, they're dirt cheap and wicked fast but they break all the time and the stock extruder is complete junk. Finally, the best investment you can probably make alongside any printer is a multi-roll filament dryer with a heating element and a fan. That more than anything else will affect your print quality. We do the bulk of our work on Bambu's now, but for really high precision stuff we wi…
Bambu Lab A1: Likes itPrusa: Likes it
I bought a Bambu A1 Mini to replace an Ender 3, thinking it would just be for occasional printing. I wanted something smaller and better looking. The opposite happened: the process got so much easier that I now regret not getting something bigger, maybe even with AMS. So while I can't compare the whole market, I can definitely say the jump in ease of use was huge. Prusa printers are great too, especially if you care about supporting a company that invested heavily in open source. I found them harder to justify on price, but I also understand why people choose them for that reason. There have also been pretty public disputes around Bambu's use of open-source work from the Prusa/Slic3r ecosystem, so that is part of the decision too.
Bambu Lab A1: Likes itPrusa: Likes it
I've extensively used Prusa MK3/MK3+, Creality K1, Bambu A1 and Bambu P1S. The K1 is the fastest but the worst hardware. We were joking they have a half life of about 3 months. The Prusa's are workhorses, they break too but at far longer intervals, they're simple and infinitely more repairable to the point that I've 'remixed' the printers to different sizes (600 mm high, as well as 1x1 meter) modifying the firmware as needed. The Bambu A1 is much better engineered than the Prusa, but the software sucks and the company behind it sucks even more they work, until they break and then they are as often as not complete write offs but it can take a considerable time before they break. The P1S is a better version of the K1 hardware wise but the software and user interface are absolutely terrible, there is no USB port that is normally accessible the one that is there doesn't work and it does not support folders. They are essentially forcing you to use their closed-source cloud based software. You can run the printer in lan only mode but you still have no idea what that cloud plugin is up to and there are multiple reports of large data streams with unknown contents making it to Bambu owned servers.
Bambu Lab A1: Likes itPrusa: Likes it
Bambu Lab A1 Mini ($299-399) Excellent print quality out of the box Automatic bed leveling and calibration Very user-friendly with great software Compact size, perfect for beginners Creality K1 Max (~$599) 300x300x300mm build volume Fast printing speeds (up to 600mm/s) Auto-leveling and enclosed design Good balance of features and price Prusa MINI+ (~$429 kit, $529 assembled) Exceptional reliability and support Magnetic flexible bed Excellent community and documentation Great for learning and consistent results
Bambu Lab A1: Likes itPrusa: Likes it
Yeah, I've got an A1 that I bought on sale. It's sitting next to a Prusa MK3S. I was doing prints for my nephews for Halloween and the A1 would do a print in 2h and PrusaSlicer estimated 9h for the MK3S. And I have, so far, not had a single failed print on the A1. They're rare on the MK3S too. But... the MK3S is "start the print and it'll be ready in the morning" and the A1 is "start the print and it'll be ready by lunch, and if you need to iterate you can have another one done by 3pm"