The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

3D printers

Bambu Lab A1 Mini vs Prusa

Hacker News owners lean toward the Bambu Lab A1 Mini.

Bambu Lab A1 MiniPrusa
Owners with an opinion16208
Positive verdicts100% of 1577% of 186
Positive/negative since 202414/088/27
Happy after 3+ years08
Longest happy owner2 yrs10 yrs
Praised forease of use and valuereliability and ease of use
Criticized for–value and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Bambu Lab A1 Mini: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
Yeah I’ve had one, still do, it never gets used because it’s a project car. Compared with one button press and coming back to a print in a few hours, it’s a constant nightmare of debugging, print issues, and manually changing filaments that aren’t stored in an airtight container and get wet. It’s not even competition, as much as I would like to support open source tools the Prusa stuff is an order of magnitude more expensive than a A1 Mini that will make a reliable print every time. It’s like saying a bicycle is a serious contender to a train, they both have kind of similar things going on but you’d have to be insane to suggest that they do as good of a job as one another at the things people actually want to achieve.
Bambu Lab A1 Mini: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
> I don’t think they earned it. 1) The people around me who bought a Bambu P1S or P2S weren't swayed by marketing. Some of them even owned Prusa machines. They bought those Bambu printers because they had products they needed printed, and the Bambu got it done while the Prusa failed prints and made them dork around with things. 2) The A1 minis are cheap and look good to consumers; they also work remarkably reliably . Prusa doesn't have anything even remotely in the same class. That is squarely the fault of Prusa. 3) A lot of people who don't know any better can go to Best Buy and buy a Bambu in stock, off the shelf, with a return policy . Again, the fault lies squarely with Prusa. 4) The Bambu printers had fundamentally better components like linear slides and servo motors, for example. Again, fault to Prusa. Prusa got caught with their pants down and refused to adjust for far too long. Bambu did genuine engineering while Prusa rested on its laurels.
Bambu Lab A1 Mini: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
> The people that started in 3d printing when they had to assemble the whole machine by hand are now sad to see their hobby replaced by something too easy, it feels like cheating. I have a 10 year old kit-built prusa I3 sitting next to me. Its brother is in the basement next to a kossel. It's been years since they have seen action, there is a litany of small bits of work they need. I unboxed an A1 Mini and it's been like an epiphany. I've been printing almost nonstop. It's so much FUN. I just send from my phone and it just works . Everything has been nearly flawless until last night where half a batch of mini utility knife frames started to spaghetti, probably my fault for not fully cleaning the build plate in a bit. Beats the hell out of glue stick or blue tape, fussing with slicer params, babysitting the first layers, etc etc. Fuck that, gimme the cheat.
Bambu Lab A1 Mini: Likes itPrusa: Doesn’t like it
For me no, definitely not. The Core ONE is the first Prusa I would actually consider buying. But it's twice as expensive as a Bambu P1S and lacks various features that are optional on the prusa but included on the P1S. Like air filtering, the chamber cam (I know it's bad but good enough for me). And their alternative for the AMS (they call it the MMU) is way less sophisticated, it doesn't do full roll retraction or include a drybox for example. Finally, I have more faith in injection-molded parts than 3D printed ones. They're smoother, more precise, more solid. Now the extendibility is a big feature but it's not something I would use. I want a printer that I can unpack and go and have minimal maintenance and tinkering on. My hobby is about printing things, the printer itself is not my hobby. It's a tool and it should just work. So no, so far Bambu is and remains the the go-to brand for me. I have a P1S + AMS and also an A1 Mini, I think it's amazing how much value you get for your money at 180 euro. I actually use the A1 Mini more lately when I have something small to print due to the easily exchangable hotend (I often print small high-detail stuff on it with the 0,2mm nozzle). And it's a lot quieter than the P1S. And like others mentioned, Prusa is becoming a lot less open source. In the video he mentioned it is because of the Chinese clones which makes some sense but still...
Bambu Lab A1 Mini: Doesn’t like itPrusa: Likes it
My 3d printing journey seems to have ended with a Prusa Mini. Really solid and well engineered device, and it's delightful that Prusa acknowledge the open-source hardware and software they depended on to build their company. BambooLab... well it is a nice machine, and they have definitely advanced the the field with input shaping. But this machine is pretty much a Prusa Mini with linear rails, and I'd bet there is open-source in their firmware and slicer, but there's no way to find out because their business model is to give nothing back to the ecosystem they have leveraged. That leaves a bad taste for me, but I'm sure many people will be quite happy to ignore such esoteric concerns and happily lock themselves in. Until BambooLab have a bad financial quarter. Then the optional cloud integration will become mandatory with a subscription, and the spool detection system will start reject non-BambooLab filament. Doctorow has struck a chord with his distillation of enshittification, and you are right on the money raising it here. (Meanwhile Prusa has just released input shaping for the Mini.)
Bambu Lab A1 Mini: Likes itPrusa: Likes it
I have a Prusa i3 MK3S+, used it for years, a recent Prusa XL, a Bambu X1C and a Bambu A1 mini. I would pick a Bambu any day, except if you need large prints and need the XL's area/volume. Otherwise the Bambu printers are quite simply better on every possible metric.