The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Desktops and mini PCs

Atari ST vs Commodore Amiga

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Atari STCommodore Amiga
Owners with an opinion2286
Positive verdicts82% of 1788% of 75
Positive/negative since 20247/245/7
Happy after 3+ years14
Longest happy owner6 yrs34 yrs
Praised forperformance and displayperformance and design
Criticized forcomfort and valuereliability and ease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Atari ST: Likes itCommodore Amiga: Doesn’t like it
The Atari ST (for me, a 520 ST+) filled the gap between entertainment-centric home computers (Commodore C64) and PCs that could run Linux (some no-name with Intel i486DX-33), you could program it in so many languages (ST Basic, GFA Basic, Pascal, Modula-2, C, Forth etc.). With a dream black/white monitor, this was a wonderful machine to improve one's programming skills on with structured programming and to do systems programming (TOS/GEM) on - it was the monitor and the available range of compilers that made me want an ST ASAP. (At the same time, the Amiga had more powerful graphics hardware, but was very slow if you did not have a harddrive and "Kickstart ROMs", as it originally required two floppy disks to start up, not just one. The Amiga had a sophisticated OS but I always felt it was too demanding for the hardware it was running on.)
Atari ST: Likes itCommodore Amiga: Doesn’t like it
All excellent points. It does seem to me that Atari did very well with the use of COTS hardware and software to get a usable machine out at such a low price. It was more usable than the Amiga at base spec (512kB RAM, 1 floppy) because the OS in ROM meant much less disk swapping. But it did need both a lot more upgrades and expansions as time went on, as you point out, correctly IMHO. Secondly, I think Atari should have adopted PC standards as they appeared and settled: PS/2 ports, VGA and SVGA monitors and display modes, Baby AT motherboards, SIMM slots, IDE connectors, ISA slots and so on. Apple successfully adopted a lot of this stuff, so classic Macs had standard RAM slots, and the lower-end ones had IDE drives, and so on. Things like PCI (1992), ATX motherboards and USB (1995) came along too late.
Atari ST: Likes itCommodore Amiga: Doesn’t like it
Built-in MIDI and the excellent 100Hz monochrome screen were very strong selling points for the ST back then, for different niches of the market. Especially given the strong audio capabilities of the Amiga, including a MIDI interface should have been a no-brainer for Commodore to position it in the music production industry. On the other end of the market, the always slightly flickering 1081/1084 color monitor made the Amiga not very suitable for an 8 hour office job.
Atari ST: Doesn’t like itCommodore Amiga: Likes it
Ok, the Atari ST may have been cheaper than the Amiga 500, but to make music with it, you had to connect a MIDI keyboard/synthesizer/etc., whereas with the Amiga you could get by just with its built-in capabilities. This is true for the original STs, apparently the "STE" models released in 1989 also had the ability to play sampled audio, but I don't know if that was ever used as intensively as on the Amiga...
Atari ST: Likes itCommodore Amiga: Likes it
It's good to hear that Amiga users are finally getting their act together and doing the open source thing after years of fighting over who was going to make a few pennies off the dated corpse of AmigaOS. In the meantime, your tone is inappropriate for a post about an open source volunteer run project. And, no, the original title was not inaccurate or misleading. EmuTOS runs on Amigas and works fine on them. That you have some chip on your shoulder that someone might accidentally run it instead of AmigaOS (?! as if) is your own concern. Finally, as for TOS being some woefully inferior garbage product that AmigaOS dwarfs in its inelegancy is ridiculous. It's fairer to say that both are products of an early 80s mindset just in different ways. Yes, AmigaOS has proper multitasking. But it also had no memory protection for a long time (ever?), and from I remember doesn't use the 68k's TRAP syscall mechanism to perfom syscalls. It had no real standard GUI toolkit to start. It had some real sexy stuff, but also some missing stuff. TOS/GEM was not multitasking, and was built to run things single process apart from the cooperative multitasking in desk accessories; but GEM explicitly has APIs designed for a multitasking environment and was built to do so later . Interprocess mailboxes and events. Concepts of process/workstation handles, etc. Hooks that later revisions to the OS built on. Why didn't they do it right away? Because at that point, on an 8mhz 68000 with 512kB of RAM this…
Atari ST: Likes itCommodore Amiga: Likes it
The Amiga 1200 was arguably the last and best of the golden era "console computers", (meaning all-in-ones with the CPU inside the keyboard and could display on a standard analog TV). This style of home computer largely reigned the consumer market between 1980 and 1990, beginning with 8-bit machines like the Commodore 64, Atari 400/800 and Apple II, evolving to 16-bit with the Amiga 500 and Atari 1040STE and ending with the 32-bit Amiga 1200. The Amiga 1200 was based on a Motorola 68020, had a hardware-based bit blitter and could display 320x240 in 256 colors, basically the holy grail of analog gaming graphics modes. It was the only widely distributed home computer capable of faithfully emulating the vast majority of 1980-90 dedicated arcade machines with few compromises. I have all the machines mentioned above in pristine working condition and still enjoy playing around with them. It was a special era in computer history because every platform had its own unique hardware and operating system providing different capabilities and trade-offs. This gives each platform an unmistakable (and strongly-opinionated) 'personality'.
Atari ST: NeutralCommodore Amiga: Neutral
> Bitplane graphics Fun fact regarding bitplane: a friend of mine realized that he could use only 16 colors instead of 32, have all colors from, say, 0 to 15 be black, then clear the whole screen by zero'ing only the first bitplane (so effectively only blitting one-fifth of what would typically need to be blitted in case you wanted to clear the whole screen between two frames). Problem is: running the Amiga in 16 colors mode (instead of 32) was faster than using that trick in 32 colors mode. However ... That trick worked on the Atari ST. It was a very fast way to clear the whole screen. But as the Atari ST only had 4 bitplanes to start with, then you'd end up with only 8 usable colors if you used that trick. We're talking decades ago, but I'm pretty sure I remember this correctly (as in: we actually tried and timed all this on both the Amiga and the Atari ST back in the days). > I wonder how hard it is for people who were not old enough back then to properly place these machines in their historical context. Yup, what an era. At least I've got my Raspberry Pis today.
Atari ST: Likes itCommodore Amiga: Likes it
The computers I own are from the 60s onward. The 70s and after 2005 (somewhat) are the most unreliable. All my 60s, 80s, 90s systems still work provided they are not PCs. The PCs from the 80s still work, but 90s and upward are quite hit or miss; HP servers, which can be seen as PCs I guess still work but desktops and laptops are broken. My favorites are msx-2(+), msx turbo r, atari st, Amiga and Sun E450 and UltraSPARC stations. They all seem unbreakable. Or maybe I am just lucky; I never had leaky capacitor issues yet that plagues many 80s ones. The one from the 60s is, obviously, over 50 years now but although called a computer, it cannot win consistently at tic-tac-toe as it is, as the memory Is wired and a few bytes; at least the 70s and 80s ones are usable somewhat (at least for games).