The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Phones

Asus Zenfone vs Google Pixel

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Asus Zenfone.

Asus ZenfoneGoogle Pixel
Owners with an opinion351968
Positive verdicts77% of 3056% of 1602
Positive/negative since 20248/5503/387
Happy after 3+ years254
Longest happy owner6 yrs10 yrs
Praised forportability and performancereliability and performance
Criticized forsoftware and batterysoftware and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Asus Zenfone: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
I bought another zenphone 9 (such a good phone... nothing comes close 4 years later for me) with the hopes of putting lineageOS on and trying to keep it up to date with security updates. I didn't realize that ASUS disabled their bootloader unlock service API. I ran a similar process to try anytime and everything to own my own device. My current (bad) idea is to run a root exploit at each boot and then patch known vulns at runtime... at least until the moto phones with grapheneOS come out. I have a recent pixel with grapheneOS but i can bring myself to use it.
Asus Zenfone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
Not only is it not a very small phone, I can't even properly type this message one handed. It's also not a good phone which I regret purchasing. Zenphones until the 10 had easy to unlock bootloaders, leading to long in official support by the community. However with the 10 ASUS stopped that tool and they've been lying ever since that they're still working on it. My zenfone is now on its final major android update, the rather minor android 15 version, and I've only got two years of security updates left until I need to look for a new phone. That's one thousand euros for barely four years of software support, it's such a disappointment. That aside the camera is lackluster, it's auto whitebalance is horrific, turning the same snowy scene into a sunset or illuminated by fluorescent light depending on the phase of the moon and it's sampling questionable making images much more blurry in a surreal way. But the optical stabilisation is seriously impressive. Overall I preferred the pixel 4a's images though. A smaller phone and my zenfone's predecessor. At least I get to just plug it into my stereo thanks to the 3.5mm jack though.
Asus Zenfone: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
What cempler said. I tried the dongle approach when the jack in my pixel 4a was failing but found I didn't like it. Having the cable go out the bottom in the center is a terrible place for me, as I rest my phone on my outstretched pinky. The zenfone ticked all boxes on paper and in reviews. Great chipset, solid build, a form factor fitting my tiny hands(though in retrospect it's so heavy that my pinky hurts after a couple hours of reading). And a headphone jack which I use to plug my phone in my stereo and my Sennheiser headphones. Really the jack is the primary reason I got this phone. Coupled by the fact that until now all zenfones had a hassle boot loader unlock and a decent rom community it really was the best choice on paper. God damn it Asus, I wasn't aware they're that dodgy :/
Asus Zenfone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
for me even pixel 5 was ok (mini is even better but let's say apple is another story). Now we have only zenfone 10, that is a bit taller so again not that nice and s23 that is +- the size of p5 but still something felt off. Iphone 13 mini was super nice to hold, super light. I would have got one if not lightning. All my devices use usb-c, it would be a downgrade to use lightning
Asus Zenfone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
i guess flip phones are the new small. once they become more affordable. my pixel 3 died after 4 years so i upgraded to a used pixel 5 which was the last small-ish pixel. very surprised with the battery. rarely end the day less than 75% - and it's smaller than the not small (imo) zenfone 10.
Asus Zenfone: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
I don't buy it. Pixel 5 did have a kinda metallic-plastiky back (sort of plastic around wireless c, but it was impossible to spot the area with naked eye), it looked nice. You also can see the zenfone 10, it's some sort of plastic, but super nice to the touch. Having glass back is not mandatory for a wireless charging phone, I think companies do this to make more profit on repairs longterm
Asus Zenfone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
How can they claim that it's "ultra compact"? That's just plain misleading advertising. Heck, it's bigger than my current Pixel 3a, which is already a bit too large for my comfort.
Asus Zenfone: Likes itGoogle Pixel: Likes it
Had one of the Intel Zenhones, very neat hefty device. If the Pixel 6 wasn't literally my favorite phone of all time, the built in call screening alone is priceless, I'd consider this.
Asus Zenfone: Doesn’t like itGoogle Pixel: Doesn’t like it
List of smaller Android phones with decent specs: Pixel 5 - 144.7 x 70.4 x 8 mm Samsung S22 - 146 x 70.6 x 7.6 mm Zenfone 8 - 148 x 68.5 x 8.9 mm (could be higher thanks to narrower body) Xiaomi 12X - 152.7 x 69.9 x 8.2 mm Samsung S21 - 151.7 x 71.2 x 7.9 mm S22 has almost identical dimensions as Pixel 5, so there is your upgrade. Personally I find all of these overpriced for what I need, I would be perfectly fine with 4A specs with better battery, so can't justify to upgrading to some of these.