The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Consoles and handhelds

ASUS ROG Ally vs Valve Steam Deck

Hacker News owners lean toward the Valve Steam Deck.

ASUS ROG AllyValve Steam Deck
Owners with an opinion22700
Positive verdicts63% of 1983% of 623
Positive/negative since 20249/5271/67
Happy after 3+ years02
Longest happy owner1.5 yrs25 yrs
Praised forperformance and portabilityperformance and ease of use
Criticized forreliability and softwarereliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

ASUS ROG Ally: Recommends itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
I got an Xbox Ally X (with bazzite as Gabe intended) after enjoying the steam deck so much. I get it's not for everyone, but I wasn't playing games on my desktop due to life/kids/etc. The handheld is awesome for my personal case, I love casual games and use it on the couch/plane/bed. If you want a PC with a keyboard and mouse that works with everything, get a gaming laptop. If you want to pull out a game for 15 minutes, play, then hit sleep and come back later, a handheld is absolutely the best way to go.
ASUS ROG Ally: Doesn’t like itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
I have the Xbox Ally, Steam Deck, and original Ally. The original Ally software launch was a disaster. Unbelievable amount of bugs and overall terrible user experience. After 6+ months of updates it was decent. I figured, hey, maybe they figured it out in advance this time? So I pre-ordered an Xbox Ally. It is a complete disaster in terms of software. It took 90 minutes to setup and download initial updates on a Google Fiber connection. Things break constantly. The other day, I got a new error, "Something went wrong and your PIN isn't available." When I try to click anything, it just goes black. After 6 or 7 restarts, it randomly glitches out and takes me right to desktop without any PIN. It is just constant bullshit like this. The entire experience breaks over, and over, and over. I hate it so much. Back to Steam Deck.
ASUS ROG Ally: NeutralValve Steam Deck: Doesn’t like it
We already have a good sense of what SoC Nintendo will likely be going with for the Switch 2. Being so dismissive of the Switch shows the disconnect between what most gamers care about, and what some tech enthusiasts think gamers care about. The Switch 1 used a crappy mobile chip, sure, but it was able to run tons of games that no other Tegra device could have dreamed of running, due to the power of having a stable target for optimization, with sufficiently powerful APIs available, and a huge target market. The Switch 1 can do 90% of what a Steam Deck can, while using a fraction of the power, thickness, and cooling. With the Switch 2 almost certainly gaining DLSS, I fully expect the Switch 2 to run circles around the Steam Deck, even without a “high end chip”. It will be weaker on paper, but that won’t matter. I say this as someone who owns a PS5, a Switch OLED, an ROG Ally, and a fairly decent gaming PC. I briefly had an original Steam Deck, but the screen was atrocious. Most people I see talking about Steam Deck’s awesomeness seem to either have very little experience with a Switch, or just have a lot of disdain for Nintendo. Yes, having access to Steam games is cool… but hauling around a massive device with short battery life is not cool to most gamers, and neither is spending forever tweaking settings just to get something that’s marginally better than the Switch 1 can do out of the box. The Switch 1 is at the end of its life right now, but Nintendo is certainly prepari…
ASUS ROG Ally: Doesn’t like itValve Steam Deck: Neutral
The problem with 1080p and higher on mobile devices like that is that the chips available for these devices physically cannot give a good experience at that resolution. The main limitation is memory bandwidth. It works great at 720p. Anything higher and it starts to break down. Citation: I own a steam deck and an ROG Ally. The Ally has the best controller on the market but it's hamstrung by the screen simply having too many pixels. Well, that and Windows.
ASUS ROG Ally: Doesn’t like itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
Would've been cool if Asus had really tried to optimize the Ally around the Z1 with faster RAM, higher GPU clocks, and better battery life instead of offering the Z1 Extreme in an upsell. It's going for $400 now, which would've been real competition a year ago. Hard to recommend it now over the OLED Deck. Will be interesting to see AMD try this in consumer processors, with frame time graphs.
ASUS ROG Ally: Doesn’t like itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
Not for a small screen like the steam deck. LTT complained 1080p made things way too small on Asus ROG Ally handheld while also hurting performance.
ASUS ROG Ally: NeutralValve Steam Deck: Likes it
I don't play while outside the house for extended periods, so battery isn't a concern for me. I mostly just wanted to be able to play my games on the couch, whether that was using the Ally as a handheld or by being able to dock it to the TV. The biggest issue that keeps me from recommending it to anyone is that it is a windows 11 machine. That is both its strongest and weakest point. Turn it on for the first time, windows setup on a tiny screen with no physical mouse keyboard. And then there is messing with game graphics settings to eek out the performance you want. SD slot is complete garbage. Most likely a hardware issue that will not be able to be fixed. It stops reading cards and in some cases, destroys the card. It is fairly easy to upgrade the internal SSD though. ASUS has also been pretty quiet on graphics driver updates. As long as you are cool with that stuff, its an awesome machine. Steamdeck has more of a 'just works' kinda console feel and kinda outdated hardware wise. Lenovo Go images just leaked today.
ASUS ROG Ally: Doesn’t like itValve Steam Deck: Neutral
That's 7h in ideal circumstances, running light games with a low screen brightness. If you open a full AAA game and let the deck really start slurping power it will get like 1.5 hours at best in my experience. I can get 4 hours when playing emulated PS2 games, but around 1.5 playing something modern like The Outer Wilds on my steam deck. The ally is much less efficient with the same battery capacity. I've seen reports of like 40 minutes of battery life when running high power draw games.
ASUS ROG Ally: Likes itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
I'm looking to finally get off Windows for good. My experience with the SteamDeck started me, later I upgraded to a ROG Ally X for beefier performance but found Windows insufferable on a handheld, and installed SteamOS. I was blown away by the performance gains. A few months later I installed Kubuntu for the first time since 2013 or so, Steam shortly after, and while the desktop linux route is definitely more taxing (manually installing things like Mod Organizer 2 instead of Vortex, for instance, and all of that needing to run differently as opposed to Windows where it's all just .exe's) I've been absolutely blown away by the performance gains again. Mind you this machine is no slacker, it's a GE76 Raider from MSI, 3060 under the hood, but games just run smoother in Linux. And the alt-tab experience is untouchable, Fallout: New Vegas hates it and crashes, but everything more modern utterly doesn't care. I can alt-tab in and out, check messages, desktop composing works great no matter what game I'm playing, no more issues in modded games where the game completely locks the machine as Linux just doesn't seem to allow it, it's fantastic. I have a couple more things to figure, I need XBox authentication to work for Halo Infinite and Sea of Theives, among others, and I need to figure out some solutions for some ancient software I have to run, which will probably end up being a Windows 11 VM. But as for my daily driver OS, I am so excited to get off Windows once and for all.
ASUS ROG Ally: Likes itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
Because a lot of tech sucks lately? Everything now is just new kinds of ways to spy on people or the same old shit repackaged in a new format. I'm dying for some actual innovation. The only new product in tech I actually like lately is the Steam Deck and later, the Ally X. Making PC gaming mobile is incredible, and I guess you could say there's nothing revolutionary there, but I dunno, it's new at least and not flagrantly a free-at-use shitpile that's going to tell AdSense my resting heart rate. Edit: And I suppose relevant to this comment thread, a lot of new tech is just more ways to fuck with people at scale to generate revenue. Which also blows ass.
ASUS ROG Ally: Likes itValve Steam Deck: Likes it
To my knowledge the ROG Ally is more of a gaming laptop replacement. Only get it if you want to play online shooters where anti-cheats don't work reliably on Linux/Proton. Or if you want the absolute best resolution and graphics in portable format. For single player games and people who don't expect their portable gaming device to be 4k/240FPS SD is better in every way.