The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Watches and wearables

Apple Watch vs Oura Ring

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple Watch.

Apple WatchOura Ring
Owners with an opinion106966
Positive verdicts64% of 89462% of 53
Positive/negative since 2024296/22217/16
Happy after 3+ years313
Longest happy owner10 yrs7 yrs
Praised forease of use and performanceperformance and ease of use
Criticized forbattery and reliabilityreliability and value
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Watch: Likes itOura Ring: Doesn’t like it
I was an early adopter of Oura, and have recently stopped wearing it. I've reverted to the Apple Watch & EightSleep for all of the tracking I could ever need. I found the experience with Oura to be overly optimistic numbers wise, as well as borderline dark patterns in the app to drive my anxiety around getting good scores.
Apple Watch: NeutralOura Ring: Doesn’t like it
Crazy how Apple added sleep tracking to their watch 17 months ago and has gotten results roughly equivalent to Fitbit who has tracking sleep for over a decade. And my Oura 2 which was arguably one of the most accurate sleep trackers when it came out in 2019 looks quite mediocre now.
Apple Watch: NeutralOura Ring: Doesn’t like it
Are there really any concrete advantages to the Oura ring over something like the Apple Watch? I used to own an Oura ring, but I returned it after I found basically no difference between ring's data and the watch with an app like Training Today. Maybe I just wasn't looking at the right stuff, though?
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itOura Ring: Likes it
So I started my journey with the Apple Watch and used a variety of apps, but I just didn't like the results and more often than not questioned the accuracy. There were always some discrepancies, moments where I knew I was awake but the app was saying I was asleep or vice versa. Plus, sleeping with a watch isn't the most comfortable way I'd say. I then "upgraded" to the Oura gen3 and so far I've been very happy with it, but I'm still in the free phase of the subscription. I'm not a fan of this new model and I'm still unsure if I'll continue paying once my time is up or move on and sell the ring. I do like the data points I'm getting, I like seeing the progress I've made to better my sleep and I like the almost real time prediction (based on things like temperature changes I can see if I'll be sick the next day). Was also very interesting to look at the data during the time I had covid. I guess once that first bill comes in, I'll have to reevaluate how important this is to me. You know what they say, less netflix/starbucks === buy a home.
Switched from the Apple Watch to the Oura RingOura Ring: Likes it
Google home, nest thermostat, Alexa, roomba, Apple Watch, iPad. GHome consistently gets worse voice recognition or usability. Nest has many notifications to enable eco modes making me uncomfortable in own home. Alexa terrible voice recognition. Roomba kept getting stuck, errors. Apple Watch useless versus oura ring even if steps aren’t as accurate. iPad usage not worth the cost. Either get a laptop full featured or a small tv and android shield box.
Switched from the Apple Watch to the Oura RingOura Ring: Recommends it
In terms of wearables, it's quite unobtrusive because it's literally just a ring. There is no display to become distracted with. The inside of the ring will glow when it's taking measurements (red for blood oxygen, green for heart rate) so that might surprise you when the lights are out, but that's about the extent of how "intrusive" it is. The battery life is very good, I typically get several days to a single charge, which is far better than the Apple Watch. But most importantly it's comfortable to wear during sleep - indeed it takes the majority of its measurements only while you're sleeping. YMMV but there's no way I can wear an Apple Watch to sleep, while the Oura ring works perfectly. I've worn the last two generations of Oura ring and would definitely recommend.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itOura Ring: Doesn’t like it
A lot of tech is overfit to the product manager role in tech companies. One of the side effects of living in a bubble. My Apple Watch is set up by default to assume any 15-minute walk is a "workout" and interrupt me to ask if I wanted to record it. No, I'm just going to the store, what is this "workout" nonsense. My Oura Ring was worse, it would assume any walk duration is noteworthy and my timeline would be a jumbled mess of "workouts". But these would be reasonable assumptions for a mostly sedentary office worker living in the suburbs. I remember when a Google feature was announced long ago, some of the headlining features was plane ticket support and currency conversion. The average American gets on a plane once a year, to a place where they accept American dollars, and wouldn't ever care about these features. But these are important if you're in your 30s and travel is an important part of your life for either business or vacations.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itOura Ring: Doesn’t like it
Sure, the statistical method matters, but I think it's missing the forest for the tree. Any metric will differ: bpm, sleep phases, body temp, etc. Because those devices are not super accurate, and the context you wear them in doesn't allow them to be anyway. If you were to do a respiratory polygraph with proper medical equipment you'll find different values from your Apple Watch or Oura ring for the times you wake up. But you'll also notice a gap between getting the values at home and in a hospital, because in the hospital the nurses will check your equipment setup. Those devices are great to give you a big picture, follow general trends and understand your own body. That's it.
Apple Watch: NeutralOura Ring: Neutral
I quit using Oura ring and it took almost two years until I didn’t have that feeling in my finger that something was missing. With Apple Watch it took half year. Makes me wonder maybe brain adapts faster when you add something, and it takes longer to adapt for loss? Also maybe finger took longer time as there are more nerves there?
Apple Watch: Likes itOura Ring: Likes it
Yep, the performance of the Apple watch is nothing but stunning especially given their medical grade ECGfeature. The (lack) progress of the others is disappointed. The Oura3 numbers are pretty impressive and at 3-5 days of battery life gives it an edge over the Apple Watch. I prefer ambient devices that lack screens so it is pretty good in that sense too.
Apple Watch: Likes itOura Ring: Likes it
Not entirely true. My wife has O2 respiratory efficiency problems, and uses both an Apple watch and an Oura ring for sleep monitoring and charts O2 patterns daily. So at least some people care intensely. As to sentence two, it was exactly the O2 feature that prompted my wife to get the watch. No O2 monitoring, no sale. If O2 monitoring went away on her current watch, the watch would be up on E-Bay, most likely, as she doesn't find anything else about it that compelling. In my case, the compelling feature for me is exercise tracking and heart-rate monitoring. This is yet another case where it is easy to fall into the "product manager trap" -- that is: designing for "most people". The trap is to de-feature things where "most people" have only modest engagement, but a few (likely your most evangelical customers) care intensely about that feature. Don't fall into that trap. The goal is to create a feature collection of "the one thing" that each segment cares intensely about, not to create a basket of meh features that everyone finds meh.
Apple Watch: Recommends itOura Ring: Recommends it
Firstly, I’d like to say congratulations on your success in family and business! I can only offer some “bio-hacks” (but really they’re key science-backed natural health habits) to master to optimize the mental well-being of humans. As they say, health is wealth. First thing: sleep well. Lack of good quality sleep is known to drive up anxiety, depression, cravings, forgetfulness, irritability, and countless other negative things. It also (perhaps ironically) leaves us feeling empty and constantly unsatisfied. I’d recommend getting a good sleep tracker (Apple Watch or Oura Ring), and to be diligent about treating your 8ish hours of sleep a night as sacred—though not to become too anal about. It’s important for your energy and spiritual bank account. Moving on… Go on a walk every morning in the AM for 30-60 minutes. It’s been demonstrated to have great positive effects on your mood, not to mention your learning ability. I get high from long walks. Maybe it’s due to the fact that I feel that I’m in control of my life when I can be at peace doing “nothing productive” for an hour a day while walking on sunshine, especially before I do any work. On that note, flex your abs when you walk, and walk strong and proud as the godly creator that you are. IMHO if one cannot make time to walk or exercise or otherwise do good things for oneself, then one is enslaved. Walk periodically throughout the day and look into the distance. For every ~45 minutes of work, we should ideally get up to wal…