The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Watches and wearables

Apple Watch vs Fitbit

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Apple WatchFitbit
Owners with an opinion1069199
Positive verdicts64% of 89452% of 160
Positive/negative since 2024296/22233/38
Happy after 3+ years315
Longest happy owner10 yrs10 yrs
Praised forease of use and performanceease of use and battery
Criticized forbattery and reliabilityreliability and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itFitbit: Likes it
I really just want an Apple version of the new Fitbit Air. I had an Apple Watch for five years. Battery didn't even last a day. I realized generally I have my phone or laptop with me all the time anyway, I don't need a watch with weather or app widgets. So in June I bought the fitbit air and it's great. Battery life lasts about 6-7 days. No distracting screen. MUCH more comfortable to sleep with since it has no buttons and a smaller form factor. If Apple made their own version of the Air but with Apple Pay I would switch back over in a heartbeat.
Apple Watch: NeutralFitbit: Likes it
I had an Apple Watch Series 6 for about five years and the battery degraded to the point it needed just about two charges a day. Then I found out about the new Fitbit Air in June and picked one up. Advertised battery life is 7 days; I tend to get closer to 6. It does the sleep/activity tracking I want (though not quite as good as the AW if I'm honest). The extra benefit is I've cut out smartwatch features from my wrist. I got tired of having notifications on a watch and rarely needed special apps or anything either. I really only used the AW for telling time, date, temp/weather conditions, and payments; but most of the time I have my phone or I'm near a computer anyway.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itFitbit: Likes it
Apple is free to do as many interoperable components or integrated products as they please. The DMA doesn't define ANY such restriction. What they CAN'T do is maintain an environment where their products cannot be met with fair competition by other players, by intentionally giving advantages in the ecosystem only to their own brands. Apple might not dominate the market for fitness trackers above 150USD today if they wouldn't have prevented others to achieve the same interoperability with their iOS ecosystem. Apples featureset for wellness tracking was not competitive, neither in function nor in price. Fitbit and Garmin were better in doing that task, but they were not able to display message notifications, apps, etc. because the required interfaces in iOS were only available to Apple's Watch. Maybe Apple would have beaten them in 2nd Gen, maybe competitors would have followed with equally tight iOS-interoperability in 2nd Gen. Maybe Apple Watch would nonetheless be the leading Smartwatch in the market today. Or maybe it would be e.g. the Moto360 (google it) just due to Apple's "virtue of sucking" and insistence of doing rectangular watches. We don't know, because none of the other players are able to compete on fair terms with Apple in this segment until today. And today Apple has such a leap-start that it's questionable whether this can still be rectified.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itFitbit: Neutral
I'm so stoked. Pebble was the only smart watch that I actually liked and used. My apple watch just sits on a shelf. My fitbit I only wear when sleeping. My pebble unfortunately broke, but it also sits on a shelf as I haven't been able to admit to myself that I'd never get around to repairing it.
Apple Watch: Likes itFitbit: Neutral
I developed a proof of concept for a Garmin Watch (I forget which model, this was 6 years ago roughly), and it was interesting, they have their own programming language called MonkeyC, it wasn't complicated to get into, and I had a demo in under a week or two. I based my code off existing sample code, and made it do what was needed for demo purposes. Personally I have owned a Fitbit Ionic, and now an Apple Watch. I'm not sure if I'll ever take the plunge towards a Garmin watch, I mainly enjoy the benefits of the Apple Watch integrating into my iPhone nicely (notifications and GPS nudging come to mind).
Apple Watch: Likes itFitbit: Neutral
Yes, thanks for asking. Continous Glucose Monitors (CGM). That used to be a diabetic-only problem until Abbott, Dexcom,and other vendors expanded their markets beyond diagnosed diabetics into pre-diabetes markets and exercise, health, and well-being applications like: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10635370/ and: https://www.levelshealth.com/ This has exploded beyond the hundred years of ketogenic research and as research on glycemic variability in mental health has grown. My current kit includes an Apple Watch series 9 and an iPhone SE. Prior to that it was Google Pixel and a Fitbit Sense, though direct BTLE->Watch was not an option in that generation. I have two complications: Abbott Freestyle Libre 3 and Dexcom G7. Continuous Glucose Monitors (CGM). The Dexcom is entirely proprietary. The Abbott is accomplished via a series of 3rd party hacks: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YqUZjXo5VXY I'd say open source, but I'm not certain that every link in the chain is open source. I've run many generations of various open source tools on Android and iPhone since no vendor ships a complete end-to-end solution that is perfect. Nightscout and watchdrip are two open source examples: https://nightscout.github.io/ https://watchdrip.org/ When G7 originally shipped last year, sensor data left the sensor and used the iPhone as a proxy-to-cloud storage, as has become the default mode across many IoT devices because it was easy, obvious, despite the unintended consequen…
Apple Watch: NeutralFitbit: Likes it
Crazy how Apple added sleep tracking to their watch 17 months ago and has gotten results roughly equivalent to Fitbit who has tracking sleep for over a decade. And my Oura 2 which was arguably one of the most accurate sleep trackers when it came out in 2019 looks quite mediocre now.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itFitbit: Likes it
All of these look important to me, but I've been particularly frustrated recently by the smartwatch issue. I've been a Fitbit user for several years and briefly tried an Apple Watch before returning it and resume Fitbit use— I had a few issues with the Apple Watch, most notably around battery life. But that brief experience showed me really starkly how much Apple is able to lock out third parties from doing things that their own stuff can do trivially by hooking right into private operating system APIs: - Apple Watch can directly use your credit cards without needing to separately add them to Fitbit/Google Pay. - Apple Watch can "find my" your phone, whereas Fitbit's version of this is limited to just making it beep, and even that only works if the phone is running the Fitbit app in the background (which it often isn't). - Apple Watch can stream data to the phone all the time, whereas Fitbit relies on the app being opened, meaning your morning sleep data isn't available immediately since opening the app (to look at it) just enables it to begin transferring. - Apple Watch can unlock itself when your phone unlocks. - Apple Watch gets much richer notification integration. And yeah, you can argue that all of this is optional "extra" stuff that is just Apple's prerogative to take advantage of as the platform holder, and maybe that's so to some degree... but these little things do add up. Particularly when Apple doesn't even have a device that competes with Fitbit, it feels unfai…
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itFitbit: Likes it
Love the Apple Watch. But yeah battery is huge drag to the otherwise lovely experience. It's barely enough to start with. Now after three years, at 79% of original capacity, it's become annoying. I actually cannot think of a watchOS function that can't be done in monocrhome. I miss my old Fitbit which could be charged during a shower before lasting almost a week.
Apple Watch: NeutralFitbit: Likes it
This is unfortunate, but expected. I used a Fitbit Charge for the past seven-plus years. I built an app, SyncFit, to sync to Apple Health. I switched to Apple Watch last year because it was clear Google had removed features in the latest Fitbit devices to sell more Android Watch devices.
Apple Watch: Likes itFitbit: Doesn’t like it
> I'm a tile user, and indeed they seem a bit unreliable. I got one for my wife to keep in a known location because she misplaces her phone, and it works to signal the phone maybe 4 out of 5 times. Mobile is hard. Google's Find My Phone fails to wake up my pixel 7 about half the time I used it, even if I am staring at the phone. Sometimes the alert goes off half an hour later. My fitbit's "find your phone" feature also works less than half the time. I am genuinely surprised that my wife's apple watch can locate her phone every time she asks it to.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itFitbit: Likes it
I'm delighted with my Fitbit Charge 5. Costs a fraction of the Apple Watch, don't need to buy into the Apple Ecosystem to make it useful. Tracks my sleep and fitness shockingly well. The official app is surprisingly good, and there's an API that works pretty well and has endpoints for most if not all the data. That said, I'm a casual exerciser, not a proper hardcore sportsperson. For those I'd say avoid a lifestyle device like the Apple watch or Fitbit watches - it feels like Garmin supports that niche better.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itFitbit: Likes it
Currently Garmin, Fitbit and Whoop have much more advanced health features than the Apple watch. I agree, its a big downfall of the Apple watch IMO.
Apple Watch: NeutralFitbit: Likes it
What is a good lightweight 24/7 heart rate and sleep tracker that's not a Fitbit? I have an Apple Watch but the Fitbit's sleep tracking is way better and I keep it on for days (whereas I charge my Apple Watch overnight). I am super happy with my Fitbit but given Google I assume it will be "sunset" within a year or two so I want to switch early.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itFitbit: Neutral
I used to wear a Fitbit religiously, for about 2 years. I considered it my "fat band" and while it kept me aware that i should walk more and exercise, I can't say it did wonders for me. Was it useful? Sure -- it made me want to walk more. And yeah, I lost some weight. But after a while, it just gets annoying. In general, I can't wear watches, bands, or anything like that. After a while, my wrist starts to turn red and break out in hives. I've tried all different brands and its the same result. My girlfriend even gave me her Apple Watch when she switched to another watch and that too, made me break out in a rash after just a week or two of wearing it. So aside from forgetting to wear my Apple watch, it just causes me rashes. I'd say it is preference.. some people like them, some don't.
Switched from the Fitbit to the Apple WatchApple Watch: Likes it
>> My friend's Fitbit works way better than my Apple watch. That's odd because I've used both, along with a bunch other wearables (e.g. Whoop), and I wouldn't give up my Apple Watch for anything. Massively useful, can take calls, make payments, stream music from my Apple playlists, read and reply to messages, and a ton of other things.