The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Watches and wearables

Apple Watch vs Casio G-Shock

Hacker News owners lean toward the Casio G-Shock.

Apple WatchCasio G-Shock
Owners with an opinion106993
Positive verdicts64% of 89493% of 87
Positive/negative since 2024296/22243/3
Happy after 3+ years3111
Longest happy owner10 yrs20 yrs
Praised forease of use and performancereliability and durability
Criticized forbattery and reliabilitydisplay
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Watch: NeutralCasio G-Shock: Likes it
Same here. I wore the Apple Watch for about 6 years. It helped me get excited about exercising and swimming on the daily, but the notifications and "focus modes" made it feel like a chore. I switched to the GShock GW-5000 and never looked back.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itCasio G-Shock: Likes it
After 3 attempts at an Apple Watch over the years, I finally had the experience that pushed me over the edge and I sold my Apple Watch 10 for a Coros APEX 4 - a device that has real battery life and a quality build, so no more worrying about my activity tracker dying during a half marathon, no more charging a device 2-3 times during an overnight backpacking trip and no more worrying about every bump and scrape. Apple has truly dropped the ball with their Watch line, with their only solution to the dismal battery life for *active* people being spend another $400 for a few extra hours of battery . No thanks. I'm quite happy with my Coros upgrade. It's really shown me that Apple Watches are a general catch all with feature bloat that don't do anything super well for serious activity seekers, yet its main requirement is the user be tethered to a charger every damn day - sometimes multiple times. That being said though, once this Coros kicks the bucket, I will being giving a lot of thought into whether I will be purchasing another activity tracker. Even with this new device that lasts 2~ weeks on a charge, I find myself missing the simplicity of my Casio G-Shock - a device that simply works . My phone still functions as a great activity tracker for biking, running and brief hikes, but lacks the real battery life needed for backpacking - which is my only holdout.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itCasio G-Shock: Likes it
I recently stopped wearing my Apple Watch and started wearing my G-Shock. I’ve noticed I live more in the present without constant notifications. I stopped trying to fill rings and started listening to my body. The Apple Watch is cool, but IMO it’s a bit of a novelty.
Switched from the Apple Watch to the Casio G-ShockCasio G-Shock: Likes it
Moved from my ultra 2, to a simply casio gshock 5601u, could not be happier, I am so sick and tired of all the notifications, stats, blah blah blah following me all over, from my macbook, iphone, that I just don't need it on my watch as well. I just don't care anymore about tracking everything and uploading to strava, or whever, and this comes from someone that, have over 100k km's logged on strava. I know the vast majority of people love it, and I love stats as well, but all the connected devices, is just getting too much, I am activily trying to go more simple, offline, outside of work.
Switched from the Apple Watch to the Casio G-ShockCasio G-Shock: Likes it
I own a GW-M5610U G-Shock. It's the bread and butter G-Shock, which comes with solar, radio control, and the old-school red bezel. No Bluetooth, no tracking, no connectivity. Like many people I know, I went from Apple Watch to a "dumb" Casio, as an escape from the attention grabbing information gateway on my wrist. It was surprisingly easy to leave smart and tracking features behind. Having a dumb watch also enables me to leave my smartphone in the backpack and checking the time whithout seeing how many messages I got. And since I don't have to charge my watch and it's virtually indestructible, I can forget about it unless I want to know the time, start a timer, set an alarm etc. I feel like this was the single most important move to switch from devices which are controlling me, back to me controlling my devices.
Switched from the Apple Watch to the Casio G-ShockCasio G-Shock: Likes it
“Alexa, set timer to x mins…” while holding a dead chicken in both hands. Works every time. And has no purchases or online services configures but Spotify and TuneIn radio. I ditched my Apple Watch for a 100$ Casio g-shock that self charges and self sets time. Cheap exercise band when training. More disconnect from always-on and big tech toxicity. Don’t see me coming back
Apple Watch: Likes itCasio G-Shock: Likes it
> all high end watches are mechanical. No, most high end male jewelry are mechanical watches (and much of women-oriented jewelry as well). High end watches are such a solved problem we don't even talk about them anymore. Either the G-shock, the Garmin watches, or the Apple Watch run circles around mechanical watches in terms of functionality with each satisfying a different niche (100% self-contained, long lived smart functionality, glance-oriented integration with full-stack personal tech ecosystem).
Apple Watch: Likes itCasio G-Shock: Likes it
What else is there in the 35-hour battery life/$300 range? Apple Watch SE starts at $249 and frequently goes on sale at $199. A regular Apple Watch of a previous generation can be bought at $299. Last-generation Apple Watch is $399 but is sold at $329 frequently. For people who have iPhones it's a no-brainer. I love G-Shocks and I hope this model will get down to more reasonable $170-180 range.