The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Watches and wearables

Apple Watch vs Casio F-91W

Hacker News owners lean toward the Casio F-91W.

Apple WatchCasio F-91W
Owners with an opinion106961
Positive verdicts64% of 89477% of 57
Positive/negative since 2024296/22227/11
Happy after 3+ years311
Longest happy owner10 yrs14 yrs
Praised forease of use and performancereliability and value
Criticized forbattery and reliabilitydurability and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itCasio F-91W: Likes it
I've been rocking out a Casio F-91W (Retails new for $23) for about 3 months now - And all the annoyance I had with with my Apple Watch Ultra (16 hour battery, constant annoyance to upgrade, endless and useless notifications) - is gone. The CR2016 battery last 5+ YEARS , replacements are < $2. Watch has everything I ever cared about - Date, Time, Alarms, Light, Stopwatch, water resistance. And, I don't think I've once missed having the big annoying clunker of a watch.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itCasio F-91W: Likes it
Yeah I sold my apple watch after about 6 months and got a good old F-91W instead. The most useful thing about it for me was having an animated memoji unicorn on my wrist to amuse people. Wasn’t really worth the trouble of charging it every night. I just want to know what time it is.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itCasio F-91W: Recommends it
For practical purposes they are better in every way Mostly agree, except you have to take the Apple Watch every single day for maintenance (charging). You can buy a Casio F-91W for $20 and go 7-10 years before you have to take off your wrist for a battery change. If you simply want to tell time, digital watches, quartz watches, and arguably mechanical watches beat smart watches.
Apple Watch: Doesn’t like itCasio F-91W: Likes it
Meh. Stopped wearing my S9 in May. Not sure why I bought it. Think AW wore off here finally. It’s a nice toy but useless for me (even cycling / hiking etc). I take an F91W when I go hiking as it doesn’t need charging.
Switched from the Apple Watch to the Casio F-91WCasio F-91W: Likes it
went back to a casio f91w. battery last 7 years, can buy 200 for the price of one apple watch se and no privacy issue. Just get a polar h10 to monitor sport activity and honestly it's as good or better, having to charge it everyday is painfull.