The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

Apple Vision Pro vs Valve Index

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple Vision Pro.

Apple Vision ProValve Index
Owners with an opinion346128
Positive verdicts62% of 30556% of 102
Positive/negative since 2024183/11424/13
Happy after 3+ years00
Longest happy owner2 yrs0.5 yrs
Praised fordisplay and performanceperformance and comfort
Criticized forcomfort and valueease of use and display
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Vision Pro: Likes itValve Index: Neutral
This isn't true. It's more that the Vision Pro deliberately prioritized certain things that Meta or Vive or Valve or Sony have not: geometrically stable pass through, wide library of popular 3D movies via AppleTV and Disney+, high resolution immersive environments, seamless keyboard/mouse/trackpad migration between PC and native apps, strong iOS/iPadOS ecosystem integration, high fps / low latency wireless ultra-wide virtual displays for the Mac, etc. In some ways it focuses on what the Oculus Go was trying to do but was underpowered to really do it. It's meant to replace other iOS devices for general productivity and entertainment, and to complement a Mac. It's not focused on VR gaming though it can do that. I have a Oculus Rift dev kit, Ovulus Go, Quest , Quest 2, Valve Index, PSVR2. The AVP is much better of an experience on almost every level but three: too much motion blur when moving your head (this isn't bad when watching high fps video), lack of controller support, not so great hand tracking (which the Quest had to do well due to lack of eye tracking). The controller support should be fixed with the Sony PSVR2 partnership. Motion blur and hand tracking I suspect will be software fixed as they evolve to prioritize active fitness with the AVP.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
> By the way, have you actually tried it? Yes (albeit not at an Apple Store). For $3,500 it's not a competitive AR experience. It's not even cutting edge, either. Inside-out hand tracking has been a thing on standalone headsets since the first-gen Oculus Quest. Gaze tracking is more trouble than it's worth, the glowing eyes on the outside are like a cheap Halloween decoration, and the whole assembly feels like it will get bricked from a waist-height drop on the carpet. Have you tried other, modern headsets? Bigscreen Beyond, Pimax Crystal, even the Valve Index? It's a blowout. Apple's price tag doesn't justify the lack of competitive features compared to their alternatives. They can't break into a market of "metaverse fans" because they don't support OpenXR or SteamVR - they are explicitly only targeting Apple fans. As someone who isn't part of the Apple ecosystem anymore, the Vision Pro is a fucking joke. What am I supposed to use it for, a $3,500 dedicated 360-degree porno machine? An overpriced streaming client for desktop VR? I have literally zero applications for it, I wouldn't have a reason to own Apple's headset if it was as cheap as an iPhone. > Once the weight is reduced and the input UI is fixed, it will be truly useful. Do you honestly believe that? After hundreds of failed attempts to make VR useful, you sincerely think Apple will be the one to do it? This will only work if Apple can convince customers to go all-in on their ecosystem. And very clearly they…
Apple Vision Pro: Likes itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
It's heavy and the extra encumbrance is not great for general purpose computing, though I never felt the need for extra screen real estate while I'm coding, watching youtube, sending emails etc. That said I still use my AVP regularly, it's a great home theater system for 4k HDR content that's portable for travel. I've owned other headsets like the valve index but the novelty of 3d gaming wore off pretty quickly.
Apple Vision Pro: Likes itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
I use my Vision Pro every single day. I love sitting in my yard in the sun with my Mac mirrored in the center, a music player hanging out on my left, a web browser with documentation on the right. Using the double loop strap I don't even notice I'm wearing it after a few minutes and I treat the battery more as a UPS than something to run off of except for when I go make myself coffee and play a game or watch a video while doing so. Having used other VR headsets (like the Valve Index) the Vision Pro is clearly leaps and bounds ahead of the competition, not just in hardware but software as well. After using the index for a bit everything would always feel a bit "weird" after taking the headset off. I don't get that at all with the Vision Pro. I can't wait for VisionOS 2.0 to deliver a closer macOS integration (being able to give individual macOS applications their own windows (à la VMWare Fusion), and use eye tracking as the cursor) but even the current version is - for my specific use case - an absolute game changer.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Likes it
I’d argue that the iPhone had way more points where it excelled. Web browsing, multi-touch, pinch to zoom, and it even offered a better cellular plan along with it (cheaper than BlackBerry). The Vision Pro doesn’t have a lot of features where it excels. Running apps on it is inferior to using your phone or tablet. Watching movies is inferior to your home television. Productivity is inferior to a standard computer. Games are inferior to existing VR gaming systems like Index or Quest. Reviewers universally describe it as lonely, dystopian. Eyestrain is still a problem, dizziness is still a problem. The iPhone had things about it that were better than existing solutions in a product category (cell phones and smartphones) that was proven and growing. The most optimistic thing you can say about the Vision Pro is that if it were more like a pair of sunglasses and got rid of all the downsides to using it, it might be a really good true AR experience where your brain forgets about the fact that you’ve augmented reality. The problem is, there is no physical hardware technology that is on the horizon that will ever feasibly bring it to that place. Not being able to install apps was completely resolvable by a software update. The hardware problems of the original iPhone like the lack of 3G were resolved within a calendar year with the next model, and the original model had an acceptable level of battery life. If a similar situation to the iPhone was happening we should be seeing a Ming…
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Neutral
I was an early adopter of VR. Original Quest, followed by Htc Vive followed by Valve Index, followed by Quest 3. Spent almost as much hours gaming and using VR as I do my regular computer. I recently tried the Vision Pro at my friends house. Graphics are definitely a lot better. Hand tracking is better than Quest 3. Weight is definitely bulkier on out of all the headsets, but thats something that you get used to - when I first started gaming in VR, my neck was super sore, but after a while, you actually end up strengthening your neck and upper back, which ironically resulted in less headaches for me during the day. That being said, Vision pro is nothing revolutionary. You either have to be a massive Apple stan or never experienced VR to begin with to find it amazing. Its a better iteration of the current VR headsets for sure, but just like the rest, its missing the point. The biggest problem in itself is that everyone is trying to mix VR and AR into one, which is the wrong way to go. VR is way better with external tracking, because you can do things like full body tracking. In VR chat, Ive participated in a few events where people were teaching dance or martial arts, with trackers on hip, knees and legs, and it worked out quite well. Behind the back tracking is also useful for games. Of course the issue with VR is that the entry cost (including the space to play VR) is very high, so the community is VERY tiny. AR on the other hand needs to be a very lightweight, low profile…
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
Since the most compelling difference from other VR headsets is the seamless pass through, I’d say you’re paying about $3000 extra dollars on top of a Quest 3 to get a headset you can do chores wearing. The weight and lack of SteamVR have me strongly considering returning it, but I’m keeping it for novelty factor and sentimental reasons (my brother worked on the foveated rendering) and have found a few ways to put it in my routine - besides chores, the environments turned all the way up are pretty relaxing, not as good as being at Haleakala, but much better than my Valve Index. In the mean time like the article says, I’m trying out different headgear - next up is a BoboVR aftermarket band for Quest 2 that someone on Reddit is 3D printing Apple Vision adapters for
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itValve Index: Doesn’t like it
It’s way better than the Index resolution wise, and there is no screen door effect. Then again even the Quest 3 is better now since the Index is so ancient. There are two main issues with the visuals though: 1. Poor vertical FOV 2. Motion blurring whenever you move which is likely due to the OLED screens You can’t use this on Steam until we get Virtual desktop on the Vision Pro. Not sure how well it would work though since the blur is not great unless you mostly play sim games.
Apple Vision Pro: Likes itValve Index: Likes it
I'm not trying to come across as vehemently pro Vision Pro here, I'm genuinely not sure if there's a market for this, but like... I really feel the need to say, this is not like any other headset, just, at all. On the weight front, it's significantly lighter than a Valve Index, by roughly 20%, and that's just the unit I'm pretty sure, the Index has an umbilical cord that is not-insubstantial in mass by itself that dangles off the back of your head, so already the Vision Pro is quite far ahead on comfort. VAC is of course a factor in any headset and this really comes down to the per-user situation: I personally got my "VR legs" in about thirty minutes way back when I got started, and am able to use full motion movement pretty well now with only minimal vertigo when things go up and down too fast for my brain's liking. However, the VP is going to have a distinct advantage here with it's big complicated camera system that allows it to operate both in VR and in AR, with most applications seeming to live in the latter realm. I think that's going to lend itself to big comfort gains for people who aren't as blessed as me in that regard. Isolation also is much improved with the VP, what with it employing again, the camera system, and also the fact that the Vision Pro (much like my Valve Index) doesn't cover or obstruct the ears. And you get those weird CG eyes you can plaster on the front of the thing, haha. Like again, I don't know if this will work out long term, I'm interested to…
Apple Vision Pro: Likes itValve Index: Likes it
I've had a HTC Vive, Quest 2, and the Valve Index. It's much higher fidelity than any of them by a very large margin. The virtual desktop feature is pretty similar experiences. The hand tracking controls are classic apple (it just works). The eye tracking can use some more work. I do feel that this could be the future. It's a huge step forward in certain areas, and I think the rest will be fixed. In a generation or two, this is going to be really compelling. I never felt that way about any of the other headsets I own.