The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

VR and AR headsets

Apple Vision Pro vs Microsoft HoloLens

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple Vision Pro.

Apple Vision ProMicrosoft HoloLens
Owners with an opinion34632
Positive verdicts62% of 30532% of 28
Positive/negative since 2024183/1142/4
Happy after 3+ years00
Longest happy owner2 yrs–
Praised fordisplay and performanceperformance and ease of use
Criticized forcomfort and valuedisplay and comfort
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Vision Pro: Likes itMicrosoft HoloLens: Doesn’t like it
I tried on the Xreal for 3 minutes when I met someone with them at a party. They were cool but noticeably a lot less bright. Similarly I tried the original HoloLens, many many years ago (2016?), with the similar waveguide technology. It was outside, at night, so relatively easy to see, albeit with jarringly tight field of view. Without a doubt I'm excited about lightweight AR glasses that I can wear in public. My non-expert opinion is we're still a few years away. In the meantime, I love my Apple goggles. For home usage only, and not when guests come over. Going open face (no lightshield) makes them feel a lot more like magic AR glasses, with the ~95% accurate passthrough.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft HoloLens: Likes it
Hadn't seen the video, thanks -- that system is the one Microsoft was prototyping tho, and and my impression from seeing Palmer Lucky on CNBC is that they're tossing the existing hardware and going with Oculus. They don't have AR goggles that projects onto a visor like hololens, they went with full camera passthrough like Apple Vision. Terrible choice for mission critical IMO, at least if Hololens crashes you are left with a transparent piece of plastic. Of course with 22B they can design new hardware from the ground up, maybe (how much did Magic Leap light on fire?)
Apple Vision Pro: Likes itMicrosoft HoloLens: Doesn’t like it
For that to happen we would need a transparent display that can block light. Seeing content on an additive display will always look somewhat transparent, with no hope of displaying blacks. The augmentation on the vision pro look so much better than on a HoloLens2, it's like looking at 3d printed objects.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft HoloLens: Doesn’t like it
Why, is AR all of the sudden useful and highly-demanded when you can run native Mac apps, instead of streaming them or using the iPad/VisionOS versions? Doesn't seem to be the case. I've come around to an understanding that the Vision Pro would be DOA even with regular VR features like OpenXR/sideloading enabled for normies. For the high-end VR/simming market you can buy much better hardware at a lower price from Pimax, and the all-in-one philosophy of the Meta Quest and Steam Frame is much more appealing than Apple's tethered battery brick. If we're being honest with ourselves, it's the exact same cowpie as Hololens with the exact same cognitive dissonance that killed Windows MR. I'd be shocked if the next Vision product (if we get one) treats the Steam Frame as a legitimate competitor, it's just not in Apple's blood to fight those battles.
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft HoloLens: Doesn’t like it
Industry was where Microsoft seemed to find a home for the HoloLens, but it ultimately died as well. In videos, cooking with the Vision Pro seemed really cool. When my dad is making a holiday meal he has his iPad up with multiple timers to try and keep track of everything. With the Vision Pro you can pin timers to each pot in space, while having all the recipes up. This all seems very cool. However, the bulk may be an issue in practice, as well as steam and other things encountered in the kitchen. The kitchen also tends to be where people socialize or want to help out, and the Vision Pro would make both of those things difficult and awkward. I only did the in-store demo of the Vision Pro and the immersive videos were the most striking to me. When it went up high in the mountains my stomach dropped as if I was actually up high and about to fall. I’ve been sky diving and I didn’t even have the feel of unease in real life while sitting on the edge of a plane, but I had it during that video. The one with the Alicia Keys concert did it too. I wasn’t expecting it and all of the sudden she was in my personal space; it was uncomfortably close. I don’t know how you’d get that experience in any other medium. It was cool, but with the limited amount of content, it wasn’t $3,500 cool. Most people I’ve seen talk about it online find using it as a monitor for their Mac to be the killer app, but that feels like kind of a lame killer app, especially when devices that are much less capable ca…
Apple Vision Pro: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft HoloLens: Doesn’t like it
Hello! I spent a lot of time in graduate school researching AR/VR technology (specifically regarding its utility as an accessibility tool) and learning about barriers to adoption. In my opinion, there are three major hurdles preventing widespread adoption of this modality: 1. *Weight*: To achieve powerful computation like that of the HoloLens, you need powerful processing. The simplest solution to this is to put the processing in the device, which adds weight to it. The HoloLens 2 weighs approximately 566g (or 1.24lb), which is a LOT of weight compared to a pair of traditional glasses, which weigh approximately 20-50g. Speaking as someone who developed with the HL2 for a few years, all-day wear with the device is uncomfortable and untenable. The weight of the device HAS to be comfortable for all-day use, otherwise it hinders adoption. 2. *Battery*: Ironically, making the device smaller to accommodate all-day wear means that you're simultaneously reducing its battery life, which reduces its utility as an all-day wearable: any onboard battery must be smaller, and thus store less energy. This is a problematic trade-off: you don't want the device to weigh too much that people can't wear it, but you also don't want the device to weigh too little that it ceases to have function. 3. *Social Acceptability*: This is where I have some expertise, as it was the subject of my research. Simply put, if a wearer feels as though they stand out by wearing an XR device, they're hesitant to wear…
Apple Vision Pro: Likes itMicrosoft HoloLens: Likes it
Again, for those complaining about price - the current (and far less capable) Microsoft HoloLens is also $3500. I've personally used and interacted with the HoloLens and was thoroughly impressed, however the leaps in optics & tracking Apple has pulled off make the Vision Pro quite compelling.