The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

TVs and streaming

Apple TV vs Nvidia Shield

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple TV.

Apple TVNvidia Shield
Owners with an opinion24538
Positive verdicts75% of 21077% of 31
Positive/negative since 202489/278/4
Happy after 3+ years32
Longest happy owner7 yrs8 yrs
Praised forease of use and performanceperformance and ease of use
Criticized forsoftware and reliabilityreliability and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple TV: Likes itNvidia Shield: Doesn’t like it
No, it's not. Let's start with the disclaimer that I work for Google, not the Android TV team, all words my own, etc. The Shield at launch was an amazing product - premium UX and hardware, premium price point. Google changed the experience to an ad-loaded mess without providing an opt out for those who had spent hundreds of dollars on the Shield. I was dogfooder, a huge advocate of the product, and someone who had convinced others to buy the Shield and Android TV devices. That UX revamp and how the team treated their customers (internal and external) turned me off the product for life. I tried the various competitors (XBox, Roku, Amazon) before landing on Apple TV. I now own two Apple TV devices - both of which are still getting updates many years after I bought them - and will continue using them for as long as the product line is maintained. People in this thread have talked about Apple's clean beautiful ad-free UX, but the apps themselves are far better. Apple sets customer-friendly App Store requirements *and enforces them*. That means: * The back button always works. It will bring you back to the home page of the app and then to the system launcher. It will not get stuck in an endless loop of "are you sure you want to quit?" and just dismissing that dialog like multiple Android apps do * No loud obtrusive sounds on app startup (YouTube, Netflix) * The apps are first-class priorities for developers. Circa 2019, the Paramount+ app was an inconsistent mess where s…
Apple TV: Doesn’t like itNvidia Shield: Recommends it
I would not recommend Apple TV. I like the computers and the phone, but the TV is disappoint. Would recommend Nvidia Shield or something. What I am going to do down the line personally is just buy a gaming laptop and use that. Can play games via Steam and watch stuff via Windows apps (e.g. Netflix, Amazon Prime, Crunchyroll). Only problem of course is the laptop will be pricier, but if someone was going to buy a tv streaming thing AND a gaming system of some kind, probably cheaper.
Apple TV: Doesn’t like itNvidia Shield: Likes it
I can happily recommend that option from experience. I've used Walmart's "Onn" Google/Android TV boxes on both 1080p and 4K televisions. They work, and with Projectivity as the launcher you can pretty much rid yourself of any and all advertising placements. If you want to be super thorough, use adb to remove the default launcher once Projectivity is installed and set to default. I now use an NVIDIA Shield in basically the same way. Projectivity Launcher set to default and advert-buttons on the remote control overridden in software. Jellyfin & SmartTube as primary apps for streaming. VLC & FCast Receiver for random video thrown around the network. LocalSend to easily sideload apps (sadly ending within a few years). Moonlight for game streaming from my PC (via gigabit ethernet). HDHomeRun app as a backup for any Jellyfin failures with live OTA TV streaming. Other apps from Google Play only as absolutely necessary (Google Play TV apps include a number of popular VPNs, along with tailscale). It's honestly better than my experience with Apple TV 4K. And if Google continues to close down and wall off AOSP, there's already at least one community build of Lineage OS with Android TV for the Raspberry Pi.
Apple TV: Likes itNvidia Shield: Doesn’t like it
> Which, in my experience, is better than the new Chromecast with Android TV. Similar experience with the Shield, running Android. I shouldn't have tried to cheap out, and should have gone straight for the AppleTV. It's not perfect, but it's by far the best high-spec streamer box I've used. The Shield was glitchy, crashy, dropped animation frames constantly despite running on strong hardware so looked/felt pretty bad, and was full of ads. Plus IMO its menus and general system navigation were a lot worse than tvOS.
Apple TV: Recommends itNvidia Shield: Recommends it
> Get a used mini-pc, install Linux on it As someone who tried that route I'd strongly recommend against it for anyone who isn't core HN audience or just loves tinkering. You're much better off with an Apple TV or an Nvidia Shield unless you really want the "beefy gaming media center". I walked the mini-PC/RPi road and they came up short every time even for me, let alone the rest of the family. Even when I put in place the perfectly optimized initial setup I was still left with a bad compromise of performance, power consumption, noise, boot time, ergonomics, and the constant trickle of things breaking down or needing tweaking because of some update. When trying to watch a movie with the family the last thing I want is to troubleshoot random issues.
Apple TV: Recommends itNvidia Shield: Recommends it
Ah that’s your problem, you bought an old Android TV. Unfortunately you bought a bad product in the first place. If you get an LG with WebOS or whatever Samsung puts on their TV it’s just fast from the factory and it doesn’t get slower over time. I have a very old LG OLED, so old that it’s curved (2015 probably), and it has no slowdown or bugs like this. But every Android TV including new ones like my friend’s cheap HiSense purchased last yesh seem to have slow volume buttons, slow bootup, slow slow slow. I think Android wasn’t designed for the type of SoC that is in a reasonable budget for a TV manufacturer, and that’s why most TV producers like LG and Samsung don’t use it. Plus, Android TV was very much a half-baked product until recently. In other words, your problem isn’t the non-upgradability of the SoC, your problem is that you have a bad product in the first place. My advice is don’t worry about the waste. Every moment you worry about the waste, Taylor swift takes a 20 minute driving commute via private jet. You have finished the useful lifespan of your device, it is probably not long before it gets picture uniformity problems anyway. Get yourself a new LG OLED or Samsung QLED or something like that. You won’t regret it. It’ll be a huge upgrade over a 7 year old Bravia LED in picture quality and capabilities. And still don’t use the smart TV built-in streaming. Use a high-end streaming box with a good processor like an Apple TV or Nvidia Shield. Don’t use a cheap Roku…