The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

TVs and streaming

Apple TV vs LG OLED

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Apple TVLG OLED
Owners with an opinion245183
Positive verdicts75% of 21069% of 154
Positive/negative since 202489/2758/29
Happy after 3+ years35
Longest happy owner7 yrs6 yrs
Praised forease of use and performancedisplay and ease of use
Criticized forsoftware and reliabilitysoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple TV: Likes itLG OLED: Neutral
The only solution I use is connecting the TV (LG OLED) via ethernet and set a traffic rule to drop all outbound internet packets from the TV and then have an Apple TV for viewing. However, I bought my Apple TV in 2022-2023 when it was like £129, so excellent value for money, not so sure nowadays. The reason why I keep it connected to the network (with a traffic rule) is I use home assistant to run automations etc so need at least LAN connectivity.
Apple TV: NeutralLG OLED: Likes it
I wonder about this every time I see a smart TV-related thread on HN. I recently purchased an LG OLED (C5 48") because my old TV died so I'll finally comment. As others have said, just don't connect it to the internet. But you knew this already, so I'll provide my anecdote on the experience of this since I wondered the same thing for years before getting this TV. When the TV is never connected to internet, and you use a single HDMI source like me, the TV acts completely like a dumb TV. It gets turned on via my AppleTV remote and displays the picture 1-2 seconds later. No LG logo (I disabled this), and no smart interface shown whatsoever. If you want to change settings, you can display the settings interface via LG remote control and it generally acts like a dumb TV (not blocking the entire screen, so you can adjust picture quality and see the result as expected). I've had the TV for about two months and never been asked to update it or shown any ad. The only time I've ever seen the smart fullscreen interface is when you unplug a live HDMI source and the TV detects that nothing is there. (If you turn the source off, it tells the TV to turn itself off as well.) Hope this helps since it's a lot easier to buy a nice smart TV and do it this way than find a truly dumb commercial panel.
Apple TV: NeutralLG OLED: Likes it
Bought an LG “C” series OLED a month or so ago. Never gave it a WiFi password. Everything (Apple TV, XBox, Switch) uses HDMI CEC, so I just turn on the desired device, inputs are switched and devices powered on. I never see the TV’s Home Screen, and it doesn’t complain about lack of network. The LG acts as “dumb” as the truly dumb TV it replaced.
Apple TV: Recommends itLG OLED: Likes it
I think the best TVs right now are still the LG OLEDs. The new Samsung OLEDs get brighter, but I do not trust Samsung's QA. In terms of the built-in software, it is all mostly bad to mediocre. The LG WebOS software is okay, but a bit clunky. You can turn off of the ads. If you really care about the Smart TV function I recommend just buying an Apple TV. It is by far the best I have used. If you prefer not to spend the money a cheap Roku stick is not a bad option. Others will mention something like Shield TV and they are fine, but the Apple TV is superior.
Apple TV: Doesn’t like itLG OLED: Likes it
I've had an LG C2 OLED for almost a month. Turned off all those settings. So far so good, but will be keeping an eye out. Before this TV I just used a first gen 4k Apple TV, but I noticed it was a bit stuttery and didn't support as many formats so I've been using the native TV apps. Maybe I rushed too quickly on that.
Apple TV: Likes itLG OLED: Doesn’t like it
Lots of reasons. If you’re a gamer with a shiny new PS5 or Xbox then you’ll want the various updates for things like VRR and tweaks to the HDR performance. There are often other fixes and new features too that relate to image or audio quality. I didn’t accept the various EULAs on my LG C1 TV. I’m able to update firmware but I don’t use any of its Apps. Instead I use an Apple TV for streaming and we don’t have a cable subscription. I haven’t checked how much data the LG is leaking (I really should turn off its Wi-Fi) and I trust Apple just enough to be less shady than LG.
Apple TV: Doesn’t like itLG OLED: Likes it
I do on _very_ rare occasions. Why? I'm fortunate enough to have gigabit symmetrical fiber, so streaming isn't an issue. That said, when viewing content on higher quality TVs and sound systems, there's a very perceptible improvement in both video and audio quality compared to streaming. For example, on my 65" LG C9 OLED with a Klipsch Atmos system, the difference is immediately noticeable. Even with dedicated streaming hardware like new generation Apple TVs, which offer 4K streaming with Dolby Vision/Atmos, it still doesn't quite compare to physical media. Ditto for the native LG apps with identical options. Of course, there are downsides. Good luck finding UHD content on physical media. Redbox doesn't offer 4K discs in my area, and local stores rarely have physical media in stock. Even with physical media, there's other annoyances--e.g. the Xbox One X produces a loud hum as the disc spins, not to mention the delay when seeking/skipping around. That said, for rarified material such as Blue Planet (or anything by Attenborough)--or movies known for their sound quality like Mad Max--physical media can be sublime.
Apple TV: Likes itLG OLED: Likes it
Samsung and LG OLED TVs are especially great, owned them for years and they're still going great with good efficiency. I also heard that smartubenext from github might be of great resource for "adless youtube". The new Apple TV 4k is great too but would be absolutely better paired with the Homeview/Homepod (immersive voice something)
Apple TV: Recommends itLG OLED: Recommends it
Ah that’s your problem, you bought an old Android TV. Unfortunately you bought a bad product in the first place. If you get an LG with WebOS or whatever Samsung puts on their TV it’s just fast from the factory and it doesn’t get slower over time. I have a very old LG OLED, so old that it’s curved (2015 probably), and it has no slowdown or bugs like this. But every Android TV including new ones like my friend’s cheap HiSense purchased last yesh seem to have slow volume buttons, slow bootup, slow slow slow. I think Android wasn’t designed for the type of SoC that is in a reasonable budget for a TV manufacturer, and that’s why most TV producers like LG and Samsung don’t use it. Plus, Android TV was very much a half-baked product until recently. In other words, your problem isn’t the non-upgradability of the SoC, your problem is that you have a bad product in the first place. My advice is don’t worry about the waste. Every moment you worry about the waste, Taylor swift takes a 20 minute driving commute via private jet. You have finished the useful lifespan of your device, it is probably not long before it gets picture uniformity problems anyway. Get yourself a new LG OLED or Samsung QLED or something like that. You won’t regret it. It’ll be a huge upgrade over a 7 year old Bravia LED in picture quality and capabilities. And still don’t use the smart TV built-in streaming. Use a high-end streaming box with a good processor like an Apple TV or Nvidia Shield. Don’t use a cheap Roku…
Apple TV: Likes itLG OLED: Likes it
LG C1 OLED here, and my setup is rather simple and has been going just fine with zero issues for over a year now (with no update requests or anything like that). I set it up normally at first, but software updates and such were annoying. LG TV has been connected to my router using wifi, so I simply clicked the "block internet connection for this device" in my router settings, and that was the end of my issues. As for how I deal with outdated apps and such on the smart tv, I have never used them in the first place. AppleTV has been hooked to the LG TV the entire time, and all apps are used from the AppleTV side. Haven't had a single "update your tv software" dialogue even once since then.