The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

TVs and streaming

Apple TV vs Google Chromecast

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple TV.

Apple TVGoogle Chromecast
Owners with an opinion245117
Positive verdicts75% of 21064% of 97
Positive/negative since 202489/2728/20
Happy after 3+ years34
Longest happy owner7 yrs10 yrs
Praised forease of use and performanceease of use and reliability
Criticized forsoftware and reliabilitysoftware
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple TV: Likes itGoogle Chromecast: Doesn’t like it
I also quickly ditched mine. I mean it worked sorta fine - but the usability was absolutely terrible. Often apps lost connection with it so any requests to pause or resume the media was several seconds delayed. If I got a phone call I often wanted a quick way to pause my media but chromecast made this super inconvenient, slow and stressful when the phone is blurting out it's ringtone. App support was also spotty at best. In the end I realized that since I've already chosen between a rock and a hard place (went with the Apple ecosystem), I could just screenshare using an old Apple TV. This ended up working much better in practice (although lower quality video stream) than Chromecast. Today I don't cast much video anymore for some reason, not really sure why. I have an Apple TV 4K and just mostly use the native apps from various services. Having a remote to a system that is completely detached from your phone is much nicer usability wise IMHO.
Apple TV: Doesn’t like itGoogle Chromecast: Likes it
>I have a Chromecast from 2016 that still runs just as well as it did when I bought it. Which, in my experience, is better than the new Chromecast with Android TV. I switched to it from an old school Chromecast and was just astounded at how badly the menus performed. Like the entire role of this device is to operate my TV, it's 2023, they can't make it do that without the UI animations dragging and occasionally crashing altogether? Not to mention the ads, ads everywhere, "recommendations" all over the home screen, crammed in every available space, and no doubt dragging performance themselves. I switched to an Apple TV and it's a bit better, but there's still a full-screen "recommendation" video at the top of the home screen and it still doesn't run perfectly, which sorry not sorry, would be my expectation for such an incredibly simple UI in this great year of 2023. Sorry to hijack the thread, but is there a single company making a set top box today that #1 consistently performs well in software and #2 isn't riddled with advertising disguised as "recommendations" for content I would never watch? Is that Roku? I haven't used one in years.
Switched from the Google Chromecast to the Apple TVApple TV: Recommends it
I don't like anything Apple, I had an awful experience with MacOS (the laptop was great), iPhones and their 12 finger gestures (again, terrible software) aren't for me. WiFi and worsening slowness woes with the Google TV/Chromecast pushed me into buying an Apple TV, and it is the single Apple product that I would glowingly recommend; that's saying something coming from an Apple hater. It is truly a fantastic product.
Apple TV: Likes itGoogle Chromecast: Likes it
I tried hooking up a Kodi install to my TV to get decent smart functionality on the old thing. Turns out remote control UI is actually quite hard to get right and all the open source options seem to miss the mark, despite the decades of hard work and best intentions. With modern smart TVs I don't think you need any external boxes, but if you like to separate the smart from the TV, I don't think there are that many better options than either Apple TV or Chromecast with Android TV, depending on what tech company you'd like to share your data with.
Apple TV: Recommends itGoogle Chromecast: Recommends it
> such devices often run on outdated Android versions, which have unpatched vulnerabilities and are no longer supported with updates. Many of them NEVER received a single update ever. There are so many shady companies producing TV boxes with no plan to ever provide any updates. Unless one of the larger brands make such a device, I don't see any reason to recommend anything but the ChromeCast or whatever Google calls it now. Or a Roku or an AppleTV, if you swing that way.
Apple TV: Likes itGoogle Chromecast: Likes it
Have you tried Chromecast 4k, though? I’ve bought one, as my LG TV’s webOS became so sluggish that it became pretty much unusable. I have an Apple TV 4k in the living room and it’s great, but I find myself drawn to the Chromecast experience way more. Apple TV is more refined, but Chromecast’s remote is far better than ATV’s (1st gen, at least) and Google’s voice assistant is obviously far smarter (especially if you’re multilingual).
Apple TV: Doesn’t like itGoogle Chromecast: Doesn’t like it
I have a love-hate relationship with my Chromecast. And my Roku, and my Apple TV. The Chromecast works great for streaming from my Plex server. Except switching away from the Plex app or letting the device sleep often causes it to disconnect, meaning the Chromecast will keep playing but can’t be controlled. So I have to keep a dedicated remote control device around. I also have to disable CEC on my TV or the Chromecast will randomly turn the TV on in the middle of the night. The Roku works great for streaming from my Plex server. Except when it doesn’t; sometimes it will stream too slowly and constantly buffer, for no discernible reason. It also puts out an annoying high-pitched whine through the speakers when no sound is playing. The Apple TV works great for everything except streaming from my Plex server. It’s a 3rd gen, meaning no App store and no Plex app, and I haven’t yet broken down and shelled out $130 for a new one. Is there any set-top box/dongle that doesn’t kind of suck?
Apple TV: Recommends itGoogle Chromecast: Recommends it
Exactly, never ever connect a smart TV to internet. Instead, connect a Apple TV/FireStick/ChromeCast/Android TV/Raspberry Pi to do the "smart" things and if they break, they will be cheaper and easier to be replaced than a TV.