The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Monitors

Apple Studio Display vs LG UltraFine 5K

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple Studio Display.

Apple Studio DisplayLG UltraFine 5K
Owners with an opinion11938
Positive verdicts76% of 10469% of 32
Positive/negative since 202450/196/6
Happy after 3+ years10
Longest happy owner5 yrs1 yrs
Praised fordisplay and ease of usedisplay and reliability
Criticized forvalue and reliabilityease of use and build quality
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Studio Display: Likes itLG UltraFine 5K: Doesn’t like it
I kinda agree with you but this is for people who don't want to think about it. That 24" monitor is incredible compared to anything sub 500. A 32" gaming monitor is garbage once you're used to 216 ppi for creative work. Realistically there is like 1 display from BenQ that even comes close spec wise. Their target user will pay 1700 and have an incredible machine that does literally everything they want and probably won't need to upgrade for what, 5-10 years in a single purchase. Compared to having to buy a mouse, keyboard, speakers, webcam, and monitor. Also having good speakers and a webcam is underrated. I use my wife's Studio Display sometimes and it's a real, real nice piece of hardware. I have a 5k LG ultrafine at work that's spec for spec similar but it feels like a toy in comparison (it's also like half the price though so).
Apple Studio Display: Likes itLG UltraFine 5K: Doesn’t like it
I commend them for making a developer-focused monitor, but anything less than 200 PPI makes me sad. If I'm staring at text all day, it'd better be crisp. The number of good Retina displays is so small. Back when I had to buy a new display I relented, I just got the Apple Studio Display, even though it is effectively the old 27" 5K iMac minus the Mac. At least it doesn't have many reported build quality issues (LG UltraFine 5K) or insane backlight bleed/uniformity issues (some Dell 6k 32" display, I forgot the model number).
Apple Studio Display: Doesn’t like itLG UltraFine 5K: Likes it
The LG 5K has all the benefits of Retina 5K and most likely is the exact same panel. The biggest downside is the slower USB-C ports (5GB vs 10GB). The camera isn't technically as good as Apple's, but it also doesn't rely on Apple software. It can raise/lower and tilt without paying $400 extra. It has a black plastic frame which doesn't look as nice, but the glass won't chip if you bump your laptop into the side. If I didn't already have an LG 5K, I'd buy the Apple Studio monitor. I used my previous Thunderbolt Display for over a decade. That should be sufficient time for someone at Apple to fix the camera bug.
Apple Studio Display: Doesn’t like itLG UltraFine 5K: Likes it
> the LG Ultra Fine 5k is which is like only $200 cheaper. $300 cheaper and 8 years old now, so likely can find used examples if you wanted. It's pretty clear that 5k / 218ppi just has no significant market appeal at this point outside of the Apple ecosystem. There were a few other 5k displays, but they've all packed up since (including LG, they don't make that 5k Ultrafine anymore afaict) Although arguably since the LG comes with a height adjustable stand it's $700 cheaper than the Studio Display 27"
Apple Studio Display: Likes itLG UltraFine 5K: Doesn’t like it
Obviously something wrong with the driver for that camera. The same camera produces very good video in the iPad Pro. As for the rest of the Studio monitor, it is a huge relief to finally have a true 5K display from Apple. The only other maker, LG produced a half-hearted effort that suffered from ghosting, backlight bleed, wobbly stand, and loose ports. Those quality control issues are usually things that Apple gets right an has done so in the similar 27" iMac for several years. No one else makes an equivalent monitor. Yes, there are lots of cheaper 4K displays out there. Some smaller, some larger. 4K is never quite right for a Mac OS display larger than about 24 inches. I see a lot of recommendations for wide-screen monitors instead. I've tried a few of those and they almost always have limited vertical resolution and the text rendering is soft enough that I have to enlarge the text to read it clearly. I do this on the Samsung widescreen that our office supplies. I know that the trend is toward higher refresh screens, and I have a couple of screens with 120hz refresh. Both of those are much smaller screens. It might be nice to have higher refresh but I don't actually miss it. 60Hz works well and if the alternative is a higher price, then, no thank you. Similar on the HDR for the screen. This IPS screen has a really great image and reasonable dynamic range for this kind of tech. It might be nice to have more, but everything suggests that mini-LED would be more expensive at thi
Apple Studio Display: NeutralLG UltraFine 5K: Neutral
Also really happy with Omarchy on Macbook. I installed the nightly kernel that has usb-c and it works really well. Connects fine to both LG Ultrafine 5k, and Studio Display. https://x.com/AGTPinsights/status/2106564829532328331 Still some tiny issues with waking from sleep lid closed, but I'm expecting to get that fixed myself with some prompting this week. The people working on Linux on Mac are really impressive (and have access to unlimited tokens), so I expect all issues to be fixed very soon. Being able combine agents, linux software and Apple hardware is so much fun.
Apple Studio Display: Doesn’t like itLG UltraFine 5K: Doesn’t like it
The main problem with that is that there are no decent 5K monitors. The Apple Studio Display is literally the same price as the iMac (so a Studio Display + Mac Mini/Studio is ridiculously expensive). The 5K 27" LG UltraFine is not that much cheaper, and people are saying it has pretty terrible build quality (at least compared to an iMac). And those are pretty much the only 5K monitors.
Apple Studio Display: Recommends itLG UltraFine 5K: Recommends it
Any non-apple 4k monitor gives me an actual headache using macos because of the scaling. Windows and ubuntu on the other hand work with these monitors since they scale their os differently (I run at 4k at 150% zoom). The solution is (unfortunately) to spend money on the lg ultrafine 5k or studio display. These have a higher PPI compared to every other monitor on the market. I run my lg ultrafine at native scaling. No more headaches and my productivity using macos 10x'd.