The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple PowerBook vs Lenovo ThinkPad

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad.

Apple PowerBookLenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion822732
Positive verdicts76% of 7575% of 2366
Positive/negative since 202427/8686/273
Happy after 3+ years10281
Longest happy owner24 yrs25 yrs
Praised forreliability and comfortreliability and performance
Criticized forperformance and portabilitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple PowerBook: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I ran Debian on my Pismo PowerBook from 2000-2008, because it was the only thing that could reliably suspend/resume. Switched to ThinkPads because Linux suspend/resume on x86 had gotten pretty reliable by then.
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad to the Apple PowerBookApple PowerBook: Likes it
It staggers me that this is still a problem, because *more than 20 years ago* I switched from Win98 on a ThinkPad to a G3 Powerbook partly because of sleep. I was working almost exclusively in Office docs back then, and the Mac and Win suites were (then as now) file-format compatible. What coding I did was on *nix servers I could SSH to. And I got real, real tired of often-crashing, slow-booting, sleep-sucks Win98 on a laptop. Then I noticed a colleague who'd come into the consulting group from the design side, and kept his Mac. He could just open it, do something, and close it. And then open it again, and have it wake up normally. It crashed marginally less often than Win98 (this is pre-OS X), but the boot time was MUCH faster, so the crashes were less annoying. I bought a Mac and have been here ever since. And you're telling me that even today, in the Year of Our Lord Two Thousand Twenty Three, that sleep still doesn't work for shit on big-name Windows laptops? That's bananas.
Switched from the Apple PowerBook to the Lenovo ThinkPadLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
Sorry to hear about that - I've got an x200 and it's been rock solid since I got it in november. I think I like it even more than I liked the 12in Aluminum PowerBook that it replaced. PowerBooks have this modernist minimalist thing going on, but my x200 has a highly evolved, almost organic quality to it. I see tons of powerbooks and Asus/Acer/whatever laptops around, and a ThinkPad is so clunky-looking it's like a geeky cool pair of thick-framed glasses. And it runs Linux really well.
Apple PowerBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I agree and I do not agree. I still sometimes use a Thinkpad X230, and wait- a G4 PowerBook, and they are fine machines for many tasks. Yet even those have soldered CPUs, simply because of design constraints. You don't need to have to train models. You want to play a game like Factorio, that, of all things, is bottlenecked on memory bandwidth - you must update each entity in a huge world on every tick, at 60 UPS, and yes, the game is insanely well optimized (check the dev blog). You don't have to play Factorio, but you also technically don't need DMA.
Apple PowerBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I sure do. Modern OS UIs might be visually rich and feature-packed, but this definitely came at the cost of clarity and efficiency. Because I do a lot of writing, I keep an old thinkpad and an old PowerBook running NT 4 and Mac OS 9 respectively. There's just something about those grays and the straightforward, no-nonsense UIs that allows me to work without distractions. I can't say the same thing about my macbook and all of its colorful superfluous features. Of course, since those OSes are ancient, it's more difficult to access the internet which also helps quite a lot with me being more focused on my work.
Apple PowerBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Is it really bullshit? Lenovo manages hundreds of laptop models via fwupd, and those work just fine after they lose OEM support. I've got a Thinkpad from 2009 that still gets modern Linux patches (to say nothing of my 2006 PowerBook running Arch/Plasma 5). Compared to what Apple makes off hardware and service revenue, the cost of opening iBoot and providing basic firmware support would be almost nothing. It's so economical that the volunteers at Asahi were capable of replacing the missing bits via black-box reverse engineering. You want to tell me that Apple is incapable of releasing that firmware themselves? On a technical forum?
Apple PowerBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I remember using laptops before the PowerBook. The keyboards were always pushed all the way forward with a large gap between the keyboard and the hinge for the screen. The laptops were thick and there was often an inch or more height difference between the keyboard and the desk. I thought if only they pushed the keyboard back the would be a palm rest. Apple’s PowerBook was the first computer that I knew of moved the keyboard back. And Apple had the first nicely integrated mouse. When the ThinkPad was introduced a year or two later, it copied the keyboard placement on some (all?) of its keyboards. And I preferred the TrackPoint to Apple’s trackballs and trackpads. Although over time and many improvements I came to like the trackpad more.
Apple PowerBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I used a PowerBook Ti 3.5 1Ghz for 4 years and I loved it. But since most of my programming is in java (whatever), I _had_ to switch. The last year I simply run ubuntu-ppc. IMO: The best of apple laptops: (1) long battery life, (2) bright screens, (3) very comfortable keyboards -if you remap the apple keys to control. The worst of apple laptops: (1) they get burning hot -even new macbook pros; (2) the spinning beachball (of death) can get to your nerves -too much swapping; (3) their sharp edge will hurt your wrists -as opposed to a smoothened, curvy Thinkpad T60 (my current).
Apple PowerBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I still have a T22 with Libranet (Debian) Linux on it. The keyboard light was great! (Much cheaper than a backlit-keyboard, and accomplished the same thing. But I do everything nowadays on my old G4 Powerbook.