The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Mice and trackpads

Apple Magic Mouse vs Logitech MX Master

Hacker News owners lean toward the Logitech MX Master.

Apple Magic MouseLogitech MX Master
Owners with an opinion190195
Positive verdicts41% of 16169% of 162
Positive/negative since 202430/4534/30
Happy after 3+ years86
Longest happy owner15 yrs18 yrs
Praised forease of use and batteryease of use and reliability
Criticized forergonomics and comfortperformance and ergonomics
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itLogitech MX Master: Likes it
> it’s the only good mouse for macOS Besides the magic mouse being a terrible mouse (the usage instructions you describe don't actually work, I used it for a few months and got awful cramps, and swiping a mouse is not ergonomic at all), the Master MX 3s is amazing to use on macOS. The thumb button allows to replicate the touchpad gestures in a much more ergonomic way than the magic mouse.
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itLogitech MX Master: Likes it
It's probably less to do with the awkwardly placed charging port that you use maybe once a month, and more to do with the ergonomics being dogshit every time you use it. Something like the MX Master is a lot better but a vertical mouse is better still if your wrists have seen better days. e.g. https://www.logitech.com/en-us/products/mice/lift-vertical-e... or https://www.logitech.com/en-us/products/mice/mx-vertical-erg...
Apple Magic Mouse: Likes itLogitech MX Master: Doesn’t like it
I just bought a Mac Mini for use as a family computer, and a Magic Mouse to go along with it. Why? Because for a computer sitting out in the open in my living room, aesthetics are actually important to me. It’s also being used by people with different hand sizes, and my MX Master is too big for my kids’ hands. And finally, it’s easier to clean than a mouse made with softer materials and lots of different crevices for wheels and buttons. I’ll also add that horizontal scrolling works really well on the Magic Mouse - comparable to a track pad. My MX Master has a horizontal scrolling wheel, but it is much harder to use due to its design and placement. This may or may not be a big deal depending on which apps you regularly use. I think for a mouse that you plan to use all day long for work, it’s worth getting something with better ergonomics. But for most people, the Magic Mouse is fine.
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itLogitech MX Master: Likes it
There are so many legitimate reasons to hate the magic mouse. Ergonimics, the polling rate, the way the glass gets greasy, the scratchy hard plastic on the bottom. Truly, inferior to the Logitech MX Master in all ways except looks. (which is subjective). But it takes literally a few seconds to get a days worth of charge out of the mouse, Apple clearly don't want you to leave it plugged in to use as a wired mouse: why? idk, because they hate choice, or perhaps its because they know it would overcharge the battery and bulge, or perhaps even still, people would get weird expectations about "wired being better for latency" despite the mouse not using the data connections on the wire. We'll never know. But the charging on the bottom is such a non-issue in reality that it makes me wonder if anyone actually owned that mouse, or they just think it looks funny. Personally, I'd rather they fix the other issues with the mouse, the charging was legitimately never an issue.
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itLogitech MX Master: Likes it
Yes, exactly - I did the ctrl cmd switch previously, but then there's 1. Magic Keyboard with no "fn" button. 2. Macbooks own keyboard with FN button. Which really messes with me, because my pinky expects the left most button to be the CTRL action button. All of it messes with my brain so hard - it makes those little actions hurt me almost every time. And as you said, different sets of terminals drive me just so crazy. I might try the settings, but I also overall hate the MacOS settings, as it seems it's all just so obscure and weirdly limited, like someone has given me those random options that do not adhere to me at all. As mentioned previously, no easy ability to turn off acceleration, which keeps gaslighting me and not feeling right even after using CLI to turn it off. My solution has been to opt just for a mouse, but Magic Mouse feels extremely terrible and awkward to hold. I have Logitech MX Master 3 - which feels nice, but not with Macbook. It sometimes randomly starts to skip and lag, I have to reset it. And it still feels like at times some force is working against me when I'm trying to move the mouse. I still feel it just somehow working against me even if I have turned off the acceleration, despite it working well with Windows. And then the MacBook animations, which feel horrible. The jumping up down thing, feels just annoying. The genie effect, terrible, the having to move the app to install it and then no loading indicator, horrible. I know I can turn off the Geni…
Apple Magic Mouse: Likes itLogitech MX Master: Doesn’t like it
I like the gestures on the magic mouse, especially the left/right scrolling. I use a Logitech MX Master at home and scrolling side to side never works well for me. For ergonomics, both are seem to be fine for the way I hold my mouse.
Switched from the Logitech MX Master to the Apple Magic MouseApple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like it
The 'magic' mouse is garbage is magically useless. I could not care less about the charging port location. The size and shape are completely wrong for adult human use. I think it's roughly the right size for my child, aged six. I used it for about ten minutes so I could order a Logitech MX Master 3S for Mac. Of all the annoying things Apple does, this pushes me the hardest.
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itLogitech MX Master: Doesn’t like it
What fortuitous timing to see this post. I bought an MX Master 3 for Mac mouse for my Silicon Mac Mini about a year and a half ago but quickly shelved it because the cursor would frequently make irritating little jumps. I replaced it with an Apple Magic Touchpad (I don't love the Magic Mouse) because, at least at the time, I was under the impression that the jumpiness was due to a OS-level bug affecting all non-Apple mice. I did have Airpods at the time but I don't recall if I ever attempted to use them alongside the Logitech mouse. The timing is fortuitous because, on a whim last night, I got my MX Master 3 out of storage and put it on a charger. I figured that, with ~18 months of macOS updates, perhaps it'll work with my Mac Mini on bluetooth or using the Logi Bolt USB adapter, which I don't own yet (I guess the Bolt is different from the Unifying Receiver... although irritatingly neither comes in USB-C). I'm intrigued by the hypothesis that Logitech is remaining quiet because their products may be violating FCC rules, specifically, part 15 of the FCC rules: "this device may not cause harmful interference". If I can replicate the AirPods issue, or if I see some other weird behavior with the Logitech mouse, I might just break out my HackRF, YARD Stick One, or Ubertooth One. I'm a total noob at radiofrequency stuff, and I'm only slightly less of a noob with running specialty software, but I wonder if I can spot some unexpected RF emissions.
Apple Magic Mouse: NeutralLogitech MX Master: Neutral
So I went ahead and also bought an MX masters, which is generaaly considered one of the best mice around. You can turn on free scrolling on the mouse wheel, so that you can smoothly scroll the wheel, and not have those little clicks, you normally get. Only that this doesn't transfer to the scrolling that goes on on the screen - this is still 2-3 lines at a time or whatever. There's a lot to dislike about magic mouse, but it still does some things way better than the competition - particularly scrolling up and down, but side-to-side scrolling is down-right terrible on normal mice, and an absolute joy on magic mouse.