The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Mice and trackpads

Apple Magic Mouse vs Apple Mighty Mouse

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple Mighty Mouse.

Apple Magic MouseApple Mighty Mouse
Owners with an opinion19014
Positive verdicts41% of 16162% of 13
Positive/negative since 202430/453/2
Happy after 3+ years80
Longest happy owner15 yrs–
Praised forease of use and batteryease of use and performance
Criticized forergonomics and comfortreliability and durability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itApple Mighty Mouse: Likes it
The Mighty Mouse (the one with the little trackball on the top) was so much better except for the weekly cleaning required. My last one died a few months ago. I still use the first generation Magic Mouse when I have to, and I hate its sharp edges. I don't know anyone who likes it, they usually say they prefer the trackpad.
Apple Magic Mouse: NeutralApple Mighty Mouse: Likes it
You are dead wrong. I have had both wireless and wired expensive gaming mice and the fact is, it makes very little difference for a whole lot of cost and trouble. You largely underestimate people susceptibility to fashion/trend and just going with what's supposed to be better. I also have a Magic Mouse (the V2, my V1 broke) and I have a wired Mighty mouse before. Outside of the ball being replaced by tactile scrolling, the wired mouse was a better product. And if you had done your research, you would know that there is very little correlation between gaming peripherals and gamer level/quality. It just doesn't matter that much and those who play a lot will have 2 wireless mouse or one of the pads to make up for the annoyance of battery management (but it has a cost and is just a waste generally). I don't want to call you an idiot, but I have knowledge on the subject far deeper than you can imagine, so I would say you are the one out of touch.
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itApple Mighty Mouse: Likes it
Apple hasn't really been known for good mice especially since they switched to usb. Their best mouse was the Mighty Mouse and not by much. The entire magic mouse concept is half baked since it relies too much on invisible touch areas for much of it's functionality. It's also way too thin for most people to use comfortably for extended periods of time. It's a really bad design overall but the bottom mounted charging port was the straw that broke the camels back. Apple could release a "pro" mouse that mostly copies the functionality and form of the MX Master 3s, and it would likely be a home run.
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itApple Mighty Mouse: Likes it
The Mighty Mouse is almost the perfect mouse, IMHO. Its two flaws are 1) (as the sibling comment pointed out) how the scroll ball accumulates junk and is impossible to clean without cutting open the mouse and the implementation of the side buttons. Having a first party Apple mouse with real middle click support is awesome. The multi direction scrolling has become a mandatory mouse feature for me. The size and weight are fantastic. For those that have used it, and don’t know, the nearly haptic tic while scrolling is an internal speaker which provides great feedback (especially when the rollers get stuck and the clicking stops so you known it’s time to clean the ball). I find the Magic Mouse uncomfortable, it has no native middle click, no side buttons. Its best feature is that it fixed the scroll ball. I finally broke down and bought a new, old stock Mighty Mouse a few months ago. The scroll ball feels so smooth.
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itApple Mighty Mouse: Doesn’t like it
I think companies get entrenched dysfunction that nobody can conquer. Apple mice have always been bad. One button mice were "simpler", but if everybody had to also learn to press control+click it wasn't really one-button. Ahd how did they ever ship that round mouse you could never orient? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hockey_puck_mouse By thw way, have you ever tried to use a mighty mouse with an FPS game? It doesn't really work. Most games use one button for fire, the other for zoom. But you have to lift your fire finger off the mouse to click the zoom button. the magic mouse... even worse. I won't even go into games and apple, they're bad at that too. Tesla is going down the same road, removing stalks and everything on the touchscreen.
Apple Magic Mouse: Likes itApple Mighty Mouse: Likes it
First, I’ve small hands. I started with the Mighty Mouse[1]. The current Magic Mouse is comfortable for my usage. The Mighty Mouse (Wireless) was the perfect one. I tried one of those Magic Mouse “enhancements” (2009-2010) -- a white silicon contraption -- that sits atop the mouse. It was handy, and I used it for a while. I eventually got used to the mouse in its form and stopped trying any modifications. I have tried the Master Series from Logitech, and I like them but don’t use all the functions. I like the simplicity of the Magic Mouse. Charging - I do it once in 45 days, or when it complains — leave it charged -- have tea, walk/run, or read. Charging was never a problem, and I believe everyone else making a lot of noise about the charging is just overblowing it. If you remember to leave it charged overnight, it needs no charging for the next month or so. 1. https://cdn.oinam.com/img/oinam/brajeshwar-apple-mighty-mous...
Apple Magic Mouse: Likes itApple Mighty Mouse: Likes it
I never had an issue with it! Not the greatest mouse, but totally fine to use for me at the time. I had one at home, and my day job was using grown up Macs so I was using both. I don’t get the orientation complaints; how do people not have instant special awareness of the mouse orientation from just holding and moving it and the feel of the weight of the cable hanging out the front. My hot take is that people just don’t like something different. Like the Magic Mouse - to me the MM is the greatest mouse ever. Thankfully Apple don’t listen to YouTubers constantly bitching about it LOL