The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Mice and trackpads

Apple Magic Mouse vs Apple Magic Trackpad

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple Magic Trackpad.

Apple Magic MouseApple Magic Trackpad
Owners with an opinion190207
Positive verdicts41% of 16181% of 182
Positive/negative since 202430/4575/21
Happy after 3+ years811
Longest happy owner15 yrs15 yrs
Praised forease of use and batteryease of use and ergonomics
Criticized forergonomics and comfortreliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itApple Magic Trackpad: Likes it
Apple keyboards and mouse are horrible, don’t bother with those, plenty of others exists that also have multiple cordless solutions (dongle, Bluetooth, WiFi). The only of the magic devices from apple that is worth is the touchpad, that one is really good, and yes it is usable with a mouse too, as some things are useful through gestures.
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itApple Magic Trackpad: Likes it
Ya I agree. Manufacturing is hard, but Apple has it generally locked in. Apple's greatest weakness has always been ergonomics. Their mice are built well, but they're little more than art projects in terms of usability. Their external scissor switch keyboards (I hated their older keyboards) have always been quite good for what they are, and if they made one in the shape of the sculpt, I'd try it. The magic trackpad is amazing, but I just find myself never reaching for it compared to my mx master 3
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itApple Magic Trackpad: Likes it
Even excluding the puck mouse, I'm sure there are worse mice than the Magic Mouse. It's still not a great product though. Technically it might be pretty clever, but the only way that can parse QA is if Apple exclusively hires testers with really small hands. It doesn't matter that there's a trackpad on the top, because you can't use it. You'll need to curl your fingers to an uncomfortable degree and there's to little traction beneath the mouse to prevent it from slipping when using the trackpad functionality. My guess is that the Magic Mouse needs to be close to 50% larger, certainly taller. The Magic Trackpad however... I hope they never stop making those. That is the best input device anyone ever made. It's large, stable, precise and just a joy to use.
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itApple Magic Trackpad: Likes it
The bigger issue with the Magic Mouse is moving it. It has rails instead of PFT feet and it tends to tire my wrist out. When I got an iMac I paid the $50 extra for the Magic Trackpad and it was worth it.
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itApple Magic Trackpad: Likes it
I object, sir! The Magic Trackpad is an outstanding peripheral and I will not have its honour besmirched on this fine platform. The Magic Keyboard is what it is, which is a perfectly decent keyboard for mainstream users. I like it because it keeps the typing feel consistent between desktop and laptop. I'm sure I'd feel differently if I was writing a novel or into competitive gaming, but I don't, so I like it. The Magic Mouse is an abomination. Not because the charging port location, sure it looks funny, but it's actually not an issue in real life. The actual problem is it's an ergonomic catastrophe. (Which is par for the course with Apple. In its 40+ year history, Apple has never once made a legitimately good mouse.)
Apple Magic Mouse: Likes itApple Magic Trackpad: Neutral
I revert back to my Magic Mouse because I love the touch gestures, but most can be recreated with vertical mouse. I use the Logitech one, it's nice, but the 1 or 2 finger gestures on the Magic Mouse are too nice and can't be replicated on any other mouse, I always revert back to it. I actually rotate the Magic Mouse, Magic Trackpad and Logitech mx vertical, usually last a few weeks or a month before switching to another.
Apple Magic Mouse: NeutralApple Magic Trackpad: Likes it
I would say a pretty good portion, enough that it is becoming more common that if IT either has a dedicated Mac person or they use Mac themselves... a new hire will likely just have a trackpad on their desk when they start. At least that has been my experience in recent years. But even if not, I know I have had conversations many times of people being frustrated with something (especially if they primarily use their Mac as a desktop) and a trackpad (and gestures) largely fixing it. As someone else said, Mac as long had a fantastic trackpad experience. Partially hardware for sure, but software is a major part of that. So they leaned into that and using a trackpad as a desktop initially felt like a really weird idea. But the ability to use the same control setup regardless of how I am using my laptop is awesome. I personally use a Mac Keyboard and Magic Trackpad. And I got https://www.twelvesouth.com/products/magicbridge from TwelveSouth that basically just turns it into one single piece. I would be completely lost if it wasn't for the trackpad. I tried the magic mouse and... it worked but it wasn't the same.
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itApple Magic Trackpad: Doesn’t like it
MacOS is a lovely desktop OS, even now. I stress "desktop" because you can use a proper full-sized keyboard with Home/End, PgUp/PgDn, Ins/Del, etc and they all do exactly what they should. Apple has built in keymaps for PC keyboards for all the localisations so that I get UK English on a PC keyboard, and then I can swap Cmd and Ctrl so Linux keystrokes work as I expect as well . And a proper external wired mouse, with 5 buttons and a scroll wheel. It's lovely. I sold my Magic Mouse, Magic Keyboard and Magic Trackpad, and may their new owners enjoy them. I am happy I never need to touch the damned things again. I have a centimetre of key travel and a big fat mechanical click, and it's lovely. It's laptops that are the pain. There, you have no choice. When I travel with this MBA I take a Lenovo USB keyboard and a cheapo 3rd party Bluetooth mouse, but I still need to fsck around with hubs and external power adaptors and so on and it's a pain. The all-day battery life sort of makes up for it. Sort of.
Apple Magic Mouse: NeutralApple Magic Trackpad: Neutral
Magic Trackpad 2 and (Mac) Magic Keyboards appear as USB HID devices when connected to a computer via Lightning-to-USB (-A or -C) cable. One annoyance is that macOS automatically Bluetooth pairs with these devices when connected via USB, overwriting any existing pairing, but this shouldn't matter for purely wired scenarios. For switching Bluetooth devices more generally, observe that most Bluetooth controllers are USB devices; with a bit of effort — mostly just copy/pasting the device pairing keys across all connected hosts — they can be switched just like any other USB peripheral (YMMV with "intelligent" USB KVM switches that virtualize USB HID device connections). IME the connection delay is a couple seconds longer than switching wired USB HID devices directly, but entirely reasonable for typical KVM use cases. Note here that "most Bluetooth controllers are USB devices" even extends to internal Wi-Fi/Bluetooth combo cards, which are commonly M.2 key A or E (= PCIe + USB 2.0 + …), or M.2 key A or E preinstalled on a mostly passive PCIe adapter, with a separate cable connection to a USB port or motherboard USB header used exclusively for Bluetooth. This turns out to be a surprisingly useful implementation detail: on one of my work desktops, I'm currently virtual USB-switching the Bluetooth controller on an Intel BE200 PCIe card between a Linux host and a Windows VM running on that host, while keeping Wi-Fi connected to the host. I have a matching hot key set up in each OS to…
Apple Magic Mouse: Likes itApple Magic Trackpad: Likes it
It's different for everyone, but one thing I've found that's been tremendously helpful for me (in 30+ years of programming and heavy W-A-S-D gaming) has been the use of ergonomic devices (keyboards, mice) and workspaces (desk height, position, chair, posture, etc.). In particular, ergo keyboards allow me to type comfortably for hours on end, day after day, year after year, at very fast speeds and without any injuries so far. Before I switched, I would get all sorts of finger and hand cramps monthly. I personally like the Microsoft Sculpt Business keyboard the most, but that's currently discontinued (soon to be re-released under the Incase brand). There are many other brands & models, both with soft laptop-style keys and harder mechanical keys. I particularly like the Microsoft one because it doesn't have an attached numpad, which means your mousing hand can fit comfortably next to the keyboard instead of stretched out unnaturally far away. (The numpad is wireless and can be placed anywhere, for the rare times you need it). There are also many types of mice, from wrist mice to vertical mice to trackballs to simply flat mice (like Magic Mouse). I found alternating between the Magic Mouse and a trackpad to help with mousing pain. You can also use webcam-based eye tracking if you prefer, or like foot pedals for scrolling.
Apple Magic Mouse: Likes itApple Magic Trackpad: Likes it
It's a surprisingly okay daily driver mouse if you actually don't use the mouse that much, like if you're writing code or staring at code most of the time. I daily drove it for 3 years despite the terrible ergonomics, because I consider macOS almost unusable without the gestures (horizontal scroll, zoom, mission control, swiping between fullscreen apps). A few weeks ago I snapped and got the Magic Trackpad instead, which is a bit pricey (that's why I delayed the purchase), but IMO lovely to use.
Apple Magic Mouse: Doesn’t like itApple Magic Trackpad: Doesn’t like it
I suspect you’re right. I very much enjoyed the Magic Mouse but had similar issues with wrist discomfort. The neutral position of the human wrist is vertical - thumb pointing up as if shaking hands with someone. The Magic Mouse is so low-profile that it forces the wrist into an almost 90deg rotation. Ergonomically, it’s highly problematic. The solution for me was to switch to a vertical mouse (well, almost) that allows the wrist to remain neutral. Because I missed the gestures I added a Magic Trackpad on the left side of my keyboard. Of course this suffers from the same ergonomic problem but I only reach for it sporadically so the impact is minimal.