The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook vs System76

Hacker News owners lean toward the System76.

Apple MacBookSystem76
Owners with an opinion2608312
Positive verdicts61% of 225469% of 280
Positive/negative since 2024718/45949/23
Happy after 3+ years16133
Longest happy owner18 yrs20 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forease of usebuild quality and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itSystem76: Likes it
> Sleep & suspend doesn’t work on Windows either. Or Macintosh. My $DAYJOB Macbook sleeps properly about about 2 out of 10 times, at best. Most of the time it fails to sleep and by the next morning when I open it up, the battery is dead. :-( For comparison, my System76 laptop running PopOS! sleeps perfectly, every time with no issues. shrug
Apple MacBook: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
Glad you are! I don't want to be overly negative. I am comparing my M2 work macbook trackpad with my 2 year old lemur pro trackpad - it's not really a fair comparison. The problem is that the pricing is similar enough where it's hard to justify the hardware downgrade. I should also mention that my free time to work on projects has dramatically decreased in the past few years, so I am valuing the ability to seamlessly switch between my desktop and laptop on personal projects less than I used to.
Apple MacBook: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
As an SRE I find that MacOS for me strikes a good balance between being unix-y enough but also reliable to the degree that it doesn't require me to spend time debugging why the bluetooth fails or why the VPN stopped working after I ran apt-get update. I spent the last 6 years on various linux laptops (even a system76 one), but unfortunately I couldn't get the same polished experience as with a macbook.
Apple MacBook: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
I strongly disagree with your assessment. First of all I don't know what kind of frankenstein Windows environment you are running to get those sorts of issues so lets put that aside. With Linux the issues are fundamental to how the OS is designed and maintained. Several of these issues were fixed only to come back one or two releases in the future. These sort of terrible regressions don't inspire confidence. You have listed excuse after excuse to justify these failures when in reality both other OSes have had these functions worked out over 10+ years ago. 1) I have heard this excuse before that I should stick to official Linux hardware. I have had issues with Thinkpads as well and some of these issues happened on a Thinkpad. I have also been hesitant to jump onboard System76 or Purism because their systems just look like junk and in 2021 when we have stunning Mac laptops with beautiful trackpads and retina displays and me entering my 30s I just don't have the stomach to spend hundreds of dollars on laptops that look like they came out of the mid to late 2000s. In the case of System76 they are rebadged Clevo systems from what I understand(could be wrong about this). So in reality I am paying for QA for this year of distro with no specific guarantee that I won't start hitting the same issues a few years down the road when the regressions start to come. There is no garuntee that System76/Purism will fix some small regression in a multi year old system. They suffer from the fact…
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itSystem76: Likes it
I've owned a System76 darter pro for a year. I've had two noticable issues, but overall I've loved the experience and would absolutely do it again. I personally prefer System76's pragmatic "get things working first and gradually make them not depend on binary blobs later" approach compared to Purism which sacrifices quality for openness. The issues: - Apparently random force shut downs every few days for months. Their support wasn't able to diagnose the issue, but it eventually went away on its own. Logs had nothing, they just stopped. - Hinge broke requiring ~$200 repair costs (needed to replace most of the exterior shell) However, I'm relatively hard on laptops and have also had similar issues with other laptops. For example, I had a MacBook that regularly reset it's clock to zero unix time probably because of a hardware issue and needed to have the memory replaced.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the System76System76: Likes it
Non US resident here, I just switched from macbook 13 to system76 lemur. Half the price and double performance, could not be happier. Market is ready for segmentation and users today are more tech savvy then before.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the System76System76: Likes it
I have one (the previous one with AMD Ryzen 5700u). I've been using it for work the last 6 months coming from an 2015 macbook. Its been great for developing. The battery lasts pretty well (forgetting my power supply when working from home I got almost 7 hours), its fast (I've done some genetics blast runs which take hours, where those extra cores really help). Its pretty quiet too (you can hear the fan when it spins up, but its very reasonable). Returning to a Mat screen has been nice. I really like AMD on the notebook. Compared to my 4 year old Oryx pro (intel 8th gen), which had poor battery life (esp when using the Nvidia graphics) and required a reboot initially if I wanted to switch to intel graphics. This one is much nicer, but it won't game nearly as well as one with dedicated graphics.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the System76System76: Likes it
I bought one less than a year ago. I took the budget for a macbook and spent it maxing out a system 76 laptop. Double the memory, over double the storage, ample USB ports, not really sure what's subpar about what I'm using. Best laptop I've ever had by far. Regarding looks, I don't know or care.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the System76System76: Likes it
I have a 17" Oryx Pro that I've been using as my daily driver for work. It's basically a luggable, but I mostly love it. The thing I really miss from my old Apple laptop though is rock-solid suspend behavior. I feel like I can leave my Macbook closed for a week, and it will barely lose any battery life. When I bring home my System76 and leave it in my bag over the weekend, it will always be dead by Monday morning.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the System76System76: Likes it
> The touchpad was like using a Windows machine from 2010. It was so tiny, and had only the bare essential features of registering 1 finger clicks, or 2 finger scrolls. No gestures. My experience is the opposite. My System76 has better gestures than the MacBook it replaced, particularly since the gestures are easily configurable per-app.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the System76System76: Neutral
I have a Galago Pro and in general I like it. some drawbacks I see: - Terrible battery life - Sound quality and volume not very good - Problems with suspend/wake and fan control. The fan turns on when a USB-C is connected and the device is in suspend mode. Sometimes the fan goes into super turbo mode at night and can only be stopped with a hard reset. This one really bugs me and I would like system76 to fix it Otherwise I like the machine. Display is good. I like the keyboard better than on my Macbook 2019. Trackpad works surprisingly well.
Apple MacBook: Likes itSystem76: Likes it
I don’t think there are any fanless x86 but I had a system76 pangolin for work. It was quite well built (I bought the next gen one for myself). They OEM the notebooks though, so the quality is decent (I’m coming from a 2015 Mac book, pretty much the gold standard of Macs) https://system76.com/laptops