The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook vs Microsoft Surface Laptop

Owners are split: the signals below point different ways.

Apple MacBookMicrosoft Surface Laptop
Owners with an opinion260879
Positive verdicts61% of 225453% of 68
Positive/negative since 2024718/45919/23
Happy after 3+ years1610
Longest happy owner18 yrs2 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and build quality
Criticized forease of usereliability and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Doesn’t like it
This sounds very exciting to me, however, the fact that it is a Windows laptop makes me sigh a bit. Why? Because they often seem to lack the fundamental experience that MacBooks have nailed. I have tried many touchpads, but nothing comes close to MacBooks. The tracking feels incredibly precise and consistent. The same goes for the speakers. It is surprising that no other laptop manufacturer has matched the sound quality Apple delivers. That is frustrating, because I genuinely want that same experience on a different system. I do not want to feel locked into MacBooks. I know the Youtube channel Dave2D did a video on this experience as well [1][2]. Another issue is how Windows laptops degrade over time. No matter how many I have tried, they eventually end up in a state where the fans spin up for no clear reason, the battery drains quickly, and I start getting notifications about low disk space even though I have not installed much. When I check the “Uninstall or remove apps” section, it does not clearly show what is actually taking up space. I often have to use tools like WinDirStat to discover leftover files from applications I already removed. These remnants build up and contribute to the system feeling bloated. I also start noticing small but frustrating delays, like the lag between pressing the Windows key and the Start menu appearing. BUT I do have an idea though, Nvidia will hopefully support Linux kernel, so if I have the opportunity to switch to one of these new machine…
Apple MacBook: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Neutral
While I am back to my Surface Laptop 7 after a few weeks with the Neo because the latter wasn't good enough for my usage, I agree it's the coolest Mac right now, the colors are great! I don't really understand why Apple keeps its "more serious" devices mostly color-less, it's a shame.
Apple MacBook: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Doesn’t like it
Just a few weeks ago I replaced my Surface Laptop 3 with a M1 MacBook and couldn't agree more regarding hardware. I can't speak for any xbox branded stuff, but any MS-branded computer I've ever owned has been trash. Microsoft might be terrible at this hardware business, but they do have a powerful presence in the developer & business community. I still feel like Microsoft is the strongest software company on earth. Consider that not even the confines of this M1 MacBook prevent me from being able to compile & run my .NET apps without modification. Apple's hypothetical hegemony does not cross over in the same way. Until Apple can get me to look at their Xcode offerings and think "wow fuck visual studio, GitHub, et. al.", I do not think their takeover of the computing world will begin.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the Microsoft Surface LaptopMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Likes it
Oh wow. I love mine, so much that I've never been back to the apple laptop eco system since. The two surface laptops I've had are the best laptops I've owned. The build it rock solid, its trivial to run wsl for a Linux environment and I still get a windows environment for work with excel, etc. The keys don't come off the keyboard like they do with my old mac chicklet style laptop keys and even my 10 year old can still drive multiple external monitors.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the Microsoft Surface LaptopMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Doesn’t like it
Same. Bought a few different gens of the laptop. Wanted to love them as an alternative to MacBook. To me, Windows 10 is a much better OS than anything Apple. Fit and finish are good (they have to be, because Apple raised the bar). Alcantara on the earlier ones was great. But - battery swell on both, killing the touchpad.
Apple MacBook: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Likes it
I know that Windows 11 doesn't get a ton of love on HN, but I have successfully replaced my M1 MacBook Air with a Surface Laptop 7. The build quality is great, and I even think that the Surface's haptic trackpad is superior. However, I don't think anything on the market beats the Macbook's speaker quality.