The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook vs Lenovo ThinkPad X220

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad X220.

Apple MacBookLenovo ThinkPad X220
Owners with an opinion2608173
Positive verdicts61% of 225486% of 155
Positive/negative since 2024718/45935/9
Happy after 3+ years16117
Longest happy owner18 yrs15 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forease of usedisplay
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
My X220 from 2012 also runs fine. I use now use a X13 because AMD Zen3+ is faster and provides much more battery runtime. The magnesium chassis and the crisp keyboard are awesome. This stuff last long: * Build quality, regarding chassis and screws. * Replacement parts are available. Hardware maintenance manual is available. A broken palm rest is something fixable. * Handle it with care. Most people don’t care about the cheap consumer laptops. Neither the manufacturer nor the consumer. Windows degrades quickly through updates, software bloat (e.g. Electron) and anti-virus snakeoil makes everything slow and unreliable. The biggest issue of ThinkPads is that the L-Series can be purchased (same hardware, bad chassis) and that bad panels can be ordered. Recently Lenovo removed the HiDPI panel option from the X13. Which is the worst possible idea. Another dumb idea is the ugly and useless camera bump protruding from the panel. Apple takes always a lot money from and prevents these mistakes. But Apple loves to deliver bad keyboards. And the aluminium chassis is bad in comparison to magnesium chassis (much better feeling, never hot or cold). Avoidable mistakes. None of these are hard challenges. As the biggest mistake “six rows keyboards”. The complete industry ruined laptop with 16:9 and after a decade we’re allowed to enjoy the much better 16:10 again. The keyboards are still small, squeezed things with awkwardly grouped keys. The X220 keyboard is a masterpiece i…
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
ThinkPads come usually with two panel options: The cheap one and the good one. Often even a third or fourth. Lenovo should only ship the good ones! If I buy a ThinkPad I want the good one. I struggled to get the HiDPI panel for the X13 and ordered it from the replacement parts. Same for the X220, I replaced the TN panel by drumroll IPS panel. Apple takes ridiculous amounts for memory or disk but you always get the good stuff with the base model. This makes it simple and reliable for customers. Except keyboards The ThinkPads always win, convex key caps, better switches and pressure/release point, travel way, better layout and a TrackPoint. In some models you can still replace it within 30 seconds (T14). With the X13 or MacBook it is a horror, requires removal of the mainboard. Not mentioning Apples failure with the TouchBar , which “feels” like the tried to save money on expensive switches by replacing them with a cheap touchscreen and selling this horrible downgrade as feature. And the infamous butterfly switches are the reason to avoid any used older MacBook (often defective).
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Neutral
Yeah. I had an X220 (or X220i?) years ago running Debian/WindowMaker until the motherboard died. I think a "tie" is fair. I'd say the MacBooks last a few years longer, though ThinkPads have more ports. ThinkPads were about as good 10+ years ago as MacBooks are now, so can we just call it a tie? I suppose. Unfortunately, the keyboards on both have regressed to "fine".
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
Thinkpad x220 checking in, still rocking my Sandy Lake and still enjoying a real keyboard. It's about 12 now. Other laptops have come and gone. I couldn't live with my macbook m1. I hated the keyboard and the desktop - why is there no delete key, pray? UTM crashed a lot. Asahi was lovely but I just didn't like touching the hardware.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
For working in sunlight or very bright days; my daily driver in winter is an x220 and it is perfect but in spring, summer, autumn, I simply cannot see anything so I switch to my MacBook m1 which, at full brightness, still is not good already (and it is only spring). But yes, blobless Linux would be a very big + and so would very long battery life. I have a stack of x220s as backup but they will run out in the end and in my country the supply is drying up as they are good and cheap so people bought them up. A run of x220 or rather x220t with eInk or rlcd would do me well with the 9-cell battery. But it is a bit big too big and I still need a tablet (in case of 220) and phone which I do not like.
Apple MacBook: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
personal preference: the current Mac keyboard is the Best keyboard I have ever used for programming and email writing. it is leagues ahead of any other keyboard when it comes to speed and comfort. before the latest Mac keyboard I was a die-hard Thinkpad keyboard fan (x220 none the less). since working on the new Macs it's like I've re-discovered the how good typing can be.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
Bought an X220 years back and it unintentionally became my main laptop for a few years. Sold it on in much worse condition (I kept the keyboard) at a profit and got an i7 X230T instead, which has also somehow gone up in price since. the X230 didn't last as long, the efficiencies of the M1 macbooks were too good to ignore. Gave it to my mother since because she wanted "an old laptop that just works"
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
I have an X201 (15 years old) and X220 (14 years) that I regularly use, running different flavors of linux. they've both been repaired and upgraded a few times. I'm spoiled by having an M2 Macbook as a daily driver - they can't match it for speed - but I love the ruggedness and resilience and I always will.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
It’s task-dependent for me as well. For development I think the current 16” MBPs are really about perfect, but for the use case of studying, web browsing, etc something in the range of 12-14” and as light as reasonably possible without negatively impacting battery life is about right. For those smaller machines, I think a squarish (5:4, 4:3, 3:2, or 16:10) aspect ratio with a body exactly as wide as a full-size laptop keyboard (as seen in 12” PowerBook G4, 12” MacBook, and ThinkPad X220) is particularly good, but nobody makes those anymore.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
Some of the newer Asus Zenbooks have the three criteria you're looking for, but they're very flaky on consistency and reliability (different trackpad hardware on the same laptop at random, screens dying randomly). I actually have no huge OS preference, but I use a MacBook because it's literally the only thing on the market right now that fulfills those three criteria (I also have a fourth: <5 lbs) and reliably performs for longer than a year. Lenovo's keeping up to some extent (I loved the X220 and X230, but the X240 is no longer competitive. Like others here have mentioned, the T440s is pretty nice, but the trackpad is clunky), but HP, Dell, Toshiba, Sony, and everyone else seem to have completely forgotten about the business laptop market. What happened, laptop manufacturers?