The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook vs Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Apple MacBookLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon
Owners with an opinion2608154
Positive verdicts61% of 225468% of 137
Positive/negative since 2024718/45911/10
Happy after 3+ years16111
Longest happy owner18 yrs10 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forease of usebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Neutral
I’ve used thinkpads (and the X1 in particular) for many years. And I do think they’re the best option you have outside of the apple ecosystem. But they are far, far, far of being an excellent replacement for MacBooks. Specially after the new Apple silicon has shown up. The deep OS integration, power saving, performance, seamless upgrades of OS, build materials quality, trackpad, audio quality, etc, etc is far ahead on MacBooks. But I do agree they are the best option if you hate or can’t pay or aren’t allowed to use apple products.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
I see a lot of nostalgia in the comments. Besides my MacBook, I have both an IdeaPad (Flex 5) and a ThinkPad X1 Carbon (the latter one work assigned). I have been using ThinkPads for almost as long as MacBooks, and I find the modern Thinkpad keyboard much nicer than the T or X series, since the longer travel gave me RSI, and the newer keyboards are much, much quieter. I can switch between my MacBook, the X1 and the Yoga without any significant decrease in accuracy (other than modifier key placement) or impact, and although the feel is different, they all feel pretty great to me. (I will not mention the hideous MacBook keyboards of the next-to-last series... Those were just bad.) Quality-wise, I do notice the Yoga is a bit mushier (like the Logitech K380 I am typing this in now, but with less travel), but the X1 is every bit as good as the MacBook's. Same goes for trackpads. X1 (using Windows 11 drivers) and MacBook are roughly equivalent, Yoga slightly less smooth but still OK. (I don't use the TrackPoint because it too makes my RSI flare up - although I was an avid user for decades, if I use it for more than a day my index tendon starts stinging noticeably) Lenovo does cut some corners, though, and with the Yoga and the X1 beside one another the differences in build quality and screen are evident (the X1 has a great HIDPI one, with good brightness and color accuracy, while the Yoga has a chalkboard). But compared to most other PC laptops I've used (except maybe some Surface…
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
I exclusively used MacBooks from 2012 to 2018 or something like that, before switching to a Carbon X1, and could never switch back. None of the laptops from Apple I had could actually be used from my lap, which is where I want to use my laptop, because of the heat coming from the bottom of the MacBooks. So I'm quite happy with plastic/softer materials rather than whatever metal material Apple uses.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
Why does nobody care about the janky Bluetooth mouse that's only janky on macOS? Why does nobody care that my USB 2.0 ports on my external USB-C docks die in about 20 minutes necessitating a reboot--again, only on macOS (and only on newer macOS versions--old ones work fine). How many years did it take Apple to (sort of) fix their shittastic keyboards? How garbagey is Xcode relative to any other IDE nowadays? I can go on ... and on. Macbooks may look pretty, but the software has been becoming increasingly garbage. And I use software to get my job done--the hardware merely needs to be sufficient (I generally customize my laptops to use an i5 (including mac)--which ducks a lot of the idiotic thermal issues). I'm sitting on a Lenovo Carbon X1 with Linux full-time now. I finally got tired of fighting craptastic software from Apple. If I'm gonna fight software, I might as well be on Linux. And, surprisingly, my experience on Linux has been better than the last year or two on macOS.
Apple MacBook: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Doesn’t like it
I think macbook is the best if you don't want to use linux. I had some issues with it using linux. I also purchased lenovo x1 carbon, but I don't like it I tell you. the build quality is kinda low. I also heard some good things about dell xps 13. but I also saw compatibility complains.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Doesn’t like it
I've been using Thinkpads exclusively from 2005 or so. My first was a T40 I got from work. Then I got a T42 of my own. I used it heavily till the fan gave out. After that, I got an X200 which I used for a long time. The keyboard got damaged because of a spill. I replaced it but somehow, the motherboard got shorted out and it died. I then bought a second hand X240 (roughly 2013) and used it as my primary machines. Replaced the battery (twice), fan, hand rest. And it's still running. My kids use it to play some simple games. My main machine right now is an X1 carbon (which I'm not really happy with compared to the others but it's okay for now). I used a Macbook for about 2.5 years in between. Didn't like it (hardware was decent. Software was terrible). I also bought a Dell latitude (which was okay and is being used now as headless machine at my workplace for tinkering). But my primary machine is a Thinkpad and I don't expect to see that changing in the near future.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
I have a GDP Pocket 3 with WSL. It's supposed to take over my old 3rd gen Thinkpad X1 Carbon, but that thing keeps trekking on. The KVM support is amazing on the Pocket, though. Wish it had the battery life of my M1.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
I've used a fully loaded MacBook and it works well. It's quite slow compared to a desktop but it's fast enough and has the Retina screen. This laptop is basically a tablet in laptop form factor; it is ultra tiny and very nice to use from a physicality standpoint. I'm currently using an X1 Carbon ThinkPad Gen 4 with a 4K screen and it is pretty nice too. It's a step up both performance wise and size wise from the MacBook.