The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook vs Lenovo ThinkPad X1

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad X1.

Apple MacBookLenovo ThinkPad X1
Owners with an opinion2608376
Positive verdicts61% of 225471% of 335
Positive/negative since 2024718/45998/57
Happy after 3+ years16128
Longest happy owner18 yrs11 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forease of usebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
I might be biased toward ThinkPads, but the only thing I envy about MacBooks is the processor and battery life. I prefer the X1 Carbon’s body a thousand times over Apple’s unibody design, which I find cold and uncomfortable, and it tends to dig into my wrists. And I’d take a TrackPoint over Apple’s trackpad a million times over. Of course, that’s just my personal preference.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
ThinkPad X1 from 2 years ago was very solid and under Fedora everything but camera worked out of the box. And for camera issue I had to blame myself for not checking details of a specific model as Lenovo was offering at that time fully-Linux compatible model. It took about one and halve year before Linux fully supported it. And I already upgraded SSD on it which took less than 10 minutes. The only complain is bad battery life. With several VMs running mostly idle it doesn’t lasts even two hours. But then I used beefy MacBook M2 at my previous work and with VMs it lasted only 4 hours.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
The screen keeps me on macbooks as well (well, and the touchpad, the speakers, and the lack of fan noise). But it is baffling how 1920x1080 (or 1200p) are still the "standard" elsewhere. If I want an X1 carbon, the best screen you can get at 14" right now is 2880x1800 (2.8k). Spec it with 32GB of RAM and it's clocking in at $2700, for a laptop that still has a worse trackpad, worse sound, and worse screen than a 14" MBP at $2399. And the Ultra7 in the thinkpad still doesn't beat the Mac, and it'll be loud with worse battery life. There truly is nothing else out there with the same experience as an Apple Silicon MBP or Air. So, my only options for the foreseeable future is wait for Asahi Linux, or suck it up and deal with macOS because at this rate I don't think there will ever be a laptop with the same quality (across all components) of the mac that can run Linux. The only one that came remotely close is the Surface Laptop 7 with the Snapdragon elite, but no Linux on that.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
There are also older Macbooks that outlasted my Thinkpad. Maybe the X1 Extreme was a poor choice, but there are also a lot of people who say that Thinkpads just aren't as good as they used to be. Macbooks also went through a period of poor quality. I hope Thinkpad improves again in the future.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
All the flaws were due to the one trick pony "make it look thin" era of Ive - the stupid butterfly keyboard switch, the fact it was riveted to the chassis, the poor thermals, the lack of larger sized ports. And after all that the thing was still heavy. Look at something like a Lenovo carbon X1 for thin done right. The latest macbook was basically and undo button for all Ives choices.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
You might need to set your system to hibernate instead of sleep. Modern x86 laptops lack proper standby power states — they only have a low power "darkwake" state in which they're able to do things like periodically check email, and instantly "wake up" from. Microsoft bills this as "modern standby". That's nice in concept, but it rarely if ever works as it's supposed to, especially under Linux. I had to set my Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Nano up so after being closed while unplugged for an hour or so it automatically hibernates, because otherwise it'll never properly sleep and Windows will drain its battery. It's stupid but the only machines that reliably sleep these days are MacBooks.
Apple MacBook: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X1: Recommends it
Lenovo ThinkPad X1 or X1 Nano are my favorites. Small, light, but powerful. Before I used the ThinkPad X230 and DELL Latitude 7270, each for many years and bought second hand. The DELL was particularly sturdy. All of these are Ubuntu LTS friendly boxes. Avoid Microsoft Surface Laptops, which require patches to run Linux, Microsoft doesn't offer an Image ready to burn on a stick. And although I'm writing this on an M1 MacBook, I can't recommend that box yet as a primary machine; I use it mostly for making and presenting slides and browsing HN and such, not for serious dev work. In a year's time, this may look different.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
I dislike using touchpads very much. I go to great lengths to control everything with the keyboard, and fall back to a traditional mouse when I have to (I tried trackballs but I couldn't adapt). Whenever I'm forced to use a touchpad because I'm on the go or I don't have room to bring a mouse with me, I groan. That said, the implementation of the touchpad in a Macbook vs a regular touchpad in even a high end laptop is night and day. The software and hardware work together to make sure the touch surface is centered, and your fingers glide through it, there are no accidental presses, and esentially never misinput. The haptic feedback is so good that you can't really tell that you're not pressing a button. In comparison, the touchpad in what I consider the best Windows laptop, the Lenovo X1 Carbon, is a steaming pile of shit, and fails every measure. I don't know how much of it is Apple's attention to detail versus their ability to do vertical integration -- Lenovo likely has very little control over how Synaptics implements their drivers -- but I would pay a hefty premium for an experience like a Macbook.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Doesn’t like it
two weeks ago I received the new Lenovo x1 carbon 3rd gen, I expected a high end machine. But I got: low brightness screen, bad colour range + build flaws: the screen cover was not glued well. These flaws also appeared with other customers (search the forums). After three days I sent it back, and today got the new macbook 13", although I don't like the brand Apple, you can't deny its quality over all the other brands.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the Lenovo ThinkPad X1Lenovo ThinkPad X1: Recommends it
Same here. I was about to order a new MacBook recently, but there’s been a lot of small issues annoying me over the past few years and Liquid Glass was the straw that broke the camel’s back for me. Back to Linux for me. Ended up ordering a Thinkpad X1 Carbon instead, and am planning to throw Fedora on it.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the Lenovo ThinkPad X1Lenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
> What do we do as Apple users stuck in this ecosystem whose main goal is to extract more money from our pockets? Leave ... the ... ecosystem. This is the whole point of things like Asahi Linux. Take advantage of the hardware and escape from the software. If all the developers who slave over Apple devices spent 10% of their time improving the experience on something else , 24 months later Apple wouldn't have a market. I left. I got tired of fighting bugs in macOS given that Apple clearly no longer gives a damn about macOS. I just bought my second Lenovo Carbon X1 after leaving Land-Of-The-Fruit. This one is about $1700 + a Saumsung 4TB SSD. Note: I can actually upgrade the SSD . It has 32GB of RAM for half the price of anything equivalent in macOS. The OLED display is right about the equivalent macOS resolution, and it's a matte display. It has a useful set of ports--a goddamn HDMI port as well as 2 USB-C and 2 USB-A ports. And Lenovo's external dock actually freakin' works . Yeah, it probably doesn't get the performance or battery life as an M3. Given that I didn't notice on my previous Lenovo vs an M1/M2, I'm not likely to notice this time either. And, as a "bonus", I can run an actual Windows install if I absolutely must.
Switched from the Lenovo ThinkPad X1 to the Apple MacBookApple MacBook: Recommends it
I grew up with Asus and Acer and then Dells and Alienwares and Surface Books and ThinkPads and Razers, comfortably in the Wintel world. But the Apple Silicon laptops are so far ahead it's not even a comparison. Especially if you want to be able to run Photoshop natively (ie not emulated in Linux). Forget the metal dings. The new ones have smoother edges, I think. Run an automatic backup to somewhere else. The hardware is so so so much better than anything else out there there's not really a comparison. I doubt anyone else would catch up within 5 years either. At the end of the day they're just tools, not some religious argument. At this point in time they're substantially better than anything else, by a large margin, especially for dev and creative work. I also use IntelliJ and Photoshop side by side, and these crazy machines last the whole day on battery power without the fans ever kicking on or anything getting slow. The poor throttled Thinkpad X1 isn't even remotely close in performance. Shrug. Sorry, probably not the answer you wanted to hear. But Apple did some serious engineering in those while Microsoft and Intel sat on their butts for a decade.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the Lenovo ThinkPad X1Lenovo ThinkPad X1: Neutral
You just made me to get my MacBook out of closet :) (I stopped using it two months ago and moved to X1 carbon right before pandemic) The ergonomic of \ {X} is exactly the same on it as on my carbon x1, my keychron tls and four other keyboards I happen to have in my drawer. Are You using modified Apple II like Rebecca Heineman or some kind of super small keyboard that looks like someone forgot to put all the keys in :) ? Either way its on you not Java. (Dont take this wrong way - this is an honest question - here in Poland almost all keyboard are backslash friendly and I would live to knowe where this is not the case)
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the Lenovo ThinkPad X1Lenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
> I could go on but as someone who has used MacOS for years and generally appreciates it, Apple really doesn't care much for developers. Other than its POSIX shell, MacOS doesn't have much going for it. This is why I couldn't justify continuing spending money on Apple (computer) hardware, I don't want to feel like a second-rate citizen on the platform I spend most of my time on. I used and loved MacBooks for a long time, but eventually I got tired of fighting against the one I'm giving money to for hardware, and had to switch away. I'm gonna be honest and say that recent M2 laptops from Apple almost got me to buy one yet again, after a couple of years of hiatus from Apple laptops, but my wife reasonably reminded me about how much I bitched about various things last time I used their laptops for work. Ended up with another Carbon X1, and everything works as expected, battery works OK and so on. But a side of me would love a laptop, but I need the maker to actually want to support me, not make it feel like sometimes they work against me.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the Lenovo ThinkPad X1Lenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
Agree. Few years ago I asked my employer to change Mac for something else and I got the 7th gen (Intel 8th gen processor) X1 Carbon, I fall in love and now I bought the latest 10th gen model (Intel 12th gen) and I very much like it. Super light and silent, great keyboard and also I like the touchpad on the latest model, it become even better. Build quality is the best, hinges are balanced very well that when you shake the laptop screen doesn’t move a bit but you can still open it with one hand. From the cons - it’s hot comparing to the 7th gen and also the battery life is slightly lower.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the Lenovo ThinkPad X1Lenovo ThinkPad X1: Neutral
Thinkpad W541 (i7, 32gb RAM, SSD), running Fedora, often connected to an external monitor, mouse and keyboard. For travel, I use Thinkpad X1 Carbon (3rd gen), also running Fedora. Nowadays I mostly work on native Android dev, so environment is primarily just AndroidStudio, vim, terminal (Guake) and what seems like hundreds of open tabs. It used to be all Macbooks for many years though. I still have a 2012 tricked out Air and a 2013 rPro, which I need to sell off.
Switched from the Apple MacBook to the Lenovo ThinkPad X1Lenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
I recently bought a gen4 ThinkPad X1 Carbon. Despite a couple of issues first getting started with Linux (I've been using OS X for years aside from running Ubuntu on my web servers) I'm now happily on Fedora 23. There was a kernel bug that I think is being patched atm, requiring booting with intel_pstate=no_hwp but no problems with Fedora other than that. When discussing this on the ThinkPad subreddit a Red Hat employee mentioned that their standard issue work laptops are ThinkPads with Red Hat Enterprise installed, but most engineers then switch to Fedora. As a result Fedora tends to run very well on ThinkPads (according to him and in my so far limited experience), as they have many Red Hat engineers working on that OS every day.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1: Likes it
Eh cheaper than now for sure. I got my old G1 X1 Carbon for somewhere between 900 and 1100 from memory. Theres a fair discount in there mind, but its not a discount I could possibly hope to replicate these days. (I think that was 1600 dollars partner pricing - charity discount - volume discount (hopped on an order for 12 already identical already going through) - tax incentives) The cheapest Gen 13 Carbon currently available is ~ 2600 in the same currency, and that's already discounted by 9%, and has a shittier OS (Ships with Home edition instead of Pro), I doubt that would get below 2200 even with partner/channel pricing. If you add "Winflation" that is, Windows 7/8 running perfectly smoothly on the Gen 1 with 8 Gig of memory, the replacement thinkpad being one that runs Windows 11 comfortably would be the $3150 in the same money, for its 32GB memory. Again doubtful it would go below 2700 or so even with channel. Macbook NEO is funnily enough 900 bucks landed for me, with 8 gig of memory. I am betting the user experience of the thing is as good or if not better than my old carbon.