The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook vs Lenovo ThinkPad

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Lenovo ThinkPad.

Apple MacBookLenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion26082732
Positive verdicts61% of 225475% of 2366
Positive/negative since 2024718/459686/273
Happy after 3+ years161281
Longest happy owner18 yrs25 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forease of usebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
I triple booted macOS on my Thinkpad specifically because my Macbook had one of the worst keyboards I had ever used. For the brief period where Apple refused to sell you non-Butterfly keyboards, it was one of the best ways to use macOS.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I keep a Linux laptop on the side and usually buy what Linux fans recommend and is Linux certified, which is typically some kind of ThinkPad. It is certainly usable, but I wouldn't recommend it to most people. It starts with much worse quality (not Linux' fault), like worse displays, borderline unusable fingerprint scanners, etc. But beyond that, I regularly get kernel panics recovering from sleep with a Thunderbolt display connected (last time I checked the exact DDC-related bug has been open for a while). With some displays the USB-C get misconfigured (another known bug), resulting in worse frame rates. Sometimes hardware doesn't come up after a resume. Battery life is generally much worse. Even if you hyperoptimize it with powertop, etc. battery life is still much worse. Not only that, but it puts Bluetooth and USB in autosuspend, which often breaks waking by using an external mouse or keyboard. Even if your laptop still supports S3 sleep, the system often runs out of battery while suspended in 12-24 hours (yes, it's fully suspended and does not wake). I could go on for a while, it's death by a thousand paper cuts. We have a bunch of MacBooks in the family. They are insanely fast, batteries last forever, and I cannot remember the last time I had a panic. Displays always work between Apple Studio Display, Dell Thunderbolt, and a bunch of USB-C LG displays. But yeah, I'm still keeping a Linux laptop around, just in case Apple restricts macOS more, extends their surveillanc…
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Yeah i can vouch for the macbook neo as well. My macbook neo outperforms my thinkpad x13g1 (ryzen 7, 8c16t, 32gb memory, amd gpu) on all metrics. It’s snappier, battery lasts more, i have the same disk storage (500gb)
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
It's the opposite feeling for me. Not sure about other brands but pretty much any ThinkPad I use, the touchpad just feels right. Whereas on Macbooks it's just off, at least ever since the first Retina generation (my first contact with it). Macbooks' touchpads are usually also way too big and, sadly, even Lenovo follows this bad trend in some of their models.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
macos desktop aesthetics have regressed, they managed to screw the rounded corners and the colors are too much macbook m series processor laptops have the camera notch and frankenturd look and feel thinkpads feel better and the hinge opens all the way
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
You get an Apple product. At least, for me it was that simple. The ThinkPad I had was pretty high end, and I was using polarized glasses and even a sun shade to work at the park while the girls played. Bought a MacBook and the screen seems to crisply outshine even the sunniest days -- I haven't had to worry about outdoor use since, to my recollection.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Dunno about other manufacturers, but Thinkpads removed S3. Stock BIOS on some T14 G3 had S3 enabled still apparently, but it was removed by subsequent BIOS updates. The notebook market is dead for me if the notebook can't sleep on 0.3% battery per hour and if it can't wake up within a second or so. So far only macbooks and >5 years old Intel notebooks can.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
I got into Linux because it gave me things I couldn't get with Windows/Mac (in 1994). There are less things that is true for now, by far. I am drawn to the ideals of Free Software (maybe BSD style, maybe GNU style) like a moth to the flame. Nonetheless, I have a smartphone, which since 2016 has been an iPhone. Now there are things I can't get with Linux that I value with macOS. The integration with the phone is just not possible if am running Linux. The power management and convenient things like Apple Music, too. I was disgusted to see Tim Cook abase himself before Trump and spent a while researching alternative phones. I did not find anything that looked like a serious option. There are things I need that are only available for iPhone or Android, it's become table stakes for life nowadays. My E-car charger required an app to function, for instance. I admire people who "vote with their wallet" and/or suffer inconvenience for their ideals. But I am not going to install Linux (or OpenBSD) on my M1 Macbook pro. It's too essential for me the way it is. For the record, I pour a lot of time into my 2014 macbook running arch and a thinkpad running OpenBSD, and keep an arch server/desktop running pretty much 24/7. I spend tons of time trying to find/devise things on Linux to match things I use that are closed-source/apple only. Hats off to people who can program at the level required to make this happen. It's beyond me. And also to those trying to make Pine Phone etc a realistic opt…
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
> I don't know about Thinkpads, but the utterly pleasant glass trackpad is still one of the things I cannot find on most non-Mac laptops, despite every manufacturer being able to copy it for years. I was never a trackpad person until I finally got a Mac at work maybe 10 years ago. But since the trackpads stopped really clicking in favor of haptics, they're a lot worse than they used to be. I get false/double clicks and inconsistent feedback. ThinkPads have nicer keyboards, but they stopped doing the more traditional IBM layout several years ago, which is really unfortunate. I'd be willing to pay for a more traditional keyboard layout with a slightly smaller trackpad and/or a sizeable bottom bezel (which is actually preferable for me because of my posture when I use a laptop most of the time).
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Definitely agreed, to a point. Phones I used to break so often it seemed worth it, although a lot seemingly had to do with device quality vs. me being especially clumsy. My iPhone has been dropped, dunked in the bath, etc. just as much as my past Pixels but is going on 3 years now. I never made it a year previously. My laptop I'm on the fence about. It's a $3,000 machine that isn't especially robust if dropped, but I haven't broken one in a decade or two. Probably won't pick it up on the next one I buy. The unrepairability of modern Macbooks is what got me to buy it in the first place though. An old Thinkpad I could self-insure for quite cheap because I had the ability to replace any component failure myself. Not so true on the Macbook. I also see it as travel insurance - I can walk into any Apple store in a major city and in theory get a replacement device on the spot. Of course that theory has yet to be strongly tested.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Thanks for pointing this one out. I am hesitant to buy Apple accessories like these as I am having quality concerns. Specifically the macbook chargers I've encountered are far less rigid than Lenovo Thinkpad chargers (at least before they switched to USB-C). I never felt Apple did a particularly good job with cables and connectors when it comes to longevity.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
To everybody trying to justify apple not offering a wwan option. On Thinkpad you can add the module later. It's a simple upgrade, open up the laptop and plug in the wwan module. The Thinkpad already comes with a sim tray. Though today presumably you would use an esim. But hey you can pick a color for your macbook, so that's something. Extra rant: the hardware quality of modern MacBook is fantastic. The keyboard sucks. The reflective screen sucks. The number of ports is ridiculously small. Soldered ssd and ram etc etc. Fantastic battery life. My thinkpad is a turd in comparison. But at least it doesn't bend when dropped. MacOS is horrible, Linux is the only thing I want. Sleep on modern PC is broken by design. A MacBook sleeping loses 1% of battery per day. A thinkpad loses 100%. Why can't we have nice things god dammit.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I got my first MacBook around 2010 because I was tired of fixing suspend to RAM every few Nvidia driver updates on my ThinkPad. Then I paid for a commercial VM to seamlessly run some Windows software I needed for my freelance work as a translator, removing the need to dual boot two operating systems. Everything just worked, and I could focus on things I wanted to do instead of continuing to tinker with the OS itself. And after years of playing with many different Linux distros, I realised that I did get tired of that. Moreover, a few games that I played, actually had native Mac versions. What's not to like? These days I do have a Tuxedo laptop for fooling around, and I don't even use laptops on the regular, which is probably why it works well enough. That and integrated Radeon graphics, I'm sure.
Apple MacBook: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I don't get the love for ThinkPads. They must be the most overrated product I've used. I've had several ThinkPads (always corporate T series) and MacBooks in the house over the last decade or so. Every time I find the Macbook far superior in terms of just about everything. Battery, display touchpad, speakers, thermals, aesthetics. I could never get used to the nipple-mouse but using my thumb on a MacBook trackpad is very easy. The ThinkPads have slightly deeper keyboard travel that's about the only good thing I can say.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I believe there is a kernel of truth here, but having used both the mainstream products and their "underdog" alternatives, this is completely counter to my experience. Nokia is a bit before my time, but I've used both iPhones and Androids and simply cannot suffer iPhones anymore. There are so many features of Android that are impossible to replicate on Apple products. Even something as simple as blocking ads is a fool's errand on iOS. I make extensive use of third-party app stores, patching .apk files, and my device's filesystem. I laugh when iOS introduces a new features that's been included in Android for half a decade. I've had to suffer many work Macbooks and vastly prefer both the hardware and (Linux) software stack on non-Apple laptops. The history of Apple hardware and OS X (sorry, macOS) is littered with blunders such as the touchbar, keyboard issues, and now Liquid Glass. Is a ThinkPad the holy grail of PCs? Probably not, but they've been a lot more reliable in my experience. NVIDIA's Linux drivers are especially laughable. After years of wrangling their drivers, struggling to make sleep work, and getting X/Wayland rendering working reliably, at this point I can't bother. I simply disable any discrete NVIDIA laptop GPUs entirely and use the integrated graphics. It just works better and doesn't drain my battery. On a desktop I'm with AMD all the way. I promise you, I have plenty of experience with both sides and I am most definitely not "suffering under inferior tech"…