The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook vs Dell XPS

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook.

Apple MacBookDell XPS
Owners with an opinion2608659
Positive verdicts61% of 225448% of 583
Positive/negative since 2024718/45972/97
Happy after 3+ years16149
Longest happy owner18 yrs20 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forease of usebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook: NeutralDell XPS: Likes it
Apple makes nice hardware, but it's definitely not superior for everything, and the gap between other manufacturers isn't really there anymore on the upper end. So sure - the Macbook is better than a cheap ~$500 laptop. But between my work issued Macbook and my nice Dell XPS? Not much difference. In either price or hardware... Honestly, even between the macbook and my framework - not enough of a difference to really be that upset about (my biggest complaint is mostly just battery life). --- Personally, I would argue that OS is a much bigger pain point to deal with, and you should probably factor that higher in the decision than the hardware. Just expect to spend roughly the same on the machine (Apple is still ~20% more)
Apple MacBook: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I agree with you on the precedent > after MS implemented precision touchpads somewhere in 2015, and suddenly Windows touchpads became as precise as those on Macs. There’s still a world of difference between a MacBook touchpad and a windows one. My work laptop (18 month old dell XPS) can’t hold a candle to my 6 year old MacBook’s trackpad. > Likewise with RGB peripherals. Even GPU driver applications have increasingly become less useful as the most important features—power control, adaptive sync, HDR, etc have moved into native Windows settings. The peripherals still need the addons though; I have ASUS armory crate, Corsair iCue and MSI center for my Motherboard, cooler and GPU respectively. They all suck.
Apple MacBook: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
> There’s still a world of difference between a MacBook touchpad and a windows one. My work laptop (18 month old dell XPS) can’t hold a candle to my 6 year old MacBook’s trackpad. The latest Dell trackpads are quite bad. Price or the product being premium or not unfortunately does not tell you if it will have a good trackpad or not. And it changes over time (Dell XPS used to have really good trackpads) Basically you have to go to a store and try or find reviews that actually pay attention to this.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itDell XPS: Likes it
It is well-documented that Panther Lake is highly power efficient. I wouldn’t personally argue against that. The days of assuming that Apple has the best chip efficiency are coming to an end, especially if the Windows/Qualcomm platform is a workable choice for your needs (maybe someday Linux support will get better). Apple still has a lead but it’s small enough that it’s not a good reason to choose an Apple system on its own. The M1 MacBook systems got double the battery life of competitors, now 5 years later, Apple systems are at best getting ~10% better battery life than competitors, and some systems like the XPS 14 have Apple beat entirely. Obviously getting 20 hours in real world productivity use was never realistic, and it’s not realistic on a MacBook Pro, either. I disagree that framework was “basically lying.” They live-streamed the laptop hitting 20 hours, it doesn’t matter that they changed settings to get there. MacBooks have a brightness slider, too. You aren’t getting anywhere close to 20 hours on a MacBook without turning the screen brightness down. IIRC the MacBook Air/Pro can’t even make it to 20 hours regardless of settings. The point is that the new framework 13 Pro laptop isn’t a 5-7 hour battery life experience like the previous models. Instead, you can expect 10+ hours depending on what you’re doing it, so it’s a full work day.
Apple MacBook: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
This is a very impressive release. At 17h to 20hr battery life on Linux, I'll finally be a able to solve my MacBook addiction. With my M2 MacBook running Asahi Linux or my work M3 MacBook running MacOS I easily get 10+hrs on battery. I've made several "attempts" to jump ship from Apple hardware before, like the dell XPS "developer edition" which ships with Linux so all the hardware was supported out of the box; the hardware was OK, but the battery life was abysmal. If I can't get 8hr of battery on a machine battery it's just a portable desktop.
Apple MacBook: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I had an XPS laptop purchased around 2020. It was a very well spec-ed machine on paper and worked reasonably well. It just did not hold up. 1. Bulging battery - replaced 2. USB-C charging blew up the charge controller - laptop completely unable to charge - replaced motherboard 3. USB-C charging blew up the charge controller again (~6 months later) #3 was out of warranty and I had just changed companies so it went into the trash. It lasted 3 years tops. I also have a dell ultrasharp 4K monitor that had to be replaced under warrant within ~1 year of purchase and I am just waiting for it to go again now that it is out of warranty. Dell seems to have had reasonable service(in-warranty) but their stuff is always breaking down. I have had several macbooks. Each lasted ~10 years+.
Apple MacBook: NeutralDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I had the 17" XPS, which was lovely. A nice 16:10 screen, which was the main thing I was looking for. Battery was easy to replace. Easy memory and M2 drive replacement. It was a pretty good laptop for x86. Main issue was heat/sound. Linux was pretty easy to get going on that hardware. You could get at the internals - so cleaning out the fan was doable. (order new screws, as they ship with silly soft metal on the orignals) https://i.imgur.com/4SdAQu9.jpeg When they released the 16" series, most of the updgrade features were gone. Memory was tied to the CPU, which puts you in the same position that Apples does. Not a fan. I swapped out the 17" for a 16" macbook. I doubt I'll look at an XPS again.
Apple MacBook: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I don't see how AI has anything to do with it. I have been running asahi Linux for more then a year with less issues then running a Dell XPS before that. I don't think calling it an intellectual exercise is fair here. These MacBooks are better Linux devices then a lot of laptops. With some hardware support still missing currently.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itDell XPS: Likes it
I really wish that "elite" LLM folks like yourself or many others in the field would just abandon apple/mac. Yes, they make better laptops from a hardware perspective. No, M series chips are not actually competitive with Nvidia hardware on anything except cheap (and relatively slow) inference of big models. The fact that windows laptops are considered DOA despite the insane amount of inertia behind Nvidia GPUs is just sad. I want a world where Dell/Lenovo can actually convince folks like you or other "elites" to use their shit. The XPS should be a better laptop than the macbook pro. Yet, I have to watch as the technical elites fawn over a company which continues to sell a starting level un-upgradable laptop with 8gb of ram and a gimped "SSD" in 2024 (this was criminal to do back in 2018) all because other companies can't make a good keyboard or touchpad. I have a similar old-man yelling at cloud tier rant about the slow death of X86...
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itDell XPS: Likes it
My 15 inch macbook which fried its display twice (didn't go to sleep properly and then put in a bagpack and overheated. There is no way to see that the sleep didn't kick in), and then had the broken display cable problem (widespread and Apple wanted $900 for a new display..) would disagree. For comparison: The 4k touch display on my xps15 that didn't survive a diet coke bath was <$300 including labor for a guy to show up in my office and repair it while I was watching....
Apple MacBook: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
After switching from an 11th gen Intel Dell XPS, to a M1 Macbook, I won't go back to PC (even though I prefer Windows) until someone confirms that newer Ryzen and Intel chips are comparable in terms of "perceived performance" to Apple silicon. The whole laptop simply becomes syrupy on battery. Even if I go high performance mode in Windows settings, the whole device is just so laggy compared to a Macbook. And, in high performance mode, the laptop has probably at _most_ 2 hours of battery life in it. Has this improved since 11th gen Intel?
Apple MacBook: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
Nice. Now try to do the same as (some types of) programmer or 3d modeller or video editor. The newest MacBook with an M2 chip compiles and runs my projects drastically faster than the 2015 Dell XPS Skylake-i7 laptop I used to have and the GPU on the M2 is so ridiculously more powerful it's like going from 3dfx voodoo to a modern GPU.
Apple MacBook: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
One thing to consider is resale value. When I tried reselling old Windows laptops like a Surface or XPS, the value dropped off a cliff from the MSRP. I would spend $2000 on a laptop and then it was selling for $700 used on ebay a year later. With MacBooks (and other Apple products) you can often recoup 70%-80% of your initial cost as long as it's in good condition.
Apple MacBook: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I have had a few dell XPSs, newest one was a 2019 one and they work, but they were not even close to the quality of the full macbook package. The keyboard was dogshit, the webcam didn't work on linux, the mic picked up huge amounts of fan noise, finger print scanner didn't work on linux and the maintainers of the open source drivers believed the hardware to be critically insecure so there is no reason you'd want it supported anyway. You could upgrade the ram on the 16" versions though which is nice. Although this is still not something I have ever done on a laptop. The new Macbooks now have easily replaceable batteries which is a welcome change.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itDell XPS: Likes it
I used a dell xps with ubuntu/gnome for years that used to get me 7-10 hours of battery life as long as I turned wifi off and was working in sublime text. This was more than I got on windows, and more than my macbook got at the time Linux is great Not sure why this is getting downvoted