The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook vs Apple PowerBook

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple PowerBook.

Apple MacBookApple PowerBook
Owners with an opinion260882
Positive verdicts61% of 225476% of 75
Positive/negative since 2024718/45927/8
Happy after 3+ years16110
Longest happy owner18 yrs24 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and comfort
Criticized forease of useperformance and portability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook: NeutralApple PowerBook: Likes it
Yeah the sharp edges have bothered me since they started with the unibody. Luckily I'm completely off Mac these days. But really the last mac I enjoyed using was my powerbook. It had really nice plastic gaskets for the edges, a keyboard with really good travel and cupped keys, it was wonderful. I got a plastic MacBook eventually which I filed down too because the edges were really sharp there. And plastic is easy to file. Also replaced the screen with a matte version, on the plastic MacBook that was also easy because the screens were readily available and there was no glass overlay. Then I had a unibody MBP 15" matte. Less sharp and with off factory matte display. Not great keyboard though. The current MBP I find abhorrent. Even after they switched from the horrible butterfly mistake the travel is still way too shallow. I just can't work with that anymore. These days I just don't buy laptops anymore. Only desk PCs.
Apple MacBook: NeutralApple PowerBook: Likes it
It's funny: there was a time when Apple understood that it could attract customers by making its devices the first choice for developers. And it did a good job, with a real Unix underneath that wasn't overly hidden, with a lot of open source support, and just generally being an ok citizen in the developer world. That strategy, which I think ran from early OSX through until mid-2010's? worked, and you'd see the results, with a sea of glowing Apple logos, even at Linux conferences. I think they've changed since then. It feels now like developers are not a priority, even as they've re-added some power-user features in recent years. As for longevity, I think my current laptop speaks for itself. It's now 11 years old, and going strong. I've carried it around the world, dropped it numerous times, and it's been the best laptop I've every owned. They do artificially force an end-of-life, usually at around 7 years old, for their operating system. I don't really have a problem with that: I appreciate that it's difficult to continue to support old hardware in new releases, and I think that timeframe is reasonable. I'd prefer that it was explicitly stated, and I'd prefer it was longer, but ... it's not bad, really. Over the years I have had many devices: desktop PCs, Unix workstations, Linux workstations, and laptops from 6" to 17". In the early 2000s I bought a 12" Powerbook, which was my first Mac -- the motivation was to get seamless Microsoft Office document support on a Unix…
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Likes it
I sure do. Modern OS UIs might be visually rich and feature-packed, but this definitely came at the cost of clarity and efficiency. Because I do a lot of writing, I keep an old thinkpad and an old PowerBook running NT 4 and Mac OS 9 respectively. There's just something about those grays and the straightforward, no-nonsense UIs that allows me to work without distractions. I can't say the same thing about my macbook and all of its colorful superfluous features. Of course, since those OSes are ancient, it's more difficult to access the internet which also helps quite a lot with me being more focused on my work.
Apple MacBook: NeutralApple PowerBook: Doesn’t like it
I have not heard anything about SSD issues from my friends in the IT department who service hundreds of laptops… Personally I’m still running an M1 MacBook Air which has been bulletproof for almost 4 years now. Before that I ran a 12” MacBook for 5 years. My last problem with a Mac laptop was in the 17” PowerBook days, circa 2010 (I suspect the case flexed and damaged the logic board)
Apple MacBook: NeutralApple PowerBook: Likes it
When it come to anecdotes... I've got a powerbook and an ibook both still alive and kicking after close to 5 years and apart from the battery that I had to replace, they haven't had any problems (despite using them a lot)... On the other hand my 2 years old macbook is starting to make some strange sound (the fan probably needs to be changed)... I think that anecdotes are only that and in my experience once you have a problem with a laptop it's usually going to be more than one problem...
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Likes it
The longest I've ever had a Mac was six years, when I used a Mac Plus from 1989-1995, when I got my dads old IIsi. Then in 1996 I bought a Quadra 605, and in 1998 I bought a PowerMac 7200, and in 2000 I bought a new iMac. In 2001 I bought a Powerbook Lombard 400, and in 2002 I bought a G4/466. Then in 2003 I bought a new Powerbook 12" 1ghz, and that worked perfectly for me for three years until December 2006 when I bought a new Macbook which needed a new motherboard six months later. Since then it's worked pretty OK though it does seem to completely lock up every now and then requiring a forced shutdown, which didn't happen with the old Powerbook 12" if I recall correctly. Our 4 year old Dell PC has worked perfectly and we will continue to use it until it blows up.
Apple MacBook: Likes itApple PowerBook: Likes it
Yeah... my solution for the last 3 decades (with a grain of salt) has been to buy the most expensive apple laptop every 6 years and never, ever update the OS. Rolling everything over to a new dev environment every 6 years is annoying but manageable. This way I took a Powerbook 3400 into the intel age, took a titanium macbook into the air age, took two airs for almost a decade from 10.4 to 10.10 or something, then an M1. Which I'm still using. The 3400 still boots into OS 9 or something. I feel like I'm forgetting one. But the point is this: Apple software usually suits the hardware it's released with, and taking their updates is always a bad idea. Just get comfy with homebrew and settle down for your 30s or 40s until you've broken all the keys and the fan stops working.
Apple MacBook: Likes itApple PowerBook: Likes it
I really liked the 12" MacBook (although my all time favourite computer was the 12" PowerBook G4 - chunky by today's standards but I just loved it). I saw a review of the MacBook Neo where the reviewer was yearning after the 12" - but suggested that Apple has made UI elements so big with such ridiculous spacing and border radius that it would be almost unusable at anything less than 13". Which would not surprise me in the least - I struggle with my 16" MBP and this crappy UI "framework".
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Doesn’t like it
I was hoping someone like Musk (who is temperamental) would tell them to spin on it. Politicians tend to use Twitter a lot. I don't rate Apple's hardware. The screens are nice, but everything else isn't that much substantially better (and sometimes worse) IME if you consider the tradeoffs further down the line when the machine gets a few years old. I've own many PowerBooks and MacBooks in the past and the machine is nice when you first get it and then it becomes an expensive mouse pad.
Apple MacBook: Likes itApple PowerBook: Likes it
My 12" powerbook from 2002 lasted well into 2011 until I formally retired it by giving to a mate. Most of my macbook airs have lasted at least 7 to 8 years. None have actually died and were still intact, but I just gave them away, so I don't know how much longer they lasted. My 2015 macbook pro (pre butterfly) is still going strong today; I did a battery replacement myself which was a huge pain in the arse, so it definitely feels replenished. I have replaced many of my family members laptops with M-series laptops, nay issue, and I have a feeling they'll easily go a decade, though at some point they'll all need the battery replaced (but I will probably just have Apple do it this time - unless it is easy now with the repair manuals being available by Apple).
Apple MacBook: Likes itApple PowerBook: Likes it
Yeah, same here -- my Macbooks (and the Powerbooks before them) have been the most solid, reliable, and long-lived laptops of my entire life (and I'm 55). I'm still using a 10 year old one as a poor-man's-NAS-controller. And the backup system that ships with the tool is insanely solid -- while I don't trust any single backup solution alone, the one time I did have to recover from backup (we were robbed), Time Machine had my new machine in exactly the same state as my stolen one within about 2h. I'm sure with faster bus speeds and drives now, it'd be even faster.
Apple MacBook: Likes itApple PowerBook: Likes it
I'm surprised... what encouraged you to update MacOS? I'm on the first M1 Macbook from 2020 and have not allowed a single OS update. The first thing I do with a mac is use Little Snitch to block all apple IP addresses, and delete all their built in apps. I still have an Air from 2015 and one from 2009, a Titanium from 2004 and a chunky old Powerbook 3400 from the 1990s that all run fine. One or two a decade. But I never update the OS because I don't want to deal with anything that might break my environment.
Apple MacBook: Likes itApple PowerBook: Likes it
I believe the primary appeal of a 12” laptop is that it’s the smallest that one can make a laptop while still having a full size keyboard. Any smaller and you have to start shrinking keys, which has strong negative effects on usability. This is part of why the 12” MacBook and its spiritual ancestor, the 12” PowerBook G4 were popular.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Doesn’t like it
I remember playing with the OS X Beta. We'd install it on a friends Powerbook G3 and after a couple days go back to OS 9 because it was so much faster and it didn't use all your memory. Not too soon after that, I bought a Powerbook G4. 867MHz, and Mac Mall doubled the RAM back then so I had 256 or 512MB, I forget. It was still pretty slow and after fumbling around with it for a few months, I sold it. Was nice for playing with iMovie using a Firewire VHS-C camera, though. Then around 2006, a friend purchased one of the first Intel MacBook models. We had fun trying to get all of his old PowerPC era stuff working on it. It was still slow, and hot. Finally, in 2010 I bought a 13" MacBook Pro and was in love ever since. Not sure how everyone else stuck around so long.
Apple MacBook: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Doesn’t like it
The tibooks whose paint rubbed off from wrist rubbing? With the flexy keyboards? And the dvd drive that would flex into the disk if your wrist was resting above it? The 1st gen intel MacBooks which had a heat pipe that would short out the system when it got warm? The 24” iMacs that would cook the hard drive after 2 years due to bad thermals? (And eventually, the backlight too).