The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs System76

Hacker News owners slightly favor the System76.

Apple MacBook ProSystem76
Owners with an opinion3902312
Positive verdicts62% of 327669% of 280
Positive/negative since 2024945/59249/23
Happy after 3+ years35533
Longest happy owner16 yrs20 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forbatterybuild quality and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itSystem76: Likes it
For a long time, I had a MBP (this is in Intel days), with a Linux VM. It was like a reverse mullet, party in front (multimedia), work in back (dev). And then: - Butterfly keyboard - Touchbar - M-series CPUs, which, while technically awesome, did not allow for Linux VMs. So I switched to System76/Linux (Pop OS) and that has been wonderful, not to mention, much cheaper.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
I got tired of fiddling with Ubuntu settings. I got tired with updates making my desktop UX worse and having to battle to get things back to what I wanted. I got tired of struggling to get wifi to work. Maybe more than any of that, though, I got tired of every laptop having bad build quality. Maybe the Dell XPS is good, but Lenovo and System76 (my last Linux machine) seemed significantly worse than a MBP. (I could maybe just run Linux on a MBP, but it's a lot more effort for little benefit.) I would like to replicate my 2005 Ubuntu desktop environment, but when Ubuntu shipped Unity, it was a serious downgrade, and at the time I struggled to get back to something good. I'm now in a macOS middle ground without having to fight the damn thing.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itSystem76: Likes it
My daily driver was a MacBook Pro for many years, and I went through two 17", and I think two 15" models. And then: butterfly keyboards, touch bars, and this code signing nonsense, so that I couldn't even run my own little bash scripts. At that point, I left the Apple world, and I have been a very happy customer of System76 running PopOS ever since. I was almost tempted back with the M1 chip. A spectacular CPU, a cool and quiet laptop, no more butterfly keyboard, no more touchbar. But I can't run Linux on it. Sorry, Apple, this isn't working. It's not me, it's you.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itSystem76: Likes it
As a AMD fanboy, I have been using the Pangolin for a few months now. I can't currently use PopOS (Intune only works on LTE Ubuntu), so I'm not getting the full benefits of the laptop - notably the battery life. I get about 5hr with a pretty big stack of containers running, as well as working in Rider. This is strictly less than the M1 that I was using prior to this laptop. A flight-safe Anker battery pack bumps it up to the 10hr I was hoping for. Performance-wise? It makes the M1 look like a complete joke. Our MITM proxy (ZScaler, a truly terrible product) is CPU-bound, and the M1 would stutter during large container image pulls. I don't notice pulls on the Pangolin - I just keep working while they happen in the background. Builds are on the order of 30% faster. It also handles two external monitors. Something is strange with secure boot and the System76 kernel; I just couldn't get it working. Monitor is average, definitely less usable in sunlight (by virtue of being actually unusable) than Apple's offerings. Keyboard and touchpad are great. I did have some issues with the touchpad, and support told me to (gasp!) open the laptop and make sure the ribbon cable was seated properly - 10/10 repairability.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
I am sure I will get all kinds of hate for saying this: despite the extra up front cost, apple stuff is a better value. Lets take device lifetime: I have a 2013 MBP 15 and 2015 MBP 15. I use them for intensive things like music production. Both devices work flawlessly. I also a System 76 Oryx Pro which cost more than any mac I own. The webcam failed 5 months in, several keys don't work anymore, and it gets hotter than the surface of the sun when I ask it to do even moderate workloads. Its also ugly as shit. I don't really use it anymore. There is also resale value: I've been able to get at least a few hundred bucks for pretty much any apple device I've owned when I've sold it. My Oryx? No one wants that thing. Its gonna end up in a landfill at some point. In my experience, you pay more up front but you get more for your money in the long run.
Apple MacBook Pro: Recommends itSystem76: Likes it
I see very disparate use cases for these laptops, so the competition is not really that fair. - Fastest CPU + GPU + battery life, x64 not needed, money no object: M1 MBP. - Reliable, serviceable, upgradeable, fashion-despising: T14 / T480 / T490. - Serviceable, upgradable, but sort of new kids on the block, and less fashion-oblivious: Star Labs Starfighter, Framework, System 76 Oryx Pro. - Sleek-looking at the expense of everything soldered and glued down: Thinkpad X1, MBP 2019. - Open-source loving, more things under user's control: System 76 Oryx Pro, Star Labs Starfighter, partly Framework. Star Labs Starfighter looks incredible BTW, thanks to bringing it to my attention. I sorely miss a trackpoint though. No idea about others. I'd like to like HP Dev One, but I don't trust HP to make reliable things any more :( I wonder why no model from the Dell Latitude line made it here; I thought some of them have good Linux support.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
I bought a System 76 laptop a few years ago and stuff like this is why I went back to Apple. I was always dealing with one weird thing or another. One day it decides it wont wake from sleep if I have it in clamshell mode, another it decides it can't find my bluetooth peripherals. I finally rage quit when my webcam went down for no reason. I spent 2500 bucks on that thing and gave up on it in less than a year. Meanwhile, I have a 2015 MBP that runs like a champ. My new M1 air goes 2 days without a charge and I never have to think about dumb shit like waking from sleep. Oh and theres the resale value. I can't give away my S76 but I bet you if I put that 2015 MBP up on craigslist, it'll still fetch me a few hundred bucks... When I was a younger man with more free time I would have fought the good fight but these days? I just want my shit to work.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
Last year I finally replaced my old Macbook Pro with a Thinkpad running Pop OS. I'm so pleased with the operating system and the hardware. I want to support System76, but I read some not so positive anecdotes about their laptop's build quality, so went with the Thinkpad. I also wanted/needed a centered keyboard layout without numberpad, which they don't offer. Their desktop models look nice, but feel like a luxury when I can get a custom-built PC and just install Linux on it. Anyway, Pop OS is wonderful. I actually installed it on the old MBP too, and gave it new life. In addition: the Nordic theme makes for a beautiful interface, it's like what macOS should have become. https://github.com/EliverLara/Nordic
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
I had this laptop, but ultimately replaced it with a 14” M1 Max. Some thoughts: - The screen is so much worse, in every way, than a MacBook. A “low resolution” (more like, not high dpi) matte screen vs the M1 screen, there is no comparison. When I first got this machine, my eyes would have to adjust to the screen, and it felt so blurry compared to my works retina Touch Bar Mac - PopOS is great! It is definitely one of the best Linux desktops I’ve used. Manjaro gives it a nice run for it’s money… But.. next year is going to be the year of the Linux desktop! No disrespect to @jeremy_soller, because he is doing a killer job on Pop, but even in 2022, the Linux desktop is RC Cola, and MacOS is Genuine Coke Cola. I’m sure there are die hard RC Cola fans, but most of the world will definitely still prefer Coke Cola. - You would need to be pretty comfortable on a command line, and using Linux, to be comfortable using a Linux desktop. This computer would not be okay for my wife. - The keyboard keys started showing wear and tear after less than 9 months. The keys started to peel, basically, the home-row keys all lost their gloss coat where you could see it visibly that usage had caused a hole in the keys glossy layer. - I had a fully specced i7, and the performance was great. It out performed my works 2019 i7 MacBook with Touchbar. As for my M1… the M1 is faster. - I loved how the screen opened all the way 180 degrees, it was something I didn’t think I’d even care about, but it was ni…
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralSystem76: Likes it
I used OS X from 2013-2020 when my at-the-time companies gave me a top-end MBP and the very strong encouragement to use OS X. It was fine. But my most recent gig had a lot of Linux users anyway, so I returned to Linux, got a crappy System76 ultrabook, have Debian and StumpWM running on it, and couldn't be happier. I plan to use this laptop and not do much more than a `sudo apt-get dist-upgrade` until the 2030s. Maybe I'll replace the battery too.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itSystem76: Doesn’t like it
I have a mid-2015 MBP 15, which is great, but is a bit beat up (dropped it too many times). I use MacOS for consumer stuff, and a Linux VM for development. I'd like to replace the machine, but I'm stuck. The newer MBPs are a non-starter, due to the keyboard and touchpad. The Purism Librem 15 is expensive and doesn't put out 4k@60 to an external monitor. The System76 Galaga Pro hardware is not great (touchpad, battery life, general fit and finish). Not interested in running Windows at all, even just to host a VM. Razer looks like great hardware but doesn't support Linux. Any suggestions?
Apple MacBook Pro: Recommends itSystem76: Likes it
I love my early-2015 MBP. Best computer I ever owned - it hits the sweet spot between processing power, screen space, weight, battery life, durability, and features. No major problems other than a slightly off-kilter hinge (coming from dropping it edge-on), and it gets a lot of (ab)use. My next computer will likely be something Windows, though. Part of this is the horror stories I've heard about recent-model Macs, and part is because between this computer and my 2013 System76 Pangolin still working, I'll be able to cover all major OSes with it.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralSystem76: Recommends it
I have a 2-3 year old Gazelle and a 2015 mbp. Here's my opinion: the Apple has beautiful hardware, retina screen, and an nvidia gpu. I hate everything else about it (e.g. mac os). The Gazelle shell is just a System76 branded generic laptop, but it has an i7 and ssd. The thing is a powerhouse, and I use it for almost everything. My advice: if you want a solid development platform, System76 is the way to go (and will cost half as much). If you care more about a nice retina screen and dont mind mac os, stick with a mbp.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itSystem76: Recommends it
If you want something that runs linux well (I currently have Cent OS running on mine, and it comes pre-loaded with Ubuntu), I'd say System 76 is a pretty good choice. Their 15.6" version is pretty beefy ($1400 base), but even their 14" model looks good right now ($800 base). The model I use is a few years old, and is holding up really well. They have native drivers for pretty much everything, even the hardware switches are supported through the BIOS if I remember correctly, so when I loaded up other distros, nothing was a problem. Windows pretty much runs on everything, but my work computer is a Lenovo/ThinkPad T540P. It's base is $800, but the version I'm running is optioned out to about $1500-1800 I think (Core i7 (4 core), 8GB RAM, 256GB SSD). Great computer, I've had about 14 vm's running in VirtualBox running on it at once before memory started becoming a problem (again, with the optioned out specs). (also, I run Windows 7 Enterprise on this, so may be YMMV with Windows 10). both of those are superb, though I guess neither really competes build-quality wise with my 15" Macbook Pro Retina. I end up using that for almost anything that I don't need the GNU C/C++ toolchain for, which ends up being most stuff anyway.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itSystem76: Likes it
I've recently switched from a MBP to a System76 laptop, after about 5 years of running MacOS X, and I couldn't be much happier. The new MBPs are extremely harsh to type on between the sharp edge and the keyboard. I ultimately had to buy a Kinesis just to use it because the MBP destroyed my fingers. Most people don't have that problem, but it's nice to be able to actually use my laptop as a portable device again. I also really don't like the direction Apple is taking MacOS. Lion chugs resources and does odd things like disable my second monitor when apps go into fullscreen mode. I don't really care much for the direction of the Mac app store, too. LinuxMint has been great. It's the first time I've really run a Linux desktop since about 2003. What I miss is the polished apps. E.g., Adium is much better than Pidgin and Postbox or Sparrow are much better than Thunderbird. But, overall, I've been pleasantly surprised. Plus, I have 16 GB RAM now (could've gone up to 32 GB) and the OS consumes a lot less of RAM in general.
Switched from the Apple MacBook Pro to the System76System76: Likes it
Based on my experience with the System 76 Lemur Pro coming from a Macbook Pro, matte helps a bit. You won't have mirror glare like on the Macbook, but the sun will still wash out the matte screen.