The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Microsoft Surface Laptop

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Pro.

Apple MacBook ProMicrosoft Surface Laptop
Owners with an opinion390279
Positive verdicts62% of 327653% of 68
Positive/negative since 2024945/59219/23
Happy after 3+ years3550
Longest happy owner16 yrs2 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and build quality
Criticized forbatteryreliability and software
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Neutral
Isn’t that what I said? That it’s very good? I had a surface laptop, it was fine, not as good as a MacBook imo. Had a razer laptop, it was good, got very hot though. Had an X1 Carbon Extreme that I liked, wasn’t as good build quality or screen or camera or trackpad as my MBP from work at the time though, was still expensive af. What are you thinking of that’s better than a MacBook Pro?
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Doesn’t like it
> For months my windows 10 install would take nearly 5 minutes to start up after a full shutdown sequence. Funnily enough, I have that exact issue but the opposite. It takes nearly as long to shut down. Which I do often because still, in 2026, even on the Snapdragon surface laptop, I can't trust Windows to actually sleep when I close the laptop lid. I've had less issues with Linux, even sleep, than any modern windows box, and even less issues (pretty much none at all) on my daily driver MacBook Pro (plenty of annoyances and quirks here too though)
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Doesn’t like it
You can accomplish the same with Distrobox on Linux, but there's definitely something to be said about having the best of both worlds by running Windows + WSL. I honestly think Microsoft could win back some mind share from Apple if they: * Put out a version of windows without all the crap. Call it Dev edition or something and turn off or down the telemetry, preinstalled stuff, ads, and Copilot. * Put some effort into silicon to get us hardware with no compromises like the Macbooks I'm on Mac now, and I jump back and forth between Mac laptop and a Linux desktop. I actually prefer Windows + WSL, but ideologically I can't use it. It has potential - PowerToys is fantastic, WSL is great, I actually like PowerShell as a scripting language and the entire new PC set up can now be done with PowerShell + Winget DSC. But, I just can't tolerate the user hostile behavior from Microsoft, nor the stop the world updates that take entirely too long. They should probably do what macOS and Silverblue, etc. do and move to an immutable/read-only base and deploy image based updates instead of whatever janky patching they do now. Plus, I can't get a laptop that's on par with my M4 Pro. The Surface Laptop 7 (the arm one) comes close, but still not good enough.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Doesn’t like it
I purchased the Surface Laptop with the Snapdragon Elite and 64GB ram. The performance seems pretty decent, even while using Visual Studio on it and a few accompanying apps/tools. Battery lasts a decent amount, but nothing close to even 10 hours if you're doing work. There are surprisingly decent amount of apps that run on ARM now, and the x86 ones also run decently. The biggest issue I've had is the sleep - it drains significantly more battery than an MBP, and after a while it seems to go into hibernate which takes a very long time to reboot back into windows (30s-60s+). It's just completely inefficient at handling sleep still. The last issue is battery time when you are not doing lightweight browsing - the battery tends to go down a lot quicker. Charging is pretty slow, wish it could be faster via USB-C, but that's a design issue, not necessarily related to snapdragon. I really wanted to love it - but it's more of an expensive toy because of the battery/sleep. My MBP with the M2 Max still handles sleep infinitely better, and battery life is also significantly better when actually doing development on it. Im not a fan at all of MacOS, and I tend to RDP into my home machine most of the time, but even with that, I'd chose the MacBook for now over the ARM windows laptop.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Doesn’t like it
I bought it primarily for the 3:2 screen after getting a Surface Laptop, which was such a lemon that it spent more time in transit for service than in use before I got rid of it. Have since swapped out every component but the screen, antenna, and chassis; the old Intel mainboard, wifi, and audio card are now in the standalone Cooler Master case driving a projector as a media center and server. My work provides a M1 MBP; it's fine, but I usually bring my Framework when I want to get actual work done on the move. The Framework works with my external display but suffers from screen flicker on the M1.[1] 1: https://www.benq.com/en-us/knowledge-center/knowledge/how-to...
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Doesn’t like it
I have always noted this when listening to music on my M1 MBP. "There is NO way my tweeters aren't about to explode!" I recall how quickly the speakers in my Microsoft surface laptop self-destructed... In my experience, the #1 prerequisite to driving a speaker this aggressively without destroying it is having a clean source of power. Hard distortion and clipping are what break voice coils in direct, physical terms. Thermals can be tolerated over brief durations. I have found (in larger scale pro audio) that the amplifier topology can have a major impact on the amount of real power you can put into a loudspeaker. One of the most popular is Class D because it requires virtually no magnetics (i.e. no toroidal transformers). The tradeoff is that it needs to have a lot of safety nannies at the extremes and will have to attenuate aggressive program material. You almost always have to put a full-time DSP on these amplifiers. Compare this to Class A,A/B, G or H topologies which can be pushed well-beyond rated supply amperage for brief durations (i.e. your lights will dim slightly, rather than the amp/DSP limiting its power draw). You can drive these with any kind of signal you please, filtered with nannies or otherwise. These topologies are where I go when I want to be able to reach to DC on a loudspeaker and am willing to replace the drivers if I bump a knob the wrong way.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Neutral
I'm currently using a Mac for work because I don't have a choice. I know it's going to be flippant, but I'm genuinely surprised people like using Macs for development anymore. Hardware wise: Apple Silicon is very nice, but my enthusiasm is greatly tempered by a horrible experience with docks. So-called USB 4 docks and even plain USB-C docks work far less reliably on my MacBook Pro M1 Max than they do on PC laptops I have laying around. I can't even get a single monitor to 4k 60hz... Unless I plug any of my adapters into a non-Apple laptop. Weirdly, most of these docks don't seem to work at ALL on the M1 Mac Mini, or only sometimes. I'm genuinely puzzled. Software wise: Window management on macOS is extremely annoying. I'd try to run one of those i3 style tools, but... Full setup requires disabling SIP. Color me and my company's compliance team very unimpressed. I'm also on two kernel panics, apparently in some Bluetooth related module. Dude, I don't even USE Bluetooth on my work MacBook. I've sent reports to Apple... But I assume they're directed to the circular file. That's as much transparency as I get anyways. Major updates break XCode every time. Bazel runs slower than dirt. Sometimes I get stuck "verifying" binaries I just built. Why do we need to phone home to Apple for ad-hoc signed binaries we just built? Feels more like a Microsoft move. OTOH, I do get why people don't like Windows and Linux. Linux is unfriendly and requires a large time investment to really take adv…
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Recommends it
> Avoid Microsoft Surface Laptops, which require patches to run Linux, Microsoft doesn't offer an Image ready to burn on a stick. Is this indeed the case, and likely to continue for the foreseeable future? If so, that is really disappointing. I came in to recommend the Surface Laptop 4. You get the choice of an AMD or Intel processor, excellent build quality, and a 200dpi 3:2 touchscreen. And if you choose the "business" version, you can spec it with up to 32GB memory. My wife is a die-hard ThinkPad user, but I can't stand the widescreen nature of them. I love how the notch on my MBP gives me that little extra bit of vertical real estate. But that screen on the Surface Laptop! My kids and a niece have them, they are amazing.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Doesn’t like it
I’m ordering a grip of employee laptops to refresh our fleet and expand some departments. Because Teams is such a dog, my #1 requirement is 16GB RAM. Maybe Microsoft _wants_ Teams to be piggy to drive hardware sales? On another note I think Teams is actually an Electron app? I do think it runs better on my Intel MBP than my new Surface Laptop. But it’s still pretty buggy for such a high profile app.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Doesn’t like it
This is good news. I was about 95% of the way to purchasing a 14" MBP this weekend. The 13" is what I really want, having had a late 2013 13" model prior. I'm on a surface laptop 3 at the moment, but its pretty garbage compared to my experience with Apple previously. The keyboard is already starting to go out on me after barely 2 years of light use. I don't even write software on this thing. Assuming Apple doesn't shank this refresh with a stealth removal of magsafe or Fn key swap for touchbar, I'll be somewhere at the front of the line on launch day.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Likes it
> Other than Microsoft nobody even makes decent laptops in the Windows world. I completely agree. I actually quit like and get along with my Surface Laptop. It's a really nice computer overall, worthy. It's the closest you get to the same polish and usability that Apple has in their macbooks. I absolutely love my M4 macbook pro, it's definitely the best laptop I've ever owned. I had an older macbook pro that I kept way past its lifetime too.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Neutral
It may still work. The prism emulation is pretty good, almost on par with Rosetta2. I have the surface laptop 7 with the X elite in it. The only thing I've ran into that outright didn't run was MSSQL server. It's not my main machine, that is still an M4 Macbook pro but I hop on it occasionally to keep up with what Windows is doing or if I need to help someone with something windows specific. I've got WSL2, Docker, VSCode, etc. all running just fine. It's decent, but not amazing. Feels a little slower than my M2 Air I have but not much, most of that is probably just windows being windows. Would be nice to be able to get Linux running on one of these
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Likes it
I kinda followed a similar trajectory. Started with a 15" MBP (2011) for years, and was super happy with that. It was a beast. But it was also a tank of a laptop. Then I got a Surface Pro 3. It was FAR more portable, enough to make me realize just how much less portable my MBP was. I couldn't bear to bring the 15" back out. However, the SP3 was definitely too small of a screen for dedicated work. Great for college & notetaking, but reliant on external displays. Now I've been using a 13" surface laptop for a few years and that's really struck me as the right portability vs productivity balance. 13 inches is big enough for two columns of code, and fits in basically any backpack pouch easy. I probably won't be going back to 15" when this dies.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Laptop: Likes it
I'm completely on board with getting a long, full life out of a laptop. The only problem is that we've got plenty of thought-to-be-durable laptops around that are complete garbage, including a high-end Thinkpad. It's really sad to see. That said, our M1 MacBook Pro, an X1 carbon, and (very surprisingly) a Microsoft Surface Laptop Go (the cheap one that had terrible reviews - but with the SSD) are looking excellent in terms of long-term durability.