The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Microsoft Surface Book

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Pro.

Apple MacBook ProMicrosoft Surface Book
Owners with an opinion390295
Positive verdicts62% of 327652% of 77
Positive/negative since 2024945/59211/19
Happy after 3+ years3554
Longest happy owner16 yrs7 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and display
Criticized forbatteryreliability and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Book: Doesn’t like it
I've used one of the flagship Surface Books two jobs ago, really beefy, could run Cyberpunk(don't ask how I know). Insanely bad machine, the overall finish was terrible, hinges broke often, charging port broke often(like every 3rd-4th person in the office), it overheated with basic office work, fans went rocket level loud when compiling basic things, after a while it was stuttering even with casual use. Had a really good Dell XPS at home too that was dying when compiling big Typescript codebase. I bought an MBP M3Pro 1.5y ago and I could never go back. It's insane how far ahead Apple is when it comes to performance. Noone seems to grasp that until they actually try to work on M-series. Three of my ex colleagues also switched to Macbooks after I told them, they also are never coming back.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Book: Neutral
Sigh. I don't get the sentiment and the whole debate here. The author is clearly nitpicking (he is the first person who uses messages after all). But honestly, complaints about "arrange" screens button? Nevertheless, he is probably right. Only the people who went through working on Windows, Linux both on cheap and expensive machines while dealing with all the "baggage" these environments bring can tolerate MacOS with leniency. I will never come back to anything else until I see a competitive offer from just anyone because what Apple offers is: * Fast, silent, extremely energy efficient devices with excellent screens and audio. * The font rendering. I honestly can't believe people who professionally work with text all their lives never mention it here. MacOS had and continues to have the best fonts and font rendering that is. * Solid build that lasts (I own MacBook Pro and MS Surface Book 2 both from 2019 so I see how they age). * A device that is ready to work when you open a lid or touch a keyboard button without any "waking up from sleep/hibernation" or freezing due to buggy video drivers and inability to work with GPU in hybrid mode OUT-OF-THE-BOX in 2025. The above-mentioned is more than enough for me to tolerate any MacOS issues and the ones mentioned in the article are just laughable. Apple offers you the full package that allows cross-device integration while Win/Linux users still rely on the Google stack or other third party "workarounds". Yes, no surprises here -- o…
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Book: Doesn’t like it
I guess we can agree to disagree, but I find the 2020 rev Macbook pros have a good number of USB-C ports (2 on the left, 1 on the right -- all can do PD), a magsafe charger, headphone jack, HDMI port and SD card slot. How many USB-C ports do you need? Sometimes I wish there was ethernet but I get why it's not there. I agree, the butterfly keyboard was shitty but I absolutely love the keyboard on the 2020 rev. It's still not as great as my mechanical desktop keyboard, but for a laptop keyboard it's serious chef's kiss. Also, I have yet to find a trackpad that is anywhere as good as the Macbook. Precision trackpads are still way way worse. Finally, the thing that always beings me back to MBPs (vs Surfacebooks or Razers) is battery life. I typically get a good 10+ hours on my MBP. Battery life on my old Razer Blade and Surfacebooks were absolutely comically horrible.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft Surface Book: Likes it
My SurfaceBook has a better build quality that my MacBook Pro model from the same era (2019) - MacBooks have improved a lot in the last few years though with the new chips I guess? I prefer the MacOs to Windows, but MacBook hardware was definitely disappointment on this model. I had numerous graphics & power issues on the MacBook Pro, plus touchbar was annoying. Dell & Lenovo are crap, I've given up on them. Surface is good, and I'm happy with my LG Gram.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itMicrosoft Surface Book: Likes it
Imo the trackpad on the Surface Book 2 is better than the trackpad on my 2023 Macbook Pro. The MacBook has a more noticeable delay before starting scrolling and sometimes misinterprets two finger clicks as one finger clicks. I think the important things to look for are a glass trackpad running Windows Precision Trackpad Drivers.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Book: Doesn’t like it
Agreed. My business depends on my phone. If I can’t call clients or pull google maps up, I’m screwed. I have both an iPhone and an Android. I’ve never had an iPhone die for no good reason. Every single android phone I’ve owned prior to my OP 8T has died in under a year. I got hit with the LG bootloop bug on my first android phone and it just went from there. And that’s just hardware. The other day I realized my 8T had bricked itself. I hadn’t used it in a few days, and an OTA update broke something. Wouldn’t flash back the normal way either, I had to go and dig up specialized software and a copy of the ROM from XDA. I’ve never had an iPhone have a bug that a simple reboot wouldn’t fix. The same thing extends to computers too. I think macOS is an abomination, but the hardware they put out it leaps and bounds ahead of pretty much every other manufacturer. In comparison, my surface book 2 has been a steaming pile of shit from day 1. I built my desktop, but my laptop is a MBP. I’d get 3-4 hours of battery on the SB2 with brightness all the way down. The MBP will literally last all day unless I’m running Thinkorswim. Whoever thought that its performance was acceptable should be shot. Even on my desktop it will routinely use 5gb+ RAM alone.
Switched from the Microsoft Surface Book to the Apple MacBook ProApple MacBook Pro: Recommends it
Have you ever actually tried driving decent large monitors from those crappy intel chips? I have. Engineering tradeoffs indeed. For all its flaws, Apple focuses on making sure there is a good experience overall. In general, they'd rather have a more limited hardware ecosystem that works better than a broad ecosystem that's flaky. There are tradeoffs to both approaches. I go back and forth between windows and mac, and have for decades. I was a surfacebook/win10/WSL guy for a few years, and liked it a lot. Win 11? Not so much. Currently the M series chips blows any PC laptop away for the combination of portability/performance/battery. The Snapdragon X might change that in the next couple years, and I'll take a look at switching back then, and see what win 12 offers. If MS decides to take a step back from being an ad-serving platform and goes back to focusing on productivity, I may switch back. For now though, I'm planning on accepting the gut punch to my wallet and picking up a 14" M3 Max in a few weeks.
Switched from the Apple MacBook Pro to the Microsoft Surface BookMicrosoft Surface Book: Likes it
This is very disheartening. As a direct result, I am spending some time tonight researching running Linux on my Suface Book. I have been impressed with what seems like a new Microsoft. I even made the switch from OSX to a Surface Book as my primary laptop. I used OSX for a decade and ran Linux as my primary OS before that.
Switched from the Apple MacBook Pro to the Microsoft Surface BookMicrosoft Surface Book: Likes it
The latest rev pushed me to a PC for the first time in like 15 years. It's partly because I didn't love the new Macbook Pro, but also cause hey..change is fun sometimes. I'm very happy with my new Surface Book. I never thought I'd like the touchscreen as much as I do. I LOVE being able to go to tablet mode for calls and stuff where I sort of want to just wander around. The pen has completely changed how I do flow-charting and wire-framing. The new Linux subsystem thing is a god-send. It was completely seamless for me to transition from the Mac to Windows pretty much solely because there wasn't really a transition. All our provisioning and development scripts just worked. It's been fun to do a bit of gaming on it too :) The touchpad is really the only thing that I think compares poorly. Apple really nails that whole experience. After a few weeks I'm getting better with it, but it's still painful compared to the precision and certainty I had on my Macbook Pro. I'm sure I'll be back on a Macbook someday (cause hey, change is fun) but no regrets right now.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface Book: Likes it
After reading the comments here, I agree. I always imagined myself as a Framework kind of guy, but I'm not sure I could bear that level of quality after using Microsoft Surface Books, Macbook Pros and now a Thinkpad professionally. I really don't need bad hinges, weak USB ports, weird screen hinges or operating system worries.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralMicrosoft Surface Book: Neutral
I want to keep the number low (I don't like e-waste): Laptops: - Macbook Pro (2021), M1, 16Go: my only personal machine. I play video games using services like Shadow or GeForce Now, I want my setup to be small. - My work laptop, employer issued. Servers: - 1st gen Surface Book: currently works as a home server, used to be my student laptop, soon to be retired with... - Core i7 3700 (something like that), 16Go DDR3: an old machine I got for free yesterday, than I will put in a small mini-ITX case to work as a full-time home server (mainly storage). It will end up at the bottom of a small shelf, and needs to be completely silent. My servers all run NixOS.