The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Microsoft Surface

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple MacBook Pro.

Apple MacBook ProMicrosoft Surface
Owners with an opinion3902171
Positive verdicts62% of 327647% of 150
Positive/negative since 2024945/59229/37
Happy after 3+ years3554
Longest happy owner16 yrs10 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forbatteryease of use
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface: Doesn’t like it
Taking the laptop to the office and back home again daily. The hinge has gotten weak over time. The connection to take off the screen is very fragile, tapping the button to enable removal only works about half the time. Then, when re-attaching the screen sometimes it doesn't catch, or the keyboard connects but doesn't realize it is connected so the machine stays in tablet mode. The trackpad has gotten spongey and harder to click. It didn't happen to me, but of the 4 people in direct team that had them, 2 had battery issues where the battery expanded making the laptop unusable. This is from approximately 2 years of daily use for work. I no longer use my surface. I typically care for my laptops very diligently. I still use my MBP from 2012 and it works like a champ. I don't have a windows laptop anymore, but my main desktop is windows. I'm not a Mac fanboy.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface: Doesn’t like it
I get 2 computer in my work, one windows, one linux. I do not bother to open the windows one, unless I need to use some obscure feature of offices programs. The development work, runs completely in linux. Privately I have mac. After 20 years of saying "mac is BAD (TM)". I buy a Microsoft surface, because I said "is not that the SW is bad, the problem is the HW is not from the same company"... 6 month later, I ditched the surface, bought an iPad, one month later iPhone, 3 month later a macbook pro. No way I would privately go back to windows. In the work, the people who got the Macbook pros were not happy, but mainly because of bad integration with the Microsoft ecosystems around.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralMicrosoft Surface: Likes it
Personally I have both a surface studio laptop and a MBP. I find myself using the surface much more due to the touchscreen and pen input. It’s plenty fast and has great battery that lasts all day. Sure the MBP is really fast, but I mean, so what? So is the Surface. If I need to sign something on the MBP I still have to pull out an iPad, and I guess that’s the way Apple wants it.
Switched from the Apple MacBook Pro to the Microsoft SurfaceMicrosoft Surface: Likes it
Aligns with my experience, Surface 3 Pro replaced my MacBook Pro and iPad air last year and this year I've added a Sony Z3 compact 8" android tablet - which is not an "inexpensive android" device, but it is waterproof, ridiculously light and waterproof. Love it, no interest in going back. Not sure what I am going to do with iPhone 5S... Easy to leave Apple at this point, especially with the mess they made of iTunes.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface: Likes it
Deepest apologies; I meant to say grille. Regardless of the flow direction, I am constantly blocking the aperture with my legs or blanket. The touchpad frequently misidentifies movement as taps, something that hasn't been a problem for me on the Macbook Pro, the X1 Carbon, or the Microsoft Surface. The keyboard keys aren't too bad, but could have a sharper inflection point in the force vs travel and also be little bit less wobbly. Neither of these are fatal flaws, but are enough, I think, to call them mediocre. Do you also find that the computer forgets its DDR5 training pretty regularly and takes a long time to boot? For me I think it's ~1-in-10 boots.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface: Likes it
>Notably, I've loved using Microsoft Surface laptops – their keyboards are awesome, in my humble opinion They have the same keyboard as the MBA / MBP 2015. The old Apple Scissors keyboard. Unfortunately Apple wanted every one to get used to typing like on iPad Screen they slim down the key distance to ridiculous level aka Butterfly. The new Magic keyboard is no where as good as scissors. >So where does Apple go next? Better Built in Camera although I am not sure how that is possible given how slim the lid is, and if they move to OLED for power efficiency it will be even slimmer. Intergated 5G Modem. Apple should have a 4G/5G only modem ( Not even 3G ) on MacBook to test out all quirks before it is even used on iPhone. And then a 3nm / 2nm M Series that is just more efficient. I mean these small but important iteration are enough for all the way till 2030. The form factor and power level itself has reached the end of the S curve. Note: I am still on my MBP 2015. So that is coming close to 10 years of using it. The last real improvement I see was the M1. But I hate the keyboard so much those improvement dont compare. Hopefully I could use this for another 3-5 years.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itMicrosoft Surface: Likes it
I am not an Apple fan by any stretch and am leaning into the PC laptop world because I both want and need a better development environment and more versatile computing environment. I have owned both MacBooks and PC laptops and the former has generally felt more pleasant to use. The trackpad on the Microsoft Surface range is actually quite good and close enough that I wouldn't complain. On the other hand, the trackpad on my Dell is fatiguing to use. It requires excessive force to actuate a click, right clicking is clumsy. Also, due to its lower sensitivity and accuracy, it's more frustrating to use, feeling more like I am dragging the cursor around. On my MBP I prefer the trackpad to an external mouse, spending literally entire work days using nothing other than the trackpad without feeling any impediment when compared to an external mouse. On my Dell, I prefer an external mouse to the trackpad and cannot imagine doing a full day's work with the trackpad alone.