The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Lenovo ThinkPad X220

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad X220.

Apple MacBook ProLenovo ThinkPad X220
Owners with an opinion3902173
Positive verdicts62% of 327686% of 155
Positive/negative since 2024945/59235/9
Happy after 3+ years35517
Longest happy owner16 yrs15 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forbatterydisplay
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
I find my M2 Macbook Pro so much less pleasant to use than my x220 thinkpad (running Debian) that I only use the Macbook for CPU-bound activities to which the x220 thinkpad is unequal. I find the Apple offering's keyboard worse to type on, its enormous touchpad is a chore to engage with compared to the venerable Trackpoint, and the operating system feels contrived to make simple things difficult. The x220 thinkpad is 14 years old now. And has a 500 GB SSD and 16 GB RAM. Perhaps in another 14 years Apple will be able to match it feature for feature. One might well ask why I own Apple hardware at all. The answer is to buy entry into their walled garden as a developer.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Doesn’t like it
> Uncles don’t let relatives buy less than 16gb ram. That has been my standard since ~2010 and our 2013 mbp is still running fine because I insisted on it. Just last weekend I bought 8gb ram thinkpad t14 for an elderly relative. 240 EUR. It replaces his thinkpad x220 where the fan and ssd slowly dies. I doubt it becomes an issue, and if it does then I can upgrade it later.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
I like thinkpads and use my x220 from 2012 or what is it quite a lot. For my work, it beat my mbp 16' intel one I had in 2019 on just feeling faster (with Linux). But the apple silicon airs (for me airs: pros are just too bulky) ones are not beaten at the moment. And I try a lot as I really want to run Linux and not mac os x. But there is nothing better for many reasons (most mentioned here and yeah I could care less about the sound). I sponsor asahi linux for that reason. If Chinese vendors would be smart, they would open up whatever hardware they ship and get all geeks on board which pushes the rest. They are not though so for now, it's macbook airs for me. Hoping for Frame.work to get there though.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
I have an x220 and an x201 with SATA SSDs and they both run great, although repasting the cpus is on my list of things to do, as the fans do run more than I'd like. I have Debian on both but recently I was testing old SSDs and one had windows 10 and even that was perfectly usable. My main daily driver is a MacBook Pro 64GB M2 Max, so it's not like I live in a world of ancient tech and don't understand the difference.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
At that time I enjoyed my X220. To be sincere, the form-factor and practicality moving from home to work and having the dock. Then the XPS 13 was more perfect for me because I could attach three external monitors and have power just via a single Thunderbolt cable (no more custom docks). The crux for all of these was the battery daily duration and replacement after a few years. In that context the MacBook Airs excel at a point that more expensive and powerful Apple notebooks such as the MacBook Pro cannot sustain a "marathon" without a charger. The issue with the Airs is that you cannot currently connect three external monitors (without doing very hacky things), but this is just a question of time. Also, this obsession from Apple about not having touch screens in notebooks because they also sell iPads is disturbing. Finally, an XPS 13 with good battery support (assuming ARM) and good Linux power handling will, probably, be the best notebook available. (would love if they remove the XPS 13 fan and there are more non-moving part notebooks)
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Doesn’t like it
Im sorry but you’re letting your Thinkpad snobby side show. I understand where you come from because I thought the same thing. I used thinkpads for long time (as a choice) but the build is shit compared to what Apple is putting out. Maybe they were better in the past, but they need to keep up. I moved from thinkpads to the 14 MBP and I can’t think of a reason I’d want to go back to Thinkpad other than being able to run Linux. I’ll leave the “far superior” keyboard aspect aside because it’s personal preference. I got used to the Apple one and I type much faster than on my x220. But the screen? Come on. Mini Led, high brightness, just looks absolutely great. Thinkpads usually have shit brightness and basic coatings. I’ve even gotten panels from China to make custom replacements for some of mine because of the garbage panels they came with. Speakers are vibrating turds on thinkpads. One day my gf brought her laptop to bed to watch a movie and i thought “there is no way this is going to be enjoyable”. Then i heard it and I was blown away. I then ripped off the speakers off mine and I made custom housing for some speakers out of a MacBook Air for mine. They couldn’t live sounded better if the whole chassis didn’t rattle with the added bass and if the speakers fired up. The soft touch coating on the shell that peels off leaving half shiny half matte, classic no? They are tied on the hinges, both are solid. Thinkpads may have more ports, but honestly I don’t go around plugging my l…
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
Faster hardware maybe but I think the ThinkPad has other benefits, like being easy to repair and upgrade. I'm extremely frustrated at my 2018 MBP, I stupidly went with the cheaper 256GB option and really wish I could just pop in a 1TB drive. Plus once the honeymoon period with macOS ended I'm now essentially stuck with an operating system I've grown to hate as support for Linux is dismal even with the latest kernel 3+ years on (No keyboard, trackpad, WiFi, Audio, suspend support plus more little issues!). An x220 or other ThinkPad should be very well supported. M1 macs have more interest from Linux devs right now but I'd be hesitant to pick one up unless it runs Linux perfectly now out of the box with most distros. I have seriously contemplated picking up an X220 or some other old ThinkPad even though the hardware would technically be a massive downgrade.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Recommends it
Quite many people are unhappy with their newer Macbook experiences! Sad to see the quality drop in Apple products. I'll add mine to the list: My 2012 MacBook Air has been my favourite laptop I used it for five years and my parents two after that. One of the best 700 hundred euros (student discount) I've spent. Then for my work I got previously used ~2014 MBP it worked well. Solid "Apple quality". Then I got an "upgrade" (i think it was 2018 MBP) and it was the most unpleasant experience I have yet to have with computers. Luckily I didn't have to pay for it, but still - so many problems that are unacceptable for any laptop. It really got me out of the Apple fanboy train. - Keyboard didn't work if the computer got too hot (which it did) - Some buttons didn't properly as dust or some particles got under them - Same problems with the trackpad than the article writer - Don't even get me started with the touchbar (why?!) - Battery life disappointed as I was expecting it to atleast compare with the 2020 Air's (of course my expectations might have been the problem here) - If external monitors were hooked up and you woke up the laptop there as 25% that it froze completely and you had to reboot The laptop got sent to maintenance - they dusted the keyboard but other problems persisted. After one year of that pain I went back to studying and bought used Thinkpad X220 and installed Arch. That is now my favourite computer! Last month I bought XPS 13 for programming since x220's CPU doesn
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Neutral
I decided to install Linux Mint (which is heavily Ubuntu-based) directly on my old A1260 MacBook Pro in 2015 - I ran into some interesting quirks with the GPU (had to force it into BIOS mode) but other than that, I ran the machine for a year purely on Linux. After setting the machine up how I liked it (I really like the Cinnamon UI, even though it's much more Windows-like), I moved the same configs to my other machines. I have a ThinkPad X220 also running Mint with an extra battery for traveling, and a seldom-used desktop PC. The aging MBP finally wore out in 2016 and no longer powers on (but after 5 years of daily use, I'm quite impressed with it). I bought a custom-built Clevo gaming laptop from Scan's 3XS division, since it gave me a lot of say over the hardware - I chose Intel and nVidia where possible to ensure compatibility. I intended from the start for the laptop to run Mint, and it has done so impressively - it has a 1TB SATA SSD for the OS (which I have dual-booting Windows for games) and a second 256GB NVMe SSD dedicated to my Steam library. I like that the machine has enough RAM (16GB) that I can casually jump into a Steam game whenever I feel like it without closing what I've currently got open, and that the RAM and SSDs are upgradable. It's also covered in ports either side, including ethernet and 4 USB3.0 ports. And it cost me less than half that of an entry-level MBP. I found Linux is mostly there, but there are some things that Apple still does much better. T
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
Retina MacBook Pro 15" 16GB/512GB SSD. Which I like mainly for the screen, use it at the simulated 1920x1200 res. It sucks that it can barely play flash or do other cpu intensive things without it getting fucking hot and loud. Its a shame because the GPU is pretty fast. Wish Apple could make a fucking decent thermal design. Thinkpad X220 16GB/256GB SSD, Win7 Pro. I love it for its small size, long battery life, and ruggedness. Although I should warn you the plastic doesn't get on well with mosquito repellant, I learned that in Costa Rica last year. Also the trackpoint, 3 mouse buttons, and keyboard. It actually has a bigger keyboard than the rMBP despite being classified as a 12" laptop. Oh and a 3-year warranty where a guy comes to your house to fix whatever is wrong that only cost $100 or so. The screen is painfully tiny at 1366x768 though. I guess I couldn't decide on one laptop, there are both good for different things. At home I sometimes plug into a 24" Dell 1920x1200 LCD and use a Kinesys Freestyle Pro keyboard and Logitech Anywhere MX mouse. That is nice for extended computer work. My phone is a HTC First. Yeah the Facebook phone. Its a reasonable size, looks nice, you can uninstall all the facebook junk, and the battery lasts me 3 days. And I only paid $170 for it because no one wants them. Oh and the GPS and 3G work unlike my previous Galaxy Nexus. Software-wise, I mainly use Debian under VMWare for work. And Firefox for browsing natively. The builtin sync feature i
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
It’s task-dependent for me as well. For development I think the current 16” MBPs are really about perfect, but for the use case of studying, web browsing, etc something in the range of 12-14” and as light as reasonably possible without negatively impacting battery life is about right. For those smaller machines, I think a squarish (5:4, 4:3, 3:2, or 16:10) aspect ratio with a body exactly as wide as a full-size laptop keyboard (as seen in 12” PowerBook G4, 12” MacBook, and ThinkPad X220) is particularly good, but nobody makes those anymore.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
My daily driver was a used T530 from 2012 - it was the version that had the best GPU. It was a hefty machine. I used to always tell friends - if I ever dropped it on the floor, I'm checking the floor first for damage. I used to push that machine like crazy. My greatest achievement was running Fallout New Vegas on it. I put everything as low as possible, and installed mods to remove extra things from rendering. When I would stare out at a desert I would see absolutely nothing - all the rocks and trees were removed. My other greatest achievement was getting Metro 2033 running as well. For both games it made my poor T530 sound like a jet engine. All that being said, I always wish I bought a X220. The repairs seem a lot easier. Taking apart my T530 to clean the fans was much, much more difficult than doing the same for an MBP Unibody 2012. I've since purchased an M1 MBP off of a college kid. He bought the MBP so that he wouldn't game, and then he sold it to me because he wanted to game. I miss Linux and my thinkpad though. This post is really getting me thinking of buying a thinkpad again.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
I got my M1 Max MBP 14" at the end of 2021 (so almost 2 years ago now) and my previous machine was an X220. The main reasons I switched were: - I was a consultant/contractor, and sometimes you have to run software you really don't want to (Citrix, Teams). You can kind of do this on Linux w/ emulation, but on an older machine it's painful. - Can't drive a 4k monitor at 60fps - 1366x768 is hard to webdev on I also had a multi-machine setup so like, a Chromebook for being spied on, a Windows machine for gaming, and an air-gapped Windows machine for music production. My partner and I had decided to move abroad and it felt like a little much to bring 4 laptops over, so I reluctantly consolidated. In truth the only thing I really gave up was acquiescing to being spied on, but at this point that's more because I haven't set up a pi-hole (etc.) than anything. I do miss (Arch) Linux, and obviously the X220 input system is unparalleled, but I'll say that I'm pretty accustomed to the MBP input system now (I learned Fn-Delete is actual delete, which actually improved my life significantly). I probably lost ~30WPM (I'm around 100-150WPM on a good keyboard) and it's definitely a worse ergonomic experience to have to leave home row to use the trackpad (you're telling me you want me to stretch my ulnar nerve even more ?). There are other niceties. My partner can airdrop me things. I can load truly ridiculous Excel spreadsheets. I can move my music production onto it. I can stream both an Sn…
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
Yeah, I love my late 2013 MacBook Pro! I also recently purchased a bunch of ThinkPads (X230 and X220) to round out my options so I have these nice era of computers going forward for a long time, since I know they will become harder to find over time. Def agree about the "early 2010s" laptops hitting a good place, kind of optimal balance of features vs. simplicity IMO
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X220: Likes it
I use a Lenovo X220 with an SSD and a 15" MBP (also with an SSD). They're both fantastic machines. The Lenovo lets me use Linux with pretty much perfect compatibility and has the best keyboard I've ever used. The MPB similarly has the best trackpad I've encountered. The main unexpected advantage of using OS X has been the presence of readline-style keyboard shortcuts at an OS mediated level (in any text field). Once you get used to that, using any other OS for incidental typing (in search fields or forms) feels slow.