The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Apple MacBook ProLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon
Owners with an opinion3902154
Positive verdicts62% of 327668% of 137
Positive/negative since 2024945/59211/10
Happy after 3+ years35511
Longest happy owner16 yrs10 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forbatterybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
> long-life > and durable keyboards It wasn't that long ago they had terrible keyboard lifespans which could be a death knell for the laptop, and overheating CPUs which limited performance way behind spec. They've come far in recent years, and I certainly wouldn't be sad if it was my main machine yet I don't expect them to be an outlier forever. In some dimension Apple (and any serious manufacturer) is always going to be ahead - and they certainly are in non-gaming portable CPU/GPU combos right now. Alas, they aren't ahead in many other dimensions; my Fedora X1 Carbon is my strong preference over my M4 macbook pro and a large part of that is the basic usability of the system and window manager (sway), which is something Apple will never match until we meaningfully switch interaction paradigms.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
After all the hype I convinced my previous employer to buy me a MBP about 7 years ago and I was using it for about 3 years. Even then the macOS was quite bad, so inflexible and with irritating barriers found to often. Even for the non-development work it was just lacking or it was just very expensive to bring it to the same level. And during those 3 years the stability also suffered a lot. So in the end I was glad to be back to GNU/Linux and KDE Plasma desktop on Lenovo X1 Carbon laptop. So much more powerful, flexible experience and also cheaper. And I had to use some MBP a couple of months ago at current job and macOS is even worse than it was back then, even more limited and dumbed down (more and more like iOS) and also there is a lot of tendency to bring in more surveillance tech just like thre is in Windows. I would choose GNU/Linux with KDE Plasma any day as it currently is, for both development and free time use. This also works much better with other devices which are not from Apple it is just a much more interoperable/open system.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
2019 13" MBP, 16GB. Pretty much anything I do will spin up the fan now. Compiling an app uses so much battery that I get less than an hour of battery life. I've resorted to remote development only, a la Chromebook. My previous laptop was a similar Lenovo X1 Carbon with Debian and wow do I miss it, but I don't have too much of a choice since I do mobile app development :(
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Neutral
As a Linux user I've had many Thinkpads. X1 Carbon does have a great keyboard. But there's to my knowledge no other laptop with a display as good as a Macbook's retina. Look at any Thinkpad next to a retina display, it's night and day. That's why keep using a 2015 MBP with Linux as my daily driver. Looks like I might be able to upgrade soon thanks to Asahi.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
I've noticed they have gotten worse. After three bad MacBook Pros in a row, I bought a used 2015 MacBook Air, which has never given me a problem. The pros all had battery/power issues, shutting down randomly several times a day. The keyboards were also horrible. I've been a Thinkpad fan for years, and I use a Carbon X1 with Linux outside of work. No complaints about that, though I do wonder if it's as physically durable as the older, bulkier models. I've noticed Lenovo is putting out more consumer grade laptops now. I don't know about their quality, but it doesn't seem as high as their professional line. My son has a Dell XPS 15, and had to replace a loud, failing fan after a year. I suppose manufacturers face a lot of pressure selling to consumers who don't know what to look for in terms of quality and don't understand why two visually similar machines with similar specs would be priced so differently. The low-end machines in Walmart look just like the high-end machines at Best Buy. The business grade machines from Lenovo, Dell, and HP have incentive to be higher quality because businesses often buy them with high level service plans. Lenovo, Dell and HP really don't want to send techs into the field to service laptops if they can avoid it, and the best way to avoid that is to build a good product.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
> Which is the reason why they dont understand the minor differences in Keyboard, Trackpad, Speakers, Chassis finishing, durability, Power Supply, Display, etc. Or they just have different preferences. I have a macpro and a lenovo X1 carbon, and I prefer the X1 for most things. The X1 keyboard wins hands down. The mac looks nicer with the aluminium finish and doesn't get fingerprints all over it, but its sharp edged and not a nice felling surface like the X1 rubbery coating. The X1 trackpad is smaller but tracks just as well as the mac touchpad and I prefer the physical buttons. Mac has way better sound, but its also much bigger. The X1 weighs significantly less but feels like its made out of stone with its carbon and magnesium chassis. The biggest benefit of Apple is they don't make low end trash laptops - so if you are starting a corporate job the Apple laptop is a safer pick vs the Windows laptop lottery where you might get some janky low end Dell.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
The whole S3 sleep fiasco is the stuff of nightmares. I have a gen 6 X1 Carbon too and I've gotten it sleeping very well. I also have a Dell XPS 15 that I love but... it's been 2 years since it was brand new and it's still stuck on S2 "idle". As I understand it, Microsoft wants it this way so they can maintain network connectivity. My major gripe with the Lenovo is the 16 gigs of RAM soldered on the board. It's so nice to be able to pop open my Dell and put up to 64 gigs in there, while replacing the SSD in one of the two M2 slots. Then again, I'm typing this on a 2019 Macbook Pro (Intel) that has nary a single replaceable part.
Apple MacBook Pro: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Doesn’t like it
Some back story: I bought a top-of-the-line X1 Carbon ThinkPad for ~$3,000 3 years ago. Within 1 year of owning it: the USB-C charging port broke, the fans started whining, so I had to open/adjust the case, Windows Hello never worked (?), the fingerprint sensor was wonky, and the battery ended up lasting around 5 hours with a realistic workload. This was after owning just about every top PC laptop brand out there: Alienware, Razer, a nice ASUS I had when in college, etc. I bought my M1 MBP around a year ago. It's now 4:30pm, and I've been using it since 10am, sitting at 50% battery without plugging in at all. Everything just works . I even installed Steam and can play some games on it. I hated the idea of owning a Mac and have fought tooth and nail until I finally bit the bullet. It's literally the best laptop I've ever owned and I am never going back. My gaming rig is a different story, but for productivity on-the-go, there's no comparison.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Doesn’t like it
Honestly, I used to hate Apple too. Not sure why, it just seemed like more of a glitzy "fashion statement" than a technical innovation. Maybe this was fueled by my own insecurities (I grew up poor), but boy, was I wrong. After dealing with PC laptops for more than a decade (my first laptop was when I was 19), I finally switched to a MacBook Pro last year and could not be happier. I've had "top" PC products in the past: Razer, X1 Carbon, etc, etc. None even remotely come close in battery life, performance, ease of use, or support. I switched to Apple phones around 6 years ago, and it's the same story. I still miss my HTC One, but other than that one phone, nothing compares to my iPhone.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
For the sake of anecdata, I found that even the Caldigit docks fail to work on the Intel Macbook Pros (I only have a single data point about the M1s and they didn't work there either). When I hook even basic things like my keyboard and mouse up to the USB A ports, things work for about 20 minutes or so (varies widely) and then the USB A ports go dead requiring a reboot to restore. This is a known failure mode, but it doesn't hit everybody. It is solely an Apple software fault as older OSs do not exhibit it. I really wish I knew what the issue was. On the plus side, I found this so infuriating that I finally threw all in and switched to Linux full-time (Lenovo X1 Carbon with a ThinkPad dock) and haven't looked back since. Side note: practically every thunderbolt dock I have works fine with every x86 laptop I have running either Windows or Linux (including the Caldigit!). YMMV.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Doesn’t like it
Seems like lots of IT folks have fond memories of the T420/T430 (and X220) era. I personally think it was the golden age of the Thinkpad line, going back perhaps to T40/T42, it was some of the best laptops I ever worked on. No other laptop has come close to getting it right since. It was really the perfect combination of build quality, modularity and performance that won me over. I'm now on the new M1 Pro Mac and while the battery life is amazing, I felt a lot more confident working on my T420 back in the day. And yes I tried the X1 Carbon/Extreme lines, and I wasn't sold on them either.
Apple MacBook Pro: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Neutral
I have a 4 years old Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon, it's running windows though, but I also develop only on Ubuntu through WSL2. So my opinion is more about the hardware than the software. I also have a 13" MacBook pro M1. I use the MacBook, because it has a much better battery life, it doesn't get warm, and it's not extremely slow on battery power. The i7 needs to be connected to power to be not annoyingly slow, but then it will cook my legs and genitals. The ThinkPad has a touchscreen, which is a huge plus for me, but I am not sure the user experience will be great on a full GNU/Linux distribution. They are both very good laptops, but the MacBook is much better if you can manage Mac os.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
> This reads like every forum post where someone has asked "how's X distro work on Y laptop", and then people respond with something like the following: "Runs great! No issues. Suspend/resume are wonky but I'm able to get by. Bluetooth doesn't work reliably but who needs that? Wifi is slower than in Windows." I am not sure what you are talking about. I didn't mention a single suspend/resume/bluetooth or wifi problem. I mentioned the following brands: Apple, Dell, Acer, Lenovo, MSI And laptops from these brands that I purchased and used worked out of the box. You are free to not believe me, but you shouldn't put words in my mouth. I am typing this on a Dell Latitude E7450 and there are no issues with this laptop whatsoever. Suspend/sleep works flawlessly, no audio issues, no wifi issues, bluetooth works flawlessly, everything worked out of the box on manjaro linux. Also I use my Lenovo X1 carbon with manjaro linux to develop software for a fortune 500/inc 500 corporation 8 hours a day and have been doing it for close to a year without a single issue. My work gave me the latest fully loaded macbook pro but I returned it because I hate the keyboard (it's unreliable as hell and has no travel distance and feels awful) and the touchbar is an abomination. The keyboard is one of the single most important things on a laptop and if the keyboard experience is lacking, the whole experience sucks. I am very happy with x1 carbon latest gen and manjaro linux and my setup destroys the macb
Apple MacBook Pro: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
I still use my 2011 MacBook Pro daily, and has been running Linux for the majority of its life. I must say it has been the best Linux machine I have ever had. It will be very hard to replace. Just put an SSD in it so I will only replace it once the motherboard or other components die, however I have a spare (donated) so it can be used for parts. I am seriously considering buying a Lenovo x1 carbon when it does kick the bucket. Apparently popular with devs for BSD and Linux. Plus has amazing battery life, is light, awesome keyboard. I would get a refurbished ex corp or gov machine, they are just too expensive new.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Doesn’t like it
Same thing here. Sold my 2013 MBP and bought a Thinkpad X1 carbon. After a year of frustration, bought a used 2013 MBP. Windows is somehow worse than it used to be. There's two control centers for some reason. Much more notifications and intrusiveness. Taskbar auto-hide doesn't work consistently. Updates install without permission. The big thing is the apps. Apps are getting much less functional (just like how the Settings app does a fraction of what Control Center used to do.) OneNote is a great example: the UWP version lost so much functionality compared to ON 2016, but the latter has been abandoned. Weirdly enough, I never found a good PDF viewer. Acrobat DC is a slow and a battery hog. Edge/Chrome are non-functional (don't handle search properly on many PDFs). Many alternatives are .NET based on battery hogs. Moreover, since Edge/Chrome won't let you use a PDF plugin anymore, the workflow is completely broken. (Download the PDF then open it in a separate app.) I never thought that Preview would be the "must have" Mac app. Oh, and the trackpad! RDP from a Mac into a Windows terminal server is a better mousing/scrolling experience than native windows on the X1 (which has an MS Precision touchpad). Oh, and power management was real hit-and-miss. Sometimes I'd get a full 10 hours, and sometimes, under the same workload, it'd be like 6. The synaptics touchpad comes with a driver (even though it's supposed to be an MS Precision touchpad) that had some helper utility that woul
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Doesn’t like it
Yes, I mostly run Win8.1 on a rMBP via bootcamp, and have no problems with it (took me a few hours to setup, you'll need a 16GB USB stick and a non-upgrade Windows 8 key to do it). The trackpad support is not as good as in OS X, but still infinitely better than any trackpad I've used on a pure Windows machine. It is definitely better than my previous Carbon X1. High res is beautiful (though there are many Windows options for that these days).
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
Isn’t that what I said? That it’s very good? I had a surface laptop, it was fine, not as good as a MacBook imo. Had a razer laptop, it was good, got very hot though. Had an X1 Carbon Extreme that I liked, wasn’t as good build quality or screen or camera or trackpad as my MBP from work at the time though, was still expensive af. What are you thinking of that’s better than a MacBook Pro?
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon: Likes it
I'm completely on board with getting a long, full life out of a laptop. The only problem is that we've got plenty of thought-to-be-durable laptops around that are complete garbage, including a high-end Thinkpad. It's really sad to see. That said, our M1 MacBook Pro, an X1 carbon, and (very surprisingly) a Microsoft Surface Laptop Go (the cheap one that had terrible reviews - but with the SSD) are looking excellent in terms of long-term durability.