The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Lenovo ThinkPad T420

Hacker News owners lean toward the Lenovo ThinkPad T420.

Apple MacBook ProLenovo ThinkPad T420
Owners with an opinion390289
Positive verdicts62% of 327687% of 77
Positive/negative since 2024945/59228/3
Happy after 3+ years35512
Longest happy owner16 yrs15 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forbatterydisplay and battery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad T420: Likes it
I had a T420 in college. One day in a CS class, I bumped my (uncovered) cup of coffee and it spilled into the keyboard. I knew the laptop had ducts to drain water out, but never tested it (for obvious reasons). I blotted up as much coffee as I could with some napkins and kept taking notes on the soaked keyboard. Worked like a charm. After drying it out, a few keys stopped working so I bought a replacement keyboard for ~$20 and swapping it out was rather fast (from memory). I use an M1 MBP now, but I still have that thing in the basement. It still works, and I loved it. I don't miss carrying it around though (or the hilariously short battery life due to forcing discrete GPU mode so I could dock it for multiple monitors at home).
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad T420: Likes it
I've only ever had second hand ThinkPad T series laptops and a brand new 2015 MBP. The MBP had by far the most hardware issues of any devices I ever had (second screen only on power, running hot enough to cook on it, battery life was mediocre from the start, ...). Every single ThinkPad I ever owned is still ready in my drawer. My ~15yo T420 still has like 6 hours battery life and works like a charm The build quality thing is only true if you compare them with cheaper laptops. In the same price class you find more interesting devices IMO
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad T420: Recommends it
I would probably go with the Lenovo T420 to get the best bang for your buck. An i5, 16gb of memory and an SSD will be more than enough. My home gaming PC used a 3rd gen processor until about 3 months ago, I was not limited by the CPU at all (I wanted an nvme SSD and the new AMD Ryzen processor) Your #2 isn't ideal as you'd undoubtedly struggle with 4gb of ram. Chrome and Slack can be a huge memory hog, on top of what PyCharm and your actual application use. You could upgrade the ram, but you're already spending $450. My primary work machine is a MacBook pro (2014), but it is by no means necessary. My next laptop will run linux.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad T420: Likes it
Hm, I find that comparison a bit off. As a lover of both, Thinkpads (original IBM and Lenovo followups) AND macbooks, I would like to say that it IS possible to maintain macbooks, at least the older ones. My 2012'er MacBook Pro is holding up, parts like the sata-cable and worn out fan were replaced and the ram was upgraded. My Powerbook 530 hat replacable parts, even the G3 Pismo(?) one and an white ibook g3 is also serviceable if you're patient. Same happend for the thinkpads 360, 570, 600, X41t, X61s, T60, T61... hell. We even had chinese colleagues ordering for motherboards for us from china with changed firmware to run 201'er boards in X200 tablets. I became frustrated on thinkpads when Lenovo tried to mimick Apples lightweight AIO design and their first chicklet keyboard frustrated me. I changed all to apple then, because if both do weird things, why not using the more power efficent M1 (imho, maybe that has changed.) Do you remember the old thinkpad bios? Where the pointer was a flying duck? Do you remember opening a thinkpad and everything was labelled with colors and had small handles to change components quickly? Do remember changing ram on a powerbook? And do you remember how hard it was to find a new scsi disc drive for them? Recently, I got an nearly mint T420 at work as I needed something for a mobile job and I just felt my love for the black boxes again. Damn, I miss those days but I also would miss my retina (apple) or 4k screen (Lenovo) if I had to decide bet…
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad T420: Neutral
a self-built desktop with two monitors running linux for work and games that is now 4 years old, replacing the previous lenovo desktop that was in use for 8 years. thinkpad t420 running linux serving as a tv station and for school work. a thinkpad x230 for windows work and games a macbook pro 2012 now only used occasionaly running macos and optionally linux a GPD pocket 1 running linux for all my important work stuff. (small enough to carry around when travelling, so i have a device to do work just in case i need to do stuff that's inconvenient on the phone. i may eventually replace that with a pinephone with keyboard extension, because that's much cheaper and it's really the keyboard and the laptop form factor that makes the difference) a one mix 1s running linux that was really supposed to replace the GPD pocket when the GPD battery died. the one mix battery died too, and in the mean time i was able to replace the GPD battery but not the one mix one. there is one more thinkpad running some old version of linux that is still booting but so old that it's not really practically usable. there are also two OLPC XO's that were the predecessors of the GPD pocket that should still boot. two working phones running /e/. one in use and and older one as backup one thing i never had, because i never found a use for that form factor, is a tablet. a device either needs to be small and easy to carry, or it better have a real keyboard. i do want to get rid of the desktop and instead get ano…
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad T420: Likes it
Seems like lots of IT folks have fond memories of the T420/T430 (and X220) era. I personally think it was the golden age of the Thinkpad line, going back perhaps to T40/T42, it was some of the best laptops I ever worked on. No other laptop has come close to getting it right since. It was really the perfect combination of build quality, modularity and performance that won me over. I'm now on the new M1 Pro Mac and while the battery life is amazing, I felt a lot more confident working on my T420 back in the day. And yes I tried the X1 Carbon/Extreme lines, and I wasn't sold on them either.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad T420: Likes it
I am typing this on a T420 although I just have 12gb not 16gb. No complaints. I like being able to swap the hard drives really quickly instead of messing with partition and the keyboard IMO is better then the new lenovo keyboards. If you are concerned about battery remember they are removable on the T420. In fact I often carry around an extra to double the battery life. I also on a Macbook Pro and frankly it is nicer in many ways but if you money strapped it probably isn't worth the price.