The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Lenovo ThinkPad P14s

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Lenovo ThinkPad P14s.

Apple MacBook ProLenovo ThinkPad P14s
Owners with an opinion390237
Positive verdicts62% of 327679% of 28
Positive/negative since 2024945/59214/2
Happy after 3+ years3550
Longest happy owner16 yrs–
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and display
Criticized forbatterybuild quality and reliability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad P14s: Likes it
I can relate. I've spent almost 30 years working primarily on Linux. I moved Windows to be under VM when I needed it around for occasionally using MS Office, first under vmware and later under kvm. Now I don't even use it as a VM, since work has Office 365. My work got me a similar M4 MacBook Pro early this year, and I find the friction high enough that I rarely use it. It is, at best, an annoying SSH over VPN client that runs the endpoint-management tools my IT group wants. Otherwise, it is a paperweight since it adds nothing for me. The rest of the time, I continue to use Fedora on my last gen Thinkpad P14s (AMD Ryzen 7 PRO 7840U). Or even my 5+ year old Thinkpad T495 (AMD Ryzen 7 PRO 3700U), though I can only use it for scratch stuff since it has a sporadic "fan error" that will prevent boot when it happens. But, I'm not doing any local work that is really GPU dependent. If I were, I'd be torn between chasing the latest AMD iGPU that can use large (but lower bandwidth) system RAM versus rekindling my old workstation habit to host a full size graphics card. It would depend on the details of what I needed to run. I don't really like the NVIDIA driver experience on Linux, but have worked with it in the past (when I had a current gen Titan X) but also did OpenCL on several vendors.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad P14s: Likes it
I got P14s with 64GB of RAM, 1TB SSD and other specs maxed out for $1050 (patiently waited for a sale from Lenovo). Other than the battery life, the P14s is roughly equivalent to a Macbook Pro M2 Pro for $3500. Windows sucks in the default install, but if you know what you're doing you can remove all the junk from it and make Windows almost as efficient as, say, Linux (and way more efficient than macOS). In my opinion, Macbooks are for people who'd rather pay more than take care of and optimize their laptops. I could have paid 3 times as much for a similarly spec'ed Macbook, but then I'd have to put up with a silly notch, not having a right Ctrl key, a keyboard getting shiny after a couple of months and other annoyances. So why even bother with Macbooks?
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad P14s: Doesn’t like it
I have an M1 Pro 14 and a work-issued P14s, which is awful. Creaky plastic, the worst trackpad I've ever used, has a terrible display, spongey keys and runs unfathomably hot. All. The. Time. Every time I see someone recommending Lenovo, I cringe. It is night and day when compared to the MacBook Pro.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad P14s: Likes it
Same here! With Intel-based Thinkpads, especially X1 Yoga Gen 6, frequent issues in Linux. But Yoga Slim 7 with 4800U and afterwards P14s Gen 2 with 5850U, amazing experience, and the latter is the best laptop overall I ever had (including MPB 14 that I'm using now).
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad P14s: Likes it
I ended up buying an MBP 14" because of the apps, but I very very nearly bought a ThinkPad P14s G2 [0]. It's fast, cheap (wait for a deal) has good battery life (for a non MacBook Air), has a great, bright, matte 4k screen, and an Ethernet port . If I could afford to be Linux only like I have been in the past I would've definitely gone this route. [0]: https://www.notebookcheck.net/Lenovo-ThinkPad-P14s-G2-AMD-la...
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad P14s: Likes it
I disagree. I have used Windows for work, and then moved to a MacBook Pro 2018. Granted, the M1 has better performance but I am someone who uses two external monitors at the very least. Paying as much for a device that supports only one ext3rnal display is ludicrous to me. I convinced my current CTO to let me use a Linux machine, and I bought a ThinkPad P14S with Ryzen 7 5800H. I will definitely prefer companies which allow me to use a ThinkPad. I'm on Ubuntu running qtile, with custom tooling for myself that I wrote in Rust. I blaze through my work because of how comfortable I've gotten with the experience. If someone offers me a buttload of money to work with a Mac, I will ask them to give me a cloud machine and use mosh to do all my work. But yes, for the same money, the company that gives me a ThinkPad and tells me to install my own OS gets my yes anyday. It's a far better developer experience.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad P14s: Likes it
Doing connected work from the subway has gotten much, much easier in the last few years. I attribute that to three things: 1. Cell service has become low-latency. This is very different from "fast", which it has also become! When I started working from the train (on HSPA+), pings in the hundreds of milliseconds were the norm. My first step was usually to SSH to a remote machine, and let just the text lag on me. Nowadays, I can run a Web browser locally without issue. 2. Cell service has, at the same time, become ubiquitous in subway tunnels. When I started, there were some areas that dropped down to EDGE (unusable), and some areas that had no service at all. Now, there is exactly one place on the Boston transit system - Back Bay Station - where I lose cell service. 3. Noise cancelling tech has gotten better. It's not just about noise cancelling headphones: both of my laptops (a 2024 MBP and a ThinkPad P14s) have microphones that can filter out screeching wheels and noisy teenagers quite well. That means I can take meetings without making them miserable for the people on the other end. These, honestly, are a huge game-changer for me. The ability to take a 30 minute meeting while commuting, where otherwise I would've had to get in early or stay late at work, actually does wonders for my ability to have a life outside of work.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad P14s: Likes it
I had to chime in that, if 14" vs 15.6" is not a deal breaker, P14s Gen 2 with Ryzen 5850U, 32GB RAM and integrated GPU is the most performant, silent, portable and generally capable laptop I ever had (and I've changed a lot). I got greedy and switched to a MBP 14 with M1 Pro, which is also great, but almost everything (speakers and trackpad excepted) on P14s was either on par or even better (perf, ports, weight, noise, keyboard, build, screen, battery...). MBP is excellent, but I miss my Arch setup a lot and don't think I would miss anything from the MBP actually if I switched back. I know Lenovo is going downwards with Thinkpad line, but P series seems to still hold well - for now at least :/