The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs HP EliteBook

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple MacBook Pro.

Apple MacBook ProHP EliteBook
Owners with an opinion390297
Positive verdicts62% of 327667% of 84
Positive/negative since 2024945/59216/15
Happy after 3+ years35513
Longest happy owner16 yrs13 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and repairability
Criticized forbatterydisplay and performance
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itHP EliteBook: Doesn’t like it
> buying top of the line laptops and trying to use them longer is never going to be cheaper or better than buying medium grade laptops and upgrading more often. I think this is much less general than you make it out to be and has an extremely strong dependency on how you use the thing and of your preference. It makes me think of the boot theory. Personally, for the type of work I do, I rarely need the latest ludicrously fast CPU. But I use it a lot and love to do so comfortably. To me, that means a great screen, a quiet fan, and a nice keyboard and touchpad. Buying a mediocre computer and changing it more often means you'll always have a mediocre experience. A case in point: at work we have HP Elitebooks. The brand-new 2025 models I see people receive have worse screens and trackpads than my 2013 MBP. Sure, that box was quite a bit pricier even in nominal terms, but it had the same amount of RAM (16 GB) and SSD (512 GB) as these new computers. I'll also grant that the new ones have a faster CPU but the SSDs are somehow absurdly slow. I haven't seen a single one of these machines last more than 10 years fully functional. My mom still uses that MBP. But the experience is sub-par. In the period 2013-2015, we never got to experience a nice laptop. For the office work these people do, that 12-year-old Mac would be an all-around better experience. The HP screens at the time were truly horrendous. They're leagues better now but still poor and clearly worse than the 2013 mac. The…
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itHP EliteBook: Likes it
From my recent purchase decision: 14 macbook pro, 32gb of ram, 1tb of storage, 120Hz high res sceen: 2900€ HP Elitebook, same specs, same weight, etc.: 1200€ https://www.campuspoint.de/hp-elitebook-845-g11-sondermodell... Surely, the macbook pro will be better in some ways but at that price difference "better" is just not good enough.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itHP EliteBook: Doesn’t like it
I don't know about Lenovo and Dell, but for HP, they do say what you're getting. I'm not familiar with the Z Book line, but for the Elite and Pro Book (which we have at work - it's why I know) they give some specs. Usually, they quote NTSC coverage and backlight intensity. Now, they never say it's great, mind. I have a top-of-the-line EliteBook screen and while it's very bright, colors aren't great and viewing angles are a bad joke. But that's likely related to the "privacy screen" feature. One of its cousins has a lower-end screen, which is 6-bit. Its angles are fine, but it's basically unable to display real reds. The first one was quoted as something like 72% NTSC. I forget what the other one was, but certainly below 50%. And, indeed, these laptops are not cheap. My 14" EliteBook cost a few hundred euros less than a 14" M1 MBP with the same quantity RAM and SSD (32 / 512). Now I haven't seen the new MBP screens, but my 2013 MBP's screen runs circles around these pieces of crap. Also, battery life is comparable to my 2013 MBP, but the SSD is slower.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itHP EliteBook: Doesn’t like it
I doubt that's it. That may help with "whow, shiny colors!" impressions, but I think that pcs just source lower quality panels. I have a 2012 unibody MBP with a matte screen (the last model before the retina line). That thing looks so much better than my 2021 HP EliteBook it's not even funny. Sure, the HP has higher resolution (1920x1080 vs 1680x1050), but the viewing angles are poor (it's a 14" panel, but there is no single position from which you can see it completely OK, the colors always change when you move the slightest). The blacks are a darkish grey. The reds are actually orange. This wasn't a cheap pc, either. It also has the 8 bit panel. Some SKUs only have dim, 6 bit ones. It cost almost as much as a 14" M1 when my company bought it (it's a work laptop, I would never have bought this crap with my own cash). The only other metric except from resolution by which it beats that 11 yo macbook is that it's very bright, to the point of being actually usable outside if the sun doesn't shine directly on it. There are many PCs with glossy coating. We also have a different model of elitebooks at work that have those (x360 line). That's an atrocious shitshow. Except for a completely dark room, you'll always see some random reflection instead of the actual screen content. My 2013 retina MBP does better outside than these poor excuses for a panel do inside. There are PCs that somehow do manage to look decent. A friend's Dell XPS comes to mind, though it doesn't look as good as a…
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itHP EliteBook: Doesn’t like it
This is what kills me. At work, they only swear by HP for some reason. So, I've got a shitty Elitebook that cost, after RAM and SSD upgrades, within 100 euros of a same-size MBP with same RAM and SSD. But the build quality is uniformly worse. And the screen... it's an atrocity. You don't have to compare it to an MBP (I only have an old 2013 one, and it still wipes the floor with it). Even compared to an older XPS (7th gen intel), it's horrible.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itHP EliteBook: Doesn’t like it
> Sure, but the M1 generally has a high-quality Apple screen (this laptop from HP advertises only “FHD” so - presumably 16:9 1080p and not Retina-quality 16:10…) This looks like their current generation Pro/EliteBook lines. I have one of the higher end ones (EB 845) and oh boy does the screen suck. Not just compared to my 9 yo MBP. But even on its own. Very low angles, washed out colors. It's only advertised as 72% NTSC IIRC. Cheaper models have 6-bit panels on which you can see the dithering in the window shadows. It's laughably bad. And it cost more than similarly-specced MacBook Air. Other than that it's a usable PC, plenty fast for my needs, and the RAM and SSD are easily upgradeable. Battery life is OK-ish (I get around 6 hours). Also, everything works under Linux and is even less of a hassle to get going than on Windows (you need an external mouse to install it).
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itHP EliteBook: Doesn’t like it
Oh man, I have an 845 g8 (840 with amd). I hate this laptop with a passion. It could've been such a great tool, but it's a steaming PoS because HP wanted to make a quick buck. I don't have your hinge issue. But, as you open the display, the hinge gets below the laptop's feet. So now it slides around on the table. Which is so stupid, because this laptop doesn't have 4 feet, but 2 large ones, than run the width of the laptop. Which is fantastic if you want to use it on the corner of a table since it won't wobble! Then there's the screen. I swear someone at HP wanted to see how shitty a screen they could get away with in a 2000 euro laptop (which is just a middle of the road config, mind you). On basic models, you have a 6 bit screen. On higher-end ones, they have this security screen thingy that massacres the viewing angles even when it's off . If you move your head around the tiniest bit (say while listening to music) the colors will perceptibly change. The colors are atrocious. And they don't even hide it! The specs say 72% NTSC (not sRGB, which is much wider). Then you have your usual suspects with cheap laptops: the cooler is an absolute joke, the fan developed a horrible noise in a few months. There's coil whine that drives you up a wall when connecting a USB-C monitor + power. On the plus side, the analog headphone out is surprisingly good. I don't hear any background noise, there's no whine when moving the mouse, and the sound is similar to my Retina MBP on relatively h…
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itHP EliteBook: Likes it
Work just upgraded me to an HP EliteBook 835 G8. It's got a Ryzen 7 Pro 5850U and 24GB of RAM. I do mostly .NET/ASP.NET development and it's seriously fantastic. Form factor is good, repairability is good (granted our company is also an HP authorized service center), I/O is good (really only missing eth), and it has a matte display with a touchscreen. I really think that Apple devices get so much clout mostly due to advertising. My issues with my iPhone 7 radio made me switch to Android after they told me it was Qualcomm's fault that it wasn't bonded to the PCB properly. My 2009 MacBook Pro 13" had some sort of issue where the SATA III part of the controller died and I was forced to either pay $800 for a new logic board because I had upgraded the RAM or use an optical drive HDD caddy which ran at SATA I(?) speeds. I had also had the logic board replaced once and the screen replaced twice less than a year after I got it as the screen had stopped working. Don't remember the actual cause of the issue, but seeing as it was covered I have a feeling there was a known issue with that line. My girlfriend's 2011 13" MacBook Pro ended up with non-functioning USB ports due to a known but never recalled, even silently, issue with a chip on the logic board. Again, would have been a $500+ logic board replacement "fix". My 2016 MacBook Air 13" started to develop a crack on the black plastic piece covering the hinge because of heat stress. I paid for the most "performant" SKU and after one m…
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itHP EliteBook: Likes it
This is getting pretty common with new Macbooks. Stop buying this proprietary piece of junk. It can stop working randomly for no reason (literaly; one day it won't start and won't charge, not a single beep). There are lots of proprietary chips with their custom firmware and any of those can go bad or decide to dislike your usb-c charger and only apple or those with years of experience with behaviour of each model and access to stolen schematics and spare chips desoldered from doner boards can diagnose and fix it. The display flex cable can break by just opening and closing the lid every day and you lose video or backlight, fixing just the flex is so tedious that they often replace the whole display assembly which is custom made by apple and costs half the price of the laptop. Same if LCD cracks. If keyboard wears down you need to replace the whole keyboard assembly. And the battery is glued and difficult to replace. If you compare that with a HP Elitebook laptop, it is a completely different universe. It is not uglier or bulkier and yet the keyboard is replaceable in minutes, held by screws, flash is in the slot, power rails are nicely visible, chips often with publicly available datasheets, battery easy to replace or measure, LCD panel has a standard size and eDP connector and you can even pick a different brand and it will work just fine.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itHP EliteBook: Likes it
As long as possible. 0. Software developer 1. Current laptop is HP EliteBook 835 G7 (16 GB/256 GB SSD). 2. I bought the current laptop secondhand for few hundred a year ago. I expect to get 5+ years out of this one. Previous laptop was MacBook Pro (15", mid 2015) that I would probably still be using, but I need to change it's keyboard and haven't bothered to do that yet. That lasted for 8 years on my use.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itHP EliteBook: Likes it
I used to work with HP Elitebook (yes, Windows) for 7 years and after that switched to Macbook Pro. I enjoyed both. While the Mac has the right filesystem in place, is fast and reliable. The HP Elitebook was easy to upgrade in terms of hardware. I enjoyed both. The HP Elitebook was a bit heavy though especially because it is very well processed and i used the drive slot for a second SSD.