The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Framework Laptop

Hacker News owners lean toward the Framework Laptop.

Apple MacBook ProFramework Laptop
Owners with an opinion3902751
Positive verdicts62% of 327671% of 661
Positive/negative since 2024945/592309/139
Happy after 3+ years35524
Longest happy owner16 yrs5 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityrepairability and reliability
Criticized forbatterybattery and build quality
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
I made the same choice albeit a year ago. Dont bother with Framework their stuff is super clunky and super expensive. I use t2linux.org, the install of Mint worked fine on one of my macbooks. The other I keep around only for logic pro. Have had no problems with it. It is not my daily driver as I have moved on to non-apple hardware for good. Anyway t2linux.org works fine I dont know about this OPs project.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Just to let you know, the Framework 13 Pro with Windows installed on it gets better mixed productivity battery life and Netflix video playback than any MacBook currently on sale. Haptic trackpad, CNC machined chassis, touch screen, fully modular design. This isn’t 10-15 years ago where no Windows laptops could compete with MacBook hardware. This is 2026 where Apple hasn’t touched the MacBook Pro chassis in 5 years and everyone else on the market also has an aluminum build with haptic trackpad, like the ThinkPad X9 15P. This is 2026 where an ASUS ExpertBook has better speakers and is significantly lighter weight than a MacBook Pro. This is 2026 where the notch on the MacBook Air and Pro is a ridiculous joke. This is 2026 where the ASUS Zephyrus G14 gets MacBook-level productivity battery life but packs an RTX 5070Ti for serious gaming in a premium build the same size of a MacBook Pro. And really, Windows is not that bad. It’s not my personal choice but it’s fine, and there’s a bunch of applications macOS can’t run.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Unfortunately, not to my knowledge. I wouldn’t be surprised if they get a retail partner soon, though. Surely they must realize that Micro Center would be an ideal partner for their demographic. I own the original chassis 13, AMD 7640U. My previous laptop was a MacBook Pro M2 14”. There are some clear downgrades: battery life, screen, speakers. Processing power, yeah, though it’s not like I ever maxed out the one I had. I love having ample storage though. 2TB/32GB in a MacBook Pro was wildly out of my price range. Back in the good old days of early 2025 buying those components yourself was something like a $200-300 cost while the Mac was closer to a thousand bucks. The keyboard is superior to a MacBook Pro in my eyes. I also started to really, really despise the notch and the way the menu bar software fights it. My Framework 13 Pro arrives tomorrow. It appears like it should address every complaint I have on my original 13”. It’s just too bad about the RAM situation otherwise LPCAMM2 would be a benefit rather than something of a detractor like it is today. I’m one of the lucky people who snagged an old stock 32GB module for $250 during the announcement keynote. You’re almost better off with soldered memory in the current situation, but hopefully that’s temporary. It’s a dream with Linux compatibility, as you’d expect. I enjoy the fact that I can play real games on Steam compared to the macOS situation where gaming was always a pain. There are also a lot of things I like about…
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
I bought a Framework 13 in 2021. I was so stoked. I used it for 5 years, and of those 5 years only 1 was heavy use. I had to replace the battery and the input cover. I never had to do that before. I never had a laptop I wasn't able to use for 5 years so the repairability was actually not that much better for me. I gave up on Framework because after 5 years they still didn't give a crap about terrible battery performance on Linux distros. I was using a Macbook Pro before. Went back to a Macbook Pro again. I don't want a Mac. I just can't find anything else remotely worth my money.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
having 2 fw 13s this is my experience as well (and also friends who bought into FW); i was willing to give the 13 pro a try until they downgraded my order. I inevitably cancelled and went with a dell xps14 and its a fantastic laptop. I am unsure bout any future fw purchases. also my m1 macbook pro is made so well I've abused this to the cows come home and i feel like it still has another 3+ years to it.. everytime someone brings up the e-waste aspects of fw, i don't know if its that simple...because i've definitely already generated much more e-waste with my frameworks than any other laptop i've bought in the last decade that being said, i do like the fw vision, but they might be trying to do TOO much that their quality is suffering for it
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
My support experience has been quite similar. Lots of required evidence, slow responses, and then just links to buy replacement parts in the store. The kicker is that the things they were telling me to buy didn't even fix the problem. My fingerprint reader was very flakey, and after replacing it and all cabling connected to it, it still didn't work. They then told me to buy a whole new input cover which was the wrong solution again. The issue was the touchpad, which routes the signal for the fingerprint sensor through its circuit board. They also encouraged me heavily to update the BIOS and firmware of everything aggressively before really digging into any of the kernel messages I was seeing. All that said, it's really hard to complain that for $50 and some waiting I was easily able to fix the problem. Compared to replacing the battery on a MacBook pro which took me 5hrs and required complete disassembly of the chassis sans fans it was a dream. Here's to hoping that framework does better, they do seem to take well to community feedback.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Food for thought: Apple’s services make more revenue than Macs and iPads combined, and they do so at a higher profit margin. There’s your answer. I don’t agree that Apple makes the best laptops by a parsec. Not anymore, many alternatives are closing the gap. This is aided by the fact that Apple hasn’t touched the MacBook Pro chassis in 5 years, making it quite dated especially with the underutilized, oversized notch and the horrendous menu bar software implementation that plagues the notch as a real problem for me and something that doesn’t just “disappear into the background.” The software solution is to just disappear menu bar items that don’t fit, making them unusable. Apple is still the gold standard, don’t get me wrong. But I’ve got my Framework 13 Pro preorder in, and the list of compromises compared to a Mac is very short. My existing Framework 13 is already close enough and the Pro appears to fix 100% of the gripes I have with my system. CNC machined chassis? Check. Haptic trackpad? Check. Graphics performance? Better than the M5 (non-Pro). Battery life? 20 hours of video playback. And I’ll be getting numerous advantages over a MacBook: cross-compatible modular hardware, upgradable RAM and storage, customizable I/O, low cost DIY repairs, 3:2 screen ratio ideal for coding. But this is just one laptop. If you explore the windows laptop space, there are a lot of great machines these days. Windows is really the weakest part of the equation, and you can just get rid of tha…
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Consider that maybe you've just gotten lucky? Laptop components do break. I haven't had Mac laptops in a bunch of years, but just off the top of my head I've had a keyboard key break (MacBook Air), and a mainboard die (MacBook Pro). But if you don't need repairs, you might want upgrades. I have a Framework 13 from 2022 and I expect I won't be buying a full new laptop for many many years. It's great that you've been able to repurpose your old laptops for other family members, but every new laptop manufactured eventually becomes e-waste.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Bought the Framework 13 in March 2022 with 16GB RAM and a 512GB SSD for about $1000. Later, I upgraded RAM and SSD to 32GB/2TB (for about $180), which made it a breeze to run multiple VMs and Docker containers in parallel. Meanwhile, the Macbook M1 Pro I got from work half a year earlier cost more than $2500 for 16GB RAM and a 1TB SSD and crashes when I dare to open Docker or the Android Simulator and keep a browser open for too long. I really like the M1, but it is unusable for my current workloads, and there is no way to adapt it.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
From a quick search online, the max brightness of your laptop is 400 nits SDR and 500 HDR. My M5 MacBook Pro is 1000 and 1500 nits. Screen brightness is not something I will compromise on after having a taste of greatness. I personally wouldn't mind spending 30-40% more for a Linux laptop with similar qualities + repairability. But I will not settle for something much more expensive and worst in some aspects. There are also arguments agains repairability in Framework's laptop. I did the calculations and for the Framework 16, it would be cheaper to buy a gaming Asus laptop and throw it out in a couple years to replace it versus buying a framework and upgrading it. Utter insanity.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
My personal perspective: 2 out of 3 MacBook Pro, I worked with, had expanding batteries after about 5 years. Replacement was a big hassle and the new no-name batteries are nowhere near as good as the original ones. I sure wish it was as easy as a battery replacement on a Framework laptop (with an original part). I know the Neo has easier battery replacement (not glued in), but still it has an iFixit rating of 6/10 whereas the Framework 12 has a 10/10.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Liquid Ass enters the chat, Apple can’t even make rounded corners anymore. I was burned by the 2016 MacBook Pro keyboard, and once Liquid Ass was announced I knew it was time to get out. Sold my MacBook Pro M2 Pro, which has a stupid gigantic notch that blocks the menu bar items with no built-in mechanism for getting to them when they overflow. Now I’m on a Framework 13” and I’ve had zero issues with Linux. Everything just works. KDE Plasma is way more customizable than macOS or Windows. I’m finally able to ditch slow Homebrew and use a real package manager. I can finally play light PC games on my laptop without dealing with streaming or Crossover. My preorder is in for the Framework 13 Pro, which looks to get even closer to delivering a MacBook Pro for Linux. Meanwhile, Apple hasn’t changed their chassis design in 5 years, while Framework updates their hardware constantly while maintaining cross-compatibility. A company with less than 500 employees is catching up to a trillion dollar corporation. I’ve already got my fully modular LPCAMM RAM delivered and ready with no Apple tax. I’ll get better battery life watching YouTube videos than a MacBook Pro and the graphics are just as powerful as the M5 base chip. And if something breaks I won’t have to deal with the nightmare I went through with my 2016 MacBook Pro.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
I can take my MacBook in to be repaired at any Apple authorized repairer or the official store. I got my entire MBP motherboard replaced at $0 cost to me a year ago. If I had a Framework, they wouldn't even be replying to me. That's the difference. That's why it's garbage. They don't stand by their product, and don't care if it fails on you. Quality INCLUDES support, by the way.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
I have a Framework 13 running an AMD AI 300 Series with Fedora as my personal laptop and an MBP M2 Pro as my work machine. I would say that the Framework is fine for battery life when you’re using it but loses like 20-30% of battery per day in sleep mode vs like 1% per day for the MBP. The workaround I use now is to set the FW to hibernate after 30 minutes of sleep so it’s not dead when I decide to use it again after a few days. The downside of this is that waking up takes a couple of minutes and so I still tend to use the MBP if I need to do something quick and don’t want to wait for the hibernate tax.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
I slapped 96GB of ram into my 13 framework laptop last year, when prices were cheap. I'm probably going to upgrade next cycle for fun and give my current laptop away (I'll keep the ram). I'm sure that laptop will last a very long time with linux. Macbook Pro's are the best laptops I've ever used. But if you go that route you better up front that RAM or you'll be stuck. The one place the Mac destroys the framework is battery usage. It's not a deal killer for me, but it might be for many.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itFramework Laptop: Neutral
It's more a matter of effiency and battery life, and that's mostly due to Linux more than inherent to the Framework or its hardware (try running Asahi Linux on an M MacBook and just notice your battery life be cut in half). I love my M1 Pro MacBook and I wish I could have the same efficiency when running Linux but I can't. My Framework runs faster, but a lot hotter, louder and with a lot less battery life. But I feel like I'm supporting a good company, a good cause, and I love that I can do software updates without fearing that it fucked everything up like every major macOS release does.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itFramework Laptop: Neutral
As a daily user of both a first gen framework 13 and a M1 MacBook Pro, the MacBook touchpad is like 5-10% better. And I suspect that's all software because I did something recently that absolutely fucked the response and feel of my framework touchpad that I haven't figured out how to undo so there's clearly a lot of room for manoeuvre in software.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
Unfortunately, if the Mac isn't distinct from Windows and desktop Linux in some way, then what's the point? Yes, as a long-time Mac user who now uses PCs at home but still uses a work-issued MacBook Pro, I greatly appreciate how Macs since the late 1990s-early 2000s are compatible with the PC ecosystem when it comes to peripherals, networking, and file systems. However, what has been lost is "The Macintosh Way"; a distinctly Macintosh approach to computing. There's something about using the classic Mac OS or Jobs-era Mac OS X: it's well-designed across the entire ecosystem. I wish Apple stayed the course with defending "The Macintosh Way"; I am not a fan of the Web and mobile influences that have crept into macOS, and I am also not a fan of the nagging that later versions of macOS have in the name of "security" and promoting Apple products. What the Mac has going for it today is mind-blowing ARM chips that are very fast and energy efficient. My work-issued MacBook Pro has absolutely amazing battery life, whereas my personal Framework 13's battery life is abysmal by comparison. What's going to happen, though, if it's possible to buy a PC that's just as good as an ARM Mac in terms of both performance and battery life?