The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Dell XPS 15

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple MacBook Pro.

Apple MacBook ProDell XPS 15
Owners with an opinion3902110
Positive verdicts62% of 327642% of 96
Positive/negative since 2024945/5926/10
Happy after 3+ years3553
Longest happy owner16 yrs5 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and display
Criticized forbatterybattery and noise
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itDell XPS 15: Likes it
Another counterpoint: my at-home install of Debian on a 2022 XPS 15 is absolutely fantastic. WiFi is solid and sleep works perfectly. (I don't think I have hibernation enabled though.) I don't use a second monitor, but projectors have always worked fine for me. Power management at first wasn't great, but simply installing Intel PowerTOP and having it apply all its suggestions on each boot made it easily the most power-conservative laptop I've ever owned. (The OLED screen I think helps with that.) Whereas my work MacBook Pro (2021 model maybe?) had decent power management up until macOS 12 junked up GPU switching, making typing horribly laggy unless I disabled GPU switching entirely -- but since that forced the external GPU, battery life took a nosedive.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS 15: Doesn’t like it
Dell lost my confidence when their XPS 15 display couldn't display a pane of gray without flickering. I switched to a Macbook Pro and haven't looked back. For me (personally) to consider Dell again, they would have to replicate everything that Framework does and ship Linux with support. Edit: can I also add that they suck for business too? The slim form factor has NO place in business, slimming down the chassis and removing ports is an anti-pattern. I couldn't give a shit how thin my work laptop looks, my job doesn't involve taking pictures of unrealistically minimalistic office desks. With Dell you either get a dainty oversized netbook or a rugged behemoth (which is a little too rugged unless you're in telecom and roll in a van). Where's the middle ground? Nothing needed to change from the old thinkpad.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS 15: Doesn’t like it
Is this a joke? I mean what's the use of this laptop for a developer if it has a typical consumer keyboard not designed for typing code? Also having been a user of couple of generations of XPS, I wouldn't wish this laptop upon an enemy. These laptops were the most unreliable I have a ever had. I also never heard fans so loud in any other laptop like in my XPS 15. They were louder than a hairdryer. Imagine this during a meeting. Plus typical issues like coil whine or if you power it off, pray that it will turn on... When my XPS 15 died, while not being a fan of Apple I bought M1 MBPRO. Now I am not sure why other manufacturers like Dell even bother making their laptops. Do yourself a favour and don't bother with Dell. You can run Linux on Mac just fine (through virtualisation).
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS 15: Doesn’t like it
Yep. Even the 14 & 16" MBP with M1 Pros stay much cooler & quieter than your typical AMD/Intel Windows laptop. Silence is golden, and even on the odd occasion where the fan on the 14" M1 Pro starts spinning (e.g. running Cinebench to purposefully max all cores), it's extremely difficult to notice without your ear right up against the laptop. By comparison, my Windows work laptops (previously an XPS 15, now a ThinkPad T14 Gen2) become plainly audible from 10ft+ away just attending a Teams meeting.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralDell XPS 15: Likes it
The whole S3 sleep fiasco is the stuff of nightmares. I have a gen 6 X1 Carbon too and I've gotten it sleeping very well. I also have a Dell XPS 15 that I love but... it's been 2 years since it was brand new and it's still stuck on S2 "idle". As I understand it, Microsoft wants it this way so they can maintain network connectivity. My major gripe with the Lenovo is the 16 gigs of RAM soldered on the board. It's so nice to be able to pop open my Dell and put up to 64 gigs in there, while replacing the SSD in one of the two M2 slots. Then again, I'm typing this on a 2019 Macbook Pro (Intel) that has nary a single replaceable part.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itDell XPS 15: Likes it
The last two laptops I bought were XPS 15s and they worked totally fine for the years I used them 2011/2015?. I'm planning a refresh this year for a new one. I have a 2019 MBP sent to me for work and it crashes at least 3 time a week. Like it or not, there is no objective value to how well or long lasting these products last, and the best we can do is require manufacturers to report defects/returns so that the public are informed, so.. probably never happen unless the EU mandates it.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS 15: Neutral
Swore I'd never buy another Mac but bought one this week (had a Dell XPS15 for a year and a half) to supervise a cross-platform app development project and many things were annoying me with NixOS (clean but not quite there yet for desktop use and may never be: too many missing packages) which had replaced Gentoo (~biannual reinstall required due to portage rot), neither of which work perfectly on laptop hardware. (Also much of my Linux work is now embedded or remote and banks here in China require Windows VMs.) Wound up just going for it, not disappointed but fairly expensive as always. It's true, the touch bar is annoying, and I am a vi user so escape is critical. But it's not really any more annoying than adjusting between apple keyboards and PC keyboards: a bit of muscle memory. I just wish you could disable the whole thing entirely, at least the lights, while keeping the escape key. Haven't figured out right click on the touchpad yet, it's currently quite irritating. The press-to-drag brightness is kinda cool, and the fingerprint lock is also cute. The Mac is about 1/2 the weight of the Dell, although the Dell was last-year's model on sale 1.5 years ago so that's to be expected. My back will thank me on business trips. USB-C is the biggest physical adjustment, and I'm all for it. Yet to select an appropriate external keyboard (might buy Apple) or HDMI adaptor (won't buy Apple), happy to take recommendations.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS 15: Doesn’t like it
Yup, agreed here. I shared the sentiments that this post had. Then I got a XPS 15" and booted ElementaryOS on it and trying to deal with the resolution issues from the 4K display was just a huge headache. Also, say what you will about the MBP, even though I paid $2k for my XPS, it still wasn't nearly as nice as the MBP's touchpad, etc. I would definitely still pay a premium for that MBP hardware.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS 15: Likes it
I have an XPS 15 I got at Costco for about $2k years back that I used out in the field (i7, 16gb RAM, 1TB NVMe). Extremely happy with it and it’s still my primary go-to laptop. No extended warranty, never repaired or any issues. I just purchased my first MacBook Pro (M2) a few months back and I absolutely love it! Now that I no longer work out in the field, I always have both laptops at my desk mounted on two Twelve South Curve Stands with an extra monitor in between. I have a magic keyboard (Touch ID) and an MX Master 3S. Can’t complain!
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itDell XPS 15: Doesn’t like it
I've noticed they have gotten worse. After three bad MacBook Pros in a row, I bought a used 2015 MacBook Air, which has never given me a problem. The pros all had battery/power issues, shutting down randomly several times a day. The keyboards were also horrible. I've been a Thinkpad fan for years, and I use a Carbon X1 with Linux outside of work. No complaints about that, though I do wonder if it's as physically durable as the older, bulkier models. I've noticed Lenovo is putting out more consumer grade laptops now. I don't know about their quality, but it doesn't seem as high as their professional line. My son has a Dell XPS 15, and had to replace a loud, failing fan after a year. I suppose manufacturers face a lot of pressure selling to consumers who don't know what to look for in terms of quality and don't understand why two visually similar machines with similar specs would be priced so differently. The low-end machines in Walmart look just like the high-end machines at Best Buy. The business grade machines from Lenovo, Dell, and HP have incentive to be higher quality because businesses often buy them with high level service plans. Lenovo, Dell and HP really don't want to send techs into the field to service laptops if they can avoid it, and the best way to avoid that is to build a good product.