The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Dell XPS

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Pro.

Apple MacBook ProDell XPS
Owners with an opinion3902659
Positive verdicts62% of 327648% of 583
Positive/negative since 2024945/59272/97
Happy after 3+ years35549
Longest happy owner16 yrs20 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forbatterybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
As far as I can tell after just looking at the specs, what I said is still the same. For example, an Intel Core Ultra 5 Processor 338H has a TDP of 25-65W vs. the M5 TDP of 3-27W. These aren't even directly comparable, but it gets worse going higher in the Intel Stack. Further, every Windows laptop seems to have a worse display. For example, an M5 Macbook Pro 14" has a 120Hz 254ppi mini-LED display with a peak brightness of 1600 nits vs. a Dell XPS 14" with a 120Hz 161ppi LCD display with a peak brightness of 500 nits. So it seems like they have figured out that they can put bigger batteries, worse displays, and throttle TDP to get better battery life, but it is still not possible for them to beat Apple's efficiency just based on those TDP numbers alone—these chips are just drawing more than 2x the power at peak load. I don't understand why there isn't more effort towards ARM in the Windows world.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I've wanted a 2n1/convertible macbook pro + ipad/ios flippy laptop ever since Windows started making them and never, ever thought it would happen with Apple. I still don't think it will happen but with this coming out I went from knowing its an impossible request to being sure it's an impossible request. All of the Windows ones have horrible throttling problems, my $3k dell xps 13z was just terrible. I hope this takes off, maybe we'll start getting neat consumer stuff from Apple again. Happily writing this from a 7 year old m1 max that runs great aside from Tahoe.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I've used one of the flagship Surface Books two jobs ago, really beefy, could run Cyberpunk(don't ask how I know). Insanely bad machine, the overall finish was terrible, hinges broke often, charging port broke often(like every 3rd-4th person in the office), it overheated with basic office work, fans went rocket level loud when compiling basic things, after a while it was stuttering even with casual use. Had a really good Dell XPS at home too that was dying when compiling big Typescript codebase. I bought an MBP M3Pro 1.5y ago and I could never go back. It's insane how far ahead Apple is when it comes to performance. Noone seems to grasp that until they actually try to work on M-series. Three of my ex colleagues also switched to Macbooks after I told them, they also are never coming back.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
>Because realistically in the laptop computer space Apple is obliterating everything else right now. Probably right, seeing how bad the laptop world is nowadays. Even with its shitty chiclet keyboard and button-less trackpad, the M2 Pro I have to use at work trounces the XPSes my Windows colleagues have. Still far from the Latitude e64x0 and old 6x series Thinkpads I had but well, they only win on the haptics and repairability level. Thankfully I kept an e6440 that still works "okay" with its Haswell i5 and 1080p IPS screen; the thermals and crappy Intel iGPU are the only thing I really lament.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I've had two Dell XPS laptops (a 13" 2015 model and a 15" 2-in-1 2018 model). Both had significant touchpad issues: not sure if that's a driver thing or a hardware thing, but both would sometimes act as if there was a phantom touch somewhere on the trackpad which messed with my actual input. One of them had a keyboard where key caps of frequently used keys (super, shift, ctrl) would split in two after a ~year of use; this was not fixed under warranty, I paid out of pocket after a year of ownership, another year later it happened again. After those two Dell XPS laptops, I got a MacBook Pro 2021 with an M1 Pro instead of getting the keyboard fixed again. No issues. Linux support isn't great, but at least macOS is a relatively competent UNIX so it's fine. I might consider another non-Mac laptop in the future. But it's not gonna be a Dell.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
But the Market has shifted, Mac is increasing in marketshare and that shift is even higher on expensive laptops, where people get expensive upgrades. Two or three years ago, I bought an XPS 15 with minimum memory specs and immediately maxed the RAM to 64gb and threw in a 2tb nvme drive. Last year I purchased a M3 Macbook Pro and made no upgrades. I don’t expect to go back to PC, because the Mac performance is so great and the power managment actually works. When I threw my XPS 15 in my bag, it often comes out of my bag with no battery. The Mac not only gets awesome battery life, but it doesn’t randomly discharge when closed and sleeps properly.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
At work, our Windows devs use expensive XPSs that are complete crap failing constantly, both hardware and software. As someone who used Latitudes and Precisions when these were the reliable workhorses you seem to describe, the new stuff is just outrageous. (My personal laptop is still an e6440). My work machine is an M2 Pro MBP and except the shitty input HW (compared to the golden era of Thinkpads/Latitudes without chiclet keyboards) and MacOS being quite bad compared to Linux, it completely trounces the neighbouring Dells that constantly need repairs (mostly the USB-C ports and wireless cards failing).
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
I loathe macOS but stick with it mostly for the hardware. I use a beefed-up 16-inch M3 Max for work and a baseline 15-inch MacBook Air for writing and OSS work. I love the Air’s hardware and wouldn’t trade it for anything. Before switching to Mac, I was running a maxed-out 16-inch Dell XPS and enjoyed using Ubuntu and Pop!_OS on it. But the hardware just wasn’t there—the trackpad felt cheap, and the keyboard would creak. There were just too many small issues for such an expensive device. Otherwise, macOS is bloated, slow, and has horrible window management. I also prefer GNU tooling over BSD, and having to install everything separately is an extra hassle. Plus, it’s getting more restrictive over the years, which I’m not a fan of.
Apple MacBook Pro: Recommends itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
You should try a MacBook Pro someday. It would still last all day with that workload. I had an XPS at work and it would last 1.5 hrs. My Apple laptop with the same workload lasts 6-8 hours easily. I never undocked the dell because of the performance issues. I undock the mac all the time because I can trust it to last.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
This is precisely the reason I switched over. The QA control for 99% of Windows laptops is completely hit or miss. My last decent Windows machine was a Lenovo T530. That thing was a workstation and didn't pretend to be anything else. Modular, easy to replace components, that thing got out of my way and just worked. That was over a decade ago. After that I had nothing but irritating issues. Everything from poor wifi (looking at you Killer), poor battery life (2 hours max), ventilation issues and overheating, etc. Example: My Dell XPS with InfinityEdge screen looked amazing. What was less amazing was the constant BSODs on a brand new machine within a few months of light usage. I switched to a MBP Max M1 and haven't looked back.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
> Windows sucks in the default install, but if you know what you're doing you can remove all the junk from it and make Windows almost as efficient as, say, Linux (and way more efficient than macOS). I can answer this as someone who, throughout last 6 months of his new job, used a Dell XPS 9570 with Windows, then PopOS, then Windows again, and just switched to an M3 Pro a week or two ago. No - you will never get close. That Dell could run fps games like CS:GO or Valorant with 100+ fps, had custom tweaks incl. thermalpads connecting to the chasis, exchanged thermal paste, was undervolted and with a custom fan curve. It still throttled from time to time. Granted - it was 8th gen i7, but it was on paper good enough to handle everything I do. Only on paper. It also choke on my day to day work, which is WebStorm, Docker and Typescript web development. Indexing, autocomplete, builds(even with swc) took a really long time. I switched to PopOS for a while, but overal user experience was even worse to me, with constant issues ranging from monitors behaving weirdly, stuff crashing, requiring weird driver installations, even Docker didn't 'just work', I had to fight it half a day to get it to actually run. Went back to Windows until I got frustrated enough and just bought a 36gb M3 Pro, and I'm never going back. This just works, builds take 1/6th of what they did, I can run full swc build in 100ms, full tsc build takes 10 seconds(down from around 60), nothing ever stutters, nothing slo…
Apple MacBook Pro: Recommends itDell XPS: Neutral
I’ve just returned to a MBP from an XPS13 running various flavours of Linux. I’d suggest that there’s lots of little things you miss on a refurbished Lenovo vs an Apple Silicon mac. Eg better battery management, better screen handling, better Bluetooth handling. None of them was a massive problem for me hut it’s that kind of fit and finish to the OS I missed. For now anyway I’d rather pay extra for a Mac.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Neutral
I managed to eke out 5 years on an XPS15 I was issued, but with no Windows 11 support (9570) its lifespan was limited. I ran Ubuntu for a while, but 23.10 broke LUKS and graphics support on my Nvidia GPU was limited. I’ve just bought a 2.5 MacBook Pro 16” refurbished, and my iPhone is 3 years old and counting with no plans to upgrade. I think getting as long as we can out of our devices is crucial, but the big wheel keeps on turning with technologies like Windows 11 and even Chrome. It’s an honourable endeavour but certainly disincentivised by big tech.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
The claim that Apple equipment is not good on a price performance ratio does not hold water. I recently needed to upgrade both my phone and my laptop. I use Apple products, but not exclusively. Making cross platform apps, I like to use all the major platforms. I compared the quality phone brands and PC brands. For a 13" laptop, both Samsung and Dell XPS are $4-500 more expensive on the same spec (i7/M2 pro, 32GB, 1TB), and I personally think that the MacBook Pro has a better screen, better touch pad and better build quality than the two others iOS devices are comparably priced with Samsung models. It was this way last time I upgraded my computer, and the time before. Yeah, you will find cheaper phones and computers, and maybe you like them, but I appreciate build quality as well as MIPS. They are tools I use from early morning to late night every day.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell XPS: Doesn’t like it
Bizarre bitterness. You really think nobody is buying Macs on their merit? Maybe you're European and apple products cost a lot more where you live? In the states, base model MacBook Airs are frequently ~$800 on sale. You can get an official refurb MacBook Air or Pro with 16GB/1TB for ~$1300 from Apple's website right now. Those machines are priced competitively when compared to Dell XPS, new ThinkPads, etc. They also have much better battery life, screens, and overall build quality compared to those machines. Also MacOS is, for all its faults, normie-accessible unlike Linux and ad-free unlike Windows.