The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Dell Precision

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Pro.

Apple MacBook ProDell Precision
Owners with an opinion3902182
Positive verdicts62% of 327662% of 157
Positive/negative since 2024945/59234/14
Happy after 3+ years35515
Longest happy owner16 yrs17 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and reliability
Criticized forbatterybattery and portability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Precision: Neutral
I'm in the market for a new linux laptop again too. I primarily use a 2019 Macbook Pro which I like, but would like to be back on linux on laptop. I bought a Framework (11th gen intel) when it was first announced but ended up returning it: - small battery, despite heavily tweaking and running a very barebones setup I was running out of battery very quickly - though I loved 3:2, 13.5" was too small for my preference - macbook trackpads are still better After returning that I ended up buying a Dell Precision 5560 (also 11th gen intel), but ended up selling that as well: - I made a mistake and got the 1920x1200 screen and it's awful - trackpad, again Otherwise the Dell is pretty good. Decent battery life, great linux compatibility, good performance and build quality. I'm leaning towards trying out the X1 Carbon Gen 10 but I'm unsure if I'll like the 14" screen. I've also looked at the X1 Extreme but unsure about battery life (I don't need the Nvidia graphics, though I guess I could just disable that and use Intel). The Star Labs Starfighter looks great on paper but there are no videos or reviews of the production units yet and I'd like to wait and see a hands-on first.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Precision: Doesn’t like it
There is no such thing as a macbook replacement at the moment IMHO. There is literally nothing with the same quality, battery life, thermals, audio, display, keyboard and reliability on the market. Not even the most expensive machines can get anywhere near even an M1 MacBook Air on this front. The M1 MBP destroys everything else. I develop software on it no problems at all. We are way past targeting one platform. Linux can be the destination for sure but like hell I'm going to do the dev work on it. Years of attempting to run Linux on a laptop or desktop have left a very unpleasant flavour in my mouth. It might work today but it probably won't tomorrow and I'm getting too old to waste my time futzing. It has to work right now, properly, today with no risks. Note: I have a mandated Dell Precision 7670 for some work, one of the most ridiculously stupid computers ever made and far more expensive in this config than a high end MBP M1 Max and it's absolutely a pile of shit from a hardware and software perspective. If you ran Linux on it, it'd be worse than if it ran windows on it, which is already terrible.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Precision: Doesn’t like it
No. I have a 5550 which is I assume what the author is referring to. It’s garbage. Overheats constantly, the touchpad is dire, the screen has bad vignette around the edges, it’s noisy, the thing hard freezes when you plug it into a dock, the webcam only works 50% of the time you power it up and if you pick it up by the base it flexes so badly the touchpad clicks. The keyboard is also soggy as hell and the battery lasts 3 hours if you’re really lucky. It’s the worst laptop I’ve ever had the displeasure of using. I am just glad I didn’t pay for the thing. But a Thinkpad or a MacBook and just give this a hard pass. I’m using a 14” MacBook Pro which was much cheaper and it’s a far more productive machine without all of the above problems!
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itDell Precision: Likes it
I am very happy with a Dell Precision 5510. I bought it as replacement for my MacBook Pro, maxed out late 2016, (MB) when it needs butterfly keyboard service (twice so far). It came with a Xeon processor and 32 GB RAM. for under 1000 USD. I run it with Ubuntu and compile software all day. My MB fans were blowing a lot and once even the battery swelled (service). My replacement Precision beats the MB in any aspect.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralDell Precision: Likes it
I used a MBP for 6 years, professionally, and this past fall switch to a Dell Precision 15". The new macbooks have a terrible keyboard, lost the magsafe connector, lost the lit apple symbol (loved it, because I could put an amusing sticker over it), have a ridiculously sized trackpad that I was constantly touching, only two USB C - one of which is always needed for power, and replaced the top set of keys with the "meh" touch bar thing. You can only get 16 GB of ram, and the guts are just fine. Windows 10 + WSL is awesome, the only minor issue being some permissions stuff. I find Windows 10 to be a more interesting, an effective interface. The only thing I miss is that the Mac trackpad has a bit better detection for when I accidentally brush it. Otherwise, I'll take my 3 USB C, 2 USB B, HDMI, SD, and audio ports any day - all of which I have used at some point in the past 6 months, incidentally. The new Mac keyboard alone was enough to make me want to toss the laptop into the trash. But, hey, it's slightly thinner, so you know, major productivity gains there!
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Precision: Doesn’t like it
I recommend strongly against buying a Dell, specifically the M4800. I ordered two for my business recently. I chose the Intel AC 7260 network adapter, which turns out to have all kinds of problems connecting reliably to 802.11n networks (the vast majority). On my laptop specifically, the motherboard and/or video card had major problems resulting in failure to shut down, an endless cycle of video adapter driver crashes and re-initializations resulting in system lockup, problems waking up from sleep, etc. I returned mine for a replacement, only to find the keyboard was absolutely horrendous--keys would double-press (bounce) almost every other key when typing fast and with moderate to heavy pressure. Upgrading the BIOS did not help as it apparently did with other Dell models. Also, Dell refuses to refund my money on the now two defective laptops because I'm outside of the 30 day refund window. They wouldn't make an exception. I told them I was never purchasing a Dell again. I can (and did) buy a 2014 MacBook Pro with better specs for the same price and now I'm running Windows in Boot Camp (for .NET development) with flawless performance. Combined with a 3-year Apple Care agreement, I never have to worry about being nickeled-and-dimed over way-too-short refund periods. In short, avoid Dell. They are shipping substandard hardware and are even getting things that should be commoditized to perfection (the keyboard) wrong.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Precision: Likes it
At work, our Windows devs use expensive XPSs that are complete crap failing constantly, both hardware and software. As someone who used Latitudes and Precisions when these were the reliable workhorses you seem to describe, the new stuff is just outrageous. (My personal laptop is still an e6440). My work machine is an M2 Pro MBP and except the shitty input HW (compared to the golden era of Thinkpads/Latitudes without chiclet keyboards) and MacOS being quite bad compared to Linux, it completely trounces the neighbouring Dells that constantly need repairs (mostly the USB-C ports and wireless cards failing).
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Precision: Likes it
I used PCs for decades before transitioning to Mac based laptops for work which I continued to use for the last 6 years. Due to the M1 laptops being poorly suited to my workflows, I have now changed back and am on a Linux powered Dell Precision laptop and am overall happy with the decision - though I had to compromise on a few things. I dislike Apple and find a lot of their choices distasteful - but I just haven't been able to find a laptop that I could use portably that feels as nice (I like to work from cafes/libraries, so the docked experience doesn't matter - the Dell crushes in that context). It's mostly the trackpad that does it, I can use a MBP trackpad for a full 8 hour work day and never think about reaching for a mouse. By contrast, my Dell is better for my workflow in every way. Aside from the battery life, it compiles things in literally half the time, IO bound tasks are, no exaggeration, an order of magnitude faster.... but it feels so horrible to use. The trackpad is physically exhausting to use and the speakers sound tinny like I am losing consciousness. The power adapter is enormous, heavy and essential. I wish someone would just make a shameless 1:1 rip off of the MBP with first class Linux support. Haha, why is it so hard for OEMs to get the hint? At the very least, OEMs like Dell could try using a MacBook and mimic the trackpad. Don't they have QA teams that tell them how bad it is?
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralDell Precision: Neutral
I also have a first gen Framework. I've used the following recently: - Framework 1st gen - Dell XPS 13 - Macbook Pro 14" (m1) - Dell Precision 5570 I wouldn't say that the framework is perfect, there are a number of minor complaints I have with it. However, it holds its own, and I really do love it, especially while running linux. I hope that Framework the company continues to support the early models with new mainboards and parts. If so, I'll be a very loyal customer. Oh, and the fact that I know I'll be able to replace the battery when the time comes is a beautiful feeling!
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Precision: Likes it
As nice as some of old-ish business and workstation laptops like Thinkpads, Latitudes, and Precisions are in some ways, one aspect that’s looking increasingly aged is battery life and brick size. I don’t necessarily need my laptops to be powerhouses, but it’s nice to not need to carry the charger brick most of the time, and on the odd occasion I do it’s better if it’s not literally a brick. I have a circa 2008 15.4” Precision that I’ve upgraded quite a lot thanks to its modularity and expandability, and it’s still pretty serviceable except that even with a brand new larger-model battery it’d be a stretch to get 4-5 hours of life out of it, and its charger brick is monstrous. It’s a stark contrast to a 16” M-series MBP, which is also a high-performance (if not quite workstation) class laptop, but gets somewhere between 2-4x the battery life and can charge up overnight with a compact 30W USB-C phone charger without any adapters. It’d be interesting if one of those projects that retrofits old ThinkPad shells with modern mainboards were built around an ultra-efficient ARM SoC instead of the usual x86 fare. That’d address the issue pretty well.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Precision: Likes it
Laptop: MacBook Pro 15" Mid-2014, 1 x 2.8GHz 4c i7-4980HQ, 16GB RAM, 1TB SSD + 512GB SDCard Desktop: Dell Precision 7920 2 x 2.9GHZ Xeon 6226R, 192GB RAM, 2TB SSD VM host: MacMini 2018, 1 x 3.2GHz 6c i7-8700B, 64 GB RAM, 1TB SSD NAS: QNAP TS-451+, 1 x 1.9GHz 4c Celeron J1900, 8GB RAM, 8TB HDD The laptop is old, but it's solid and has the decent keyboard, and I haven't _needed_ to replace it yet, and I can't bring myself to spend the $5k a decent replacement will cost. One day. The desktop was paid for by my employer. It's a beast. Not what I would have bought, but ... it's pretty good for big C++ project builds. It has two 30" Dell monitors too. The VM host lets me run macOS, Windows, and Linux VMs. Renting Mac/Windows VMs is expensive, so I ended up with this instead. Very happy with how it worked out. The NAS just has a mirrored pair of 8TB drives (one Seagate, one Western Digital). I do BTRFS snapshots onto a 16TB backup drive, which gets removed and swapped off-site once a month. I need to grow this: I'll probably put the backup drives into the NAS, and get a pair of bigger backup drives.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Precision: Likes it
Personally, I use a Macbook Pro. I don't want to spend time messing with my configuration files. I want to focus on what gets money flowing into my pocket. To answer your question, I've heard great things about the Dell M3800. You can get Linux preloaded and get a higher resolution screen. Dell has worked with Canonical to make sure the hardware support is there. Before this machine, I had a Thinkpad and I really had trouble understanding what all the hype was. I don't think I'd buy one now after Superfish.