The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Dell Latitude

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Dell Latitude.

Apple MacBook ProDell Latitude
Owners with an opinion3902207
Positive verdicts62% of 327672% of 184
Positive/negative since 2024945/59247/23
Happy after 3+ years35523
Longest happy owner16 yrs20 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forbatterybattery and build quality
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itDell Latitude: Likes it
I bought a macbook pro m1 pro. Its value is 25% in 4/5 years. I bought a second hand dell latitude 7/8 years ago, it was 3/4 years old then. Still running as a server today. A cheap acer bought in 2017 runs almalinux and is surprisingly fast and capable today, I had upgraded ram and put in nvme SSD long back.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itDell Latitude: Likes it
I am the opposite. I've regretted every Apple computer purchase I've made. Their phones are well made - iBook g4 12 inch. GPU died. Known fault. - Mac mini. Ended up using this as a build machine for iOS. Had to replace the hardrive outside warranty. Took me about 2 hours to do. Now is running Debian and is a Minecraft server. - Macbook Pro 2014 - dead. Glue'd on battery, ended up paying a local Mac repair guy to do the job. A year later The power brick (official) burned out the power lines on the motherboard. Now the PC laptops are all still running. - Dell E6410 - still works, Debian 13. - Dell D-series - still works, window xp 64bit - Thinkpad T480 - still works Debian 13. The non apple hardware I can normally repair myself and thus I can keep it running forever.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itDell Latitude: Likes it
Sadly, this is more of MSFT's "we can do what Apple does too!". For a "business" oriented portable why is it so limited on ports? No wired Ethernet? As many others have pointed out, why are the 3D graphics so hobbled? People use laptops for CAD, visualizations and these days GPUs perform offload of a lot of other functions. I saw someone "crap" on Dell and Lenovo but honestly I think most of the Lattitude laptops have really good build quality, decent availbility of parts and good longevity. Lenovo X1 Carbons are far from perfect but they're pretty solid machines and still offer wired Ethernet (albiet via a breakout dongle) and a decent amount of ports. Linux works pretty decently here too. I never understood what the value add of MSFT's Surface family was/is, supposedly a "first party" portable with Windows with the same quality and engineering as an Apple product but if you look at HOW they go about it they seem to keep missing the point. If you go to Wikipedia and punch in 'Surface' you'll see some crazy big table of devices they've churned out, all with varying degrees of issues. I have a Surface Pro 2 which runs Debian Linux quite well (like another poster pointed out) so that's cool but it's has a lot of oddities that wouldn't be acceptable had the machine not been free. Lenovo made an X1 Tablet family that's fanless and is honestly pretty compelling if you need a fanless, "tablet-like" PC that runs Windows. I use mine as a car diagnostics computer and the car sof…
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itDell Latitude: Likes it
I have 2 Dell Inspiron 1525 from 2008, still kicking bottoms as DAW under Manjaro. I used to have a a Dell Latitude d630 from 2007 running Debian fine in 2018 but I gave it away. Compared to my 2008 macbook pro, that cost me 1400€ at the time, and suddenly died on me 4 years later for no obvious reason (this series was subject to a recall campaign due to its nvidia 8600 gpu, but I missed the elegibility window by a few months). TBH though, my dad uses a 2009 macbookpro with W10 and it runs just fine with an SSD. All in all, you never know, YMMV .
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Latitude: Doesn’t like it
It's just one of many great aspects for such a capable device. They also run very cool and are effectively silent even when the fan DOES eventually turn on for a sustained max load. By comparison, every Windows/Intel laptop I've had over the last decade exhibited obvious fan noise every time there was some short-lived load on the CPU - that includes several nicer business/pro grade laptops including Dell XPS, Latitudes, and a Thinkpad. ...and NONE of those other laptops came remotely close to reliably lasting 10+ hours on battery like the MBPs can/do.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralDell Latitude: Doesn’t like it
I'm a software developer and an older laptop is not great for productivity. I have an old Dell Latitude from 2017 and I pumped as much life into it as I could. Bought more RAM, an SSD but despite all that, it's a pain to run the IDEs I need to use for work. I keep it as a backup and work on an M2 Max now. Same goes with my S.O. who is a Chemist. Older computers are just not ideal for new software.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itDell Latitude: Recommends it
You did not mention whether you will be using it as dev machine or something else. In case dev, get Dell XPS Ubuntu. Latitudes with Ubuntu are even better (used one for 4 years). Bought the MacBook Pro, due to all the hype. It already made me visit Mac service centre twice. One day it just refused to boot. Motherboard replaced. Second time due to battery swelling issue whole Touchpad, Keyboard and battery replaced. Regretting it now. Only useful if you are developing apps for iPhone/macOS.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itDell Latitude: Likes it
> This reads like every forum post where someone has asked "how's X distro work on Y laptop", and then people respond with something like the following: "Runs great! No issues. Suspend/resume are wonky but I'm able to get by. Bluetooth doesn't work reliably but who needs that? Wifi is slower than in Windows." I am not sure what you are talking about. I didn't mention a single suspend/resume/bluetooth or wifi problem. I mentioned the following brands: Apple, Dell, Acer, Lenovo, MSI And laptops from these brands that I purchased and used worked out of the box. You are free to not believe me, but you shouldn't put words in my mouth. I am typing this on a Dell Latitude E7450 and there are no issues with this laptop whatsoever. Suspend/sleep works flawlessly, no audio issues, no wifi issues, bluetooth works flawlessly, everything worked out of the box on manjaro linux. Also I use my Lenovo X1 carbon with manjaro linux to develop software for a fortune 500/inc 500 corporation 8 hours a day and have been doing it for close to a year without a single issue. My work gave me the latest fully loaded macbook pro but I returned it because I hate the keyboard (it's unreliable as hell and has no travel distance and feels awful) and the touchbar is an abomination. The keyboard is one of the single most important things on a laptop and if the keyboard experience is lacking, the whole experience sucks. I am very happy with x1 carbon latest gen and manjaro linux and my setup destroys the macb
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralDell Latitude: Doesn’t like it
I was gonna reply to defend the Macbook Pro, but then I realized the author is right, I did have to replace my Macbook Pro keyboard too because the spacebar key was stuck. But whatever, I am not gonna leave my macbook behind just because of that. By comparison, my Macbook is still better than my work Dell Latitude (which costs the same) that sounds like a jet engine because the fan keeps coming on, battery lasts for less than 5 hours, wireless keeps dropping, and I occasionally gets the BSOD... Nothing's perfect, that's just life.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralDell Latitude: Recommends it
I got a 14 inch Dell e6470 with 4 physical cpu cores - its stellar machine, everything is working using OS drivers from kernel - I love it - you might consider that - I like this machine way better than the late 2014 macbook pro (13 inch) my company issued to me.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Latitude: Likes it
>Because realistically in the laptop computer space Apple is obliterating everything else right now. Probably right, seeing how bad the laptop world is nowadays. Even with its shitty chiclet keyboard and button-less trackpad, the M2 Pro I have to use at work trounces the XPSes my Windows colleagues have. Still far from the Latitude e64x0 and old 6x series Thinkpads I had but well, they only win on the haptics and repairability level. Thankfully I kept an e6440 that still works "okay" with its Haswell i5 and 1080p IPS screen; the thermals and crappy Intel iGPU are the only thing I really lament.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Latitude: Likes it
At work, our Windows devs use expensive XPSs that are complete crap failing constantly, both hardware and software. As someone who used Latitudes and Precisions when these were the reliable workhorses you seem to describe, the new stuff is just outrageous. (My personal laptop is still an e6440). My work machine is an M2 Pro MBP and except the shitty input HW (compared to the golden era of Thinkpads/Latitudes without chiclet keyboards) and MacOS being quite bad compared to Linux, it completely trounces the neighbouring Dells that constantly need repairs (mostly the USB-C ports and wireless cards failing).
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Latitude: Likes it
My experience has been that there is only two reasonable ways to buy a laptop for personal use: 1. Buy an Apple device new. 2. Buy a Lenovo Thinkpad or Dell Latitude refurb/used via their outlet stores from their business line-ups With #2, you know exactly what you're getting, but you're getting it cheap, and the parts are possible to find (e.g. eBay) to fix it yourself. With #1, you know exactly what you're getting, and you're paying for a premium experience that you'll actually receive and isn't a sham or bait n switch (like it is with "premium" PC products). I have a stack of laptops on my desk because I physically separate the different types of work that I do (for many various reasons). 2 are Thinkpads, 2 are Apple, and one is a Dell Latitude. All of have been solid for years. My newest laptop in the stack is an M1 Macbook Pro 14" with the M1 Max, and it's FANTASTIC, it's easily the best laptop I've owned since I retired my /IBM/ Thinkpad T60p. There is no reason anyone should ever subject themselves to the torture that is buying a laptop "intended" for "consumers". There is no reason anyone should ever pay full price for any non-Apple laptop, because they all make annoying trade-offs that are only acceptable when you buy them cut-rate.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Latitude: Likes it
My Anecdotal Laptop History: 2006 HP Pavillion - dragged around the world. Felt a bit cheap/plasticy but never had any major issues. 2013 Macbook Pro Retina was a champ, a bit dated now. Saved me from massive back-injury when I fell on some ice and acted as a shield. Put a huge dent in the corner. Speakers rumbled a bit after. Unusable now due to MacOS limit. 2015 Asus Zenbook Pro still quite usable. Windows 10 still happy. Keys felt a bit plastic/motile but still decent to type on. 2022 Dell Latitude 7520 just arrived, extremely light and peppy. Overall has a very utilitarian feel with a backspace key and function row. Nice big trackpad. Hope it lasts a while. Now the only funny thing is if you add up the cost of all the non Apple laptops it equated to the same cost as all the others combined. Pavillion ~$800, Zenbook Pro ~$1299, Dell ~$1699, Macbook Pro Retina: ~$3700 Definitely got my eye on a https://frame.work/ soon for personal.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itDell Latitude: Likes it
That's wild, I have 3 laptops right now, one purchased in 2001 (dell latitude), one in 2003 (dell inspiron) and a macbook pro from 2006 and all work perfectly -- all with dead batteries. I still use them. One for my home theater, one for monitoring web sites, and one to type this comment. I'm not saying this to be mean or anything, but I think your stuff could last longer or you could fix them. One time, the inspiron died on me. I called dell and they said i had to send it back for a new mobo at $500. I said, "No way!" and opened it up. Turns out, it was just a loose connection on the power panel! Fixed it for free and saved a little piece of the planet in the process. One thing we agree on is that we've been doing it wrong for many years . The wrong is disposable. The wrong is not repairing things. The wrong is filling up landfills. Apple, with these battery decisions, is exacerbating the problems caused by the wrongs we have been doing for years. Regarding the razor issue, you're right -- not the best example of sustainability, but it was a gift and it was a decade ago before I realized I have an impact on the planet. I no longer shave every day and I use a $19 trimmer once a week (sometimes month or quarter) -- traditional razors just won't cut it (pun intended) after that much growth and I leave a 5 o'clock -- better for the skin and I don't waste shaving cream. When I run across a strop, I'm going to start using my great granddad's straight razor.