The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Dell laptop

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple MacBook Pro.

Apple MacBook ProDell laptop
Owners with an opinion390215
Positive verdicts62% of 327620% of 15
Positive/negative since 2024945/5922/6
Happy after 3+ years3550
Longest happy owner16 yrs–
Praised forperformance and reliabilitysoftware and build quality
Criticized forbatteryreliability and support
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Recommends itDell laptop: Doesn’t like it
The three laptops I had before my MBP were all from different companies, ASUS, Gateway, Dell, and I hated the hardware on all of them. There was always something going on. The case didn't close right, the battery life sucked, the trackpads were awful and so itty bitty, the wifi cut in and out, the power cord needed to be jiggled just right to charge, or wouldn't charge at all unless held in place with tape just so ... between the three laptops and six years there was always SOMETHING going wrong. So you could say that I originally purchased my MBP because of the hardware. I expected to install Windows on it (didn't, but that's a different story). I swallowed the extra cost when I did the math. I use my laptop about 3000 hours a year. Day in, day out, I'm on it in some way. They usually last me 2 years or so before I get the itch to upgrade or they fail. I did the math and found that the ~$1000 laptops I bought cost me $0.003 per minute over the course of those two years. A $1300 MBP cost me $0.004 per minute. I decided that I would rather pay $0.001 more per minute to enjoy the hardware I used. I'd rather be in a rage over the fact that my code isn't doing what I want than if my battery isn't taking a charge again. An added side benefit has been how much tougher the MBP is. I've had it for two years now and it shows no signs of needing replacement. I probably won't upgrade until I see how Apple's Retina display transitions to their laptop line. The upgrade then will probab
Switched from the Dell laptop to the Apple MacBook ProApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
You simply can't compare anything to MacBooks. I had a Dell that I paid about $2,000 for, and it was really good (or so I thought). Then at work, I got a MacBook Pro, and that's when I saw the difference. Its not only the Pros, no "high-end" laptop running Windows or Linux with just 8GB of RAM can perform better than a MacBook Air with 8GB. I don't know how Apple has optimized memory usage, but my personal feeling is that 8GB of RAM on Macs is equivalent to 32GB on non-Apple devices. I'm not some Apple fanboy—I've been using Arch Linux daily for the past month or two, and it's great. However, there isn't a day that passes without screen freezes during peak usage, and I need to reboot every day or two. This happens despite having 32GB of RAM, an RTX 4060, and a Ryzen 5 7600. That never happens with my 5-year-old MacBook Air. I really wish Linux were as good as macOS, I really do. I'm pushing myself to use it even though I experience frustration every day, but this simply isn't the case. It's easy to optimize the system and applications for one specific hardware configuration (like Apple does), but it's very hard, if not impossible, to do this for every possible hardware combination available today. That's why Linux and Windows can't win this performance battle.
Switched from the Dell laptop to the Apple MacBook ProApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
I previously used a work issued Dell laptop. A powerful machine. It was super irritating to use. The trackpad was too sensitive, would click with the slightest touch. The screen was poor to look at. The battery life was awful. Linux as a whole was fine to use, but I don't miss it. Now use a MBP M1. I far prefer it. The trackpad is amazing. The keys a great. The battery life is way better. The screen is way better. I intensely dislike Apple's practices and walled garden predatory approach, but their hardware is amazing.
Switched from the Dell laptop to the Apple MacBook ProApple MacBook Pro: Recommends it
It is always amazing to me people who will chastise people for using Macs. It is by far the most robust hardware and 15 years later Windows laptops may finally be catching up. My first programming job was LAMP so I had a Linux desktop and loved it. Later I got a new job that gave us laptops, but they were quite beefy. I had a Dell laptop with an Nvidia GPU and an Intel iGPU... After updating my OS my gpu was the only way to use my laptop, which made the battery die in under an hour and of course it was much hotter. I tried numerous driver installs, proprietary, open source, reinstall OS, different OS... Nothing got it working again on a newer version of the Linux kernel. Went to the Apple Store bought a MBP and have never had an issue since. Not one dead laptop, in 10 years, I plug in my USB C dock and go. 2 years later, what happened to one of my coworkers? Same exact thing. He spent 3 days trying to fix it and basically had a workaround that crashed occasionally. I get paid to produce working software not configure my OS, and people wonder why Macs are so popular?
Switched from the Dell laptop to the Apple MacBook ProApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
I.. don't know. I'm a relatively new (~12mths) convert from a lifetime of Windows, and one of the things that has really surprised me is that I don't seem to need to care about RAM usage. I actually had to look up how to find out. I'm mostly photo editing (Exposure, XnView, Nitro) or doing small dev projects (VSCode, Rider). On a my old Dell laptop with 16GB RAM, I'd have to actively monitor RAM usage if I wanted Exposure to run well, shut down most other apps etc. On my MBP with 16GB, it has never been an issue. Right now I have: Mail, LibreWolf, Signal, Jellyfin, Bitwarden, LibreOffice, XnView, Nitro, Terminal, Safari, Calibre, Remote Desktop, WIIM Home, Notes and Rider open, along with a host of background things like VPN, Syncthing etc. Activity Monitor says 14.2GB used. But I'm not sure if that number matters, because I've never noticed running out of RAM.
Switched from the Dell laptop to the Apple MacBook ProApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
I decided my last Macbook Pro 15 was my last Macbook, then bought a top of the range DELL running Windows 10, and the fit and finish of both the device and the OS is just not there. Using the touchpad was a chore as it's not as responsive; ads pop up all over the Start menu; the monitor is blurry; and even setting up things like Bluetooth devices were hit and miss. Ended up getting another Macbook, for better or worse
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itDell laptop: Doesn’t like it
It was 2017 that I decided to go all in ensuring that my main work computers were built from parts sourced via the local Micro Center. The real eye-opening situation is even if I have a top line most expensive MacBook Pro or most expensive Dell laptop with full warranty, the truth is anytime there was a hardware issue which happened every 2 to 3 years it would destroy a day or more of work. you cannot have it fixed and returned to you the same day being able to have more redundancy in the ability to source individual parts locally is a gigantic financial benefit when you’re livelihood depends on a working high-performance systems as a high-end consultant. I also ensure that I have two laptops capable of running my work though neither perform as highly as my high-end gaming class workstation.