The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Apple PowerBook G4

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple PowerBook G4.

Apple MacBook ProApple PowerBook G4
Owners with an opinion390226
Positive verdicts62% of 327683% of 23
Positive/negative since 2024945/59212/2
Happy after 3+ years3556
Longest happy owner16 yrs12 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityperformance and durability
Criticized forbatteryreliability and build quality
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook G4: Likes it
I have used Macs since the Classic era. My best Mac was a PowerBook G4 that could run Windows on a VM faster than most Windows machines at the time. My first MacBook was brilliant, but I have noticed a decline since then. My 4-year-old MacBook Pro really struggles nowadays, whereas I remember a time when people proudly said their 10-year-old Macs were still snappy. Currently, Linux is the preferred choice for work. Windows 11 Enterprise is not bad when stripped of all social, news, and 360 ads overhead, but Microsoft is really trying hard to mess it up there too. And Mac is my driver, but maybe not for long.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook G4: Likes it
I’m right where you are. Very happy Apple customer since my first PowerBook G4. Currently have an M1 Max, an iPhone 17 Pro, the iPad Pro, HomePod, Apple TV, and Watch Ultra. All the _just works_ feeling and reliability seem to be gone. Tahoe is so unstable that I now restart the Mac every day, when in the past it happened on software updates only. Apple Music is another huge mess, I can’t comprehend how can it be so unreliable. Looking for exits as well and kind of looking forward to migrating to Graphene OS, self-hosted Immich, and Navidrome
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook G4: Likes it
> You're just making up facts [...] Here's objective facts and my experiences that I used to draw my conclusions. My final Android phones were: [1] a Samsung A7 (2017), which included a non-replaceable battery, shipped with Android 6 (2015), officially supported Android 8 (2017; theoretical first-party security patches which it never received were offered until 2021), no longer receives updates even from LineageOS, and never ran postmarketOS; and [2] a Nokia 3 (2017), which had pretty much the same story (support ended on Android 9). In 2019, someone gave me an old, smashed [3] iPhone 7 (2016), and the phone literally worked better than any Android phone I've owned before, including either of the two above. Since it was already physically falling apart, I took the liberty of getting [4] an iPhone SE (2020), which is still with me; the 7 continued to serve in the family for a couple more years. [1]: https://www.gsmarena.com/samsung_galaxy_a7_(2017)-8335.php [2]: https://www.gsmarena.com/nokia_3-8572.php [3]: https://www.gsmarena.com/apple_iphone_7-8064.php [4]: https://www.gsmarena.com/apple_iphone_se_(2020)-10170.php > All my non-Mac computers I'm using here have been around way longer than two years. I have a 2002 TiBook, which, believe me or not, continues to outlive my T61 and X200. My MBP (2017) had a spicy pillow though (which Apple repaired for free, outside of warranty). > [...] to protect your beloved brand/cult. I'm not a cultist, I'm a pragmatist. I used t…
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itApple PowerBook G4: Likes it
>the butterfly days I skipped that entire generation, but the modern silicon keyboards are slick. My workshop computer is a 2012 MacBook "Pro" (disabled GPU), which also has fantastic keys. Best Apple keyboard ever has to be the 12" PowerBook G4, but that may just be nostalgic ... ---- My major critique of the Neo is: for its intended market (younger), it should be more durable, not less — why is there no MagSafe power connector? From a computer repair technician's POV, there will be lot$ of U$B port replacement$, due to power supply abusers (have you seen some students' charging cables?!). From manufacturer's POV: if they had MagSafe, they probably wouldn't need separate USB ports (IMHO). It's almost guaranteed that the second revision of this product line will use MagSafe (you own the patent already! ).
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itApple PowerBook G4: Likes it
I enjoy my Framework 13 laptop; it’s great having a laptop that is user-serviceable and upgradable, and I’m keeping my eyes out on the upcoming Framework convertible laptop as a potential replacement for my aging Microsoft Surface Pro 7. With that said, I do wish the keyboard on my Framework 13 were better. It would be a wonderful to have a ThinkPad-quality keyboard, I have a ThinkPad T430 and its keyboard is one of the best chiclet-style keyboards I’ve ever used. I also like the keyboard on my old aluminum PowerBook G4, as well as the keyboard on my work-issued M3 MacBook Pro. What would be a dream, though, would be if there’s some way to fit a mechanical keyboard into a laptop.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itApple PowerBook G4: Likes it
It’s task-dependent for me as well. For development I think the current 16” MBPs are really about perfect, but for the use case of studying, web browsing, etc something in the range of 12-14” and as light as reasonably possible without negatively impacting battery life is about right. For those smaller machines, I think a squarish (5:4, 4:3, 3:2, or 16:10) aspect ratio with a body exactly as wide as a full-size laptop keyboard (as seen in 12” PowerBook G4, 12” MacBook, and ThinkPad X220) is particularly good, but nobody makes those anymore.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itApple PowerBook G4: Likes it
Apple laptops had an amazing run from 2000-2015, starting with the Titanium PowerBook G4 and ending with the retina MacBook Pro (pre-touchbar). FYI MagSafe was introduced with the first intel MacBook Pros in 2006 (although they had a nearly identical case as the PowerBook G4), so unfortunately no PowerPC notebooks had it.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralApple PowerBook G4: Neutral
There are tradeoffs. (I've owned and used Powerbooks and MacBooks from the beginning -- I had a Powerbook 100, the 16 mhz 68000 with a lead acid battery. Used a 140 and 170 of that era as well. And a Duo230, and a 5300, and a Duo 2300, Tibook G4, White x86 Macbook, 2012 era Air and MBP, 2015 MBPs, a work 2017 MBP, Last x86 Air, M1 Air). Early machines had a lot of flex. The hinges creaked. The trackball gummed up. Some of their keyboards were good (the 140 and 170 especially had _really_ nice mechanical keyboards, and a good trackball as well). And some of the keyboards were mushy goo (the Duos, and the Tibook to a lesser extent. Basically the low point till the 2016 MBP). Despite the magnesium frames in the duo, the whole computer could flex enough that the battery would disconnect while in use. Also, the Duos were a royal pain to repair -- I remmeber an hour or more to disassemble to get to one little piece in the back that needed replaced -- I think it was a serial port. The spring loaded keyboard on the G4 (and the toilet seat ibooks) was great from a maintenance POV, because you could get into the innards really easily to replace memory, drives, etc. But the keyboards on the unibody are soooo much better. The Tibook was an inflection point where the machines started lasting me more than a couple of years. Some of that was probably usage patterns (having a desktop for the heavy lifting), and some was build quality (and possibly, some was buying a top of the line machine f…
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itApple PowerBook G4: Likes it
My 2007 BlackBook was, I think, my favorite computer of all time. As a college student, it was such a huge upgrade from my previous Sony Vaio (that while beautiful, quite literally burned/discolored/cooked my upper thigh -- it took almost two years for the area to stop being discolored) and I gladly paid the Black Tax, with the justification that it was really just $50 if you compared it to a CTO price with the same size HDD. But honestly, the color WAS worth the price difference for me. To this day, I think the plastic Black MacBook design is just perfect. I will always love the 12" PowerBook G4, but for me, that black plastic is just timeless in a clean and excellent way. A side-effect of the Black Tax was that the cracked palm wrest issue that impacted a lot of white MacBooks, didn't seem to impact the Black models nearly as much (Apple replaced the top component I believe for people with yellowed or cracked palm wrests). As much as I love my 14" MacBook Pro Max, if I could have it in solid black, I would love it (that or bring back the true rose gold color and give it to the Pro machines, cowards!).