The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro vs Apple PowerBook

Hacker News owners lean toward the Apple PowerBook.

Apple MacBook ProApple PowerBook
Owners with an opinion390282
Positive verdicts62% of 327676% of 75
Positive/negative since 2024945/59227/8
Happy after 3+ years35510
Longest happy owner16 yrs24 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and comfort
Criticized forbatteryperformance and portability
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralApple PowerBook: Likes it
It was with the first generation of unibody macbooks in 2008, if I remember correctly. I have a Powerbook G4 with a nice matte screen, and I distinctly remember the first generation of non-unibody MBP also having a similar matte screen. So it's been a while. 18 years with glossy screens.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Likes it
Yeah the sharp edges have bothered me since they started with the unibody. Luckily I'm completely off Mac these days. But really the last mac I enjoyed using was my powerbook. It had really nice plastic gaskets for the edges, a keyboard with really good travel and cupped keys, it was wonderful. I got a plastic MacBook eventually which I filed down too because the edges were really sharp there. And plastic is easy to file. Also replaced the screen with a matte version, on the plastic MacBook that was also easy because the screens were readily available and there was no glass overlay. Then I had a unibody MBP 15" matte. Less sharp and with off factory matte display. Not great keyboard though. The current MBP I find abhorrent. Even after they switched from the horrible butterfly mistake the travel is still way too shallow. I just can't work with that anymore. These days I just don't buy laptops anymore. Only desk PCs.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Likes it
I really liked the 12" MacBook (although my all time favourite computer was the 12" PowerBook G4 - chunky by today's standards but I just loved it). I saw a review of the MacBook Neo where the reviewer was yearning after the 12" - but suggested that Apple has made UI elements so big with such ridiculous spacing and border radius that it would be almost unusable at anything less than 13". Which would not surprise me in the least - I struggle with my 16" MBP and this crappy UI "framework".
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Neutral
That's funny you say that, because this is precisely the time, I started buying Macs (I got a Pismo PowerBook G3 gifted and then bought an iBook G4). And my experience was that for sure, if you put as much money into a PC than in a Mac you would get MUCH better performance. What made it worth it at the time (I felt) was the software. Today I'm really don't think so, software has improved overall in the industry and there is not a lot of things "Mac specific" that makes it a clear-cut choice. As for the performance I can't believe all the Apple silicon hype. Sure, it gets good battery life given you use strictly Apple software (or software optimized for it heavily) but in mixed workload situation it's not that impressive. Using the M2 MacBook Pro of a friend I figured I could get maybe 4-5 hours out of its best case scenario which is better than the 2-3 hours you would get from a PC laptop but also not that great considering the price difference. And when it comes to performance it is extremely unequal and very lackluster for many things. Like there is more lag launching Activity Monitor on a 2K++ MacBook Pro than launching task manager on a 500 PC. This is a small somewhat stupid example but it does tell the overall story. They talk a big game but in reality, their stuff isn't that performant in the real world. And they still market games when one of their 2K laptops plays Dota 2 (a very old, relatively ressource efficient game) worse than a cheapo PC.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Likes it
I have had many Apple devices since the 2nd gen iPod, and they have all lasted a very long time compared to my other devices. All my laptops back to my 15” PowerBook is still working. They have fixed a faulty GPU on a 4 year old laptop for free, even though I had opened the laptop and changed thermal paste. (Known manufacturing issue with that GPU, but still impressive) They have made mistakes. Like the battery in my current 2015 MBP is too hard to replace. And I avoided upgrading for a long time due to the known issues with the keyboards. But it seems like they generally correct when making mistakes like that. I do agree that SSDs shouldn’t be soldered on though. Hopefully it’s one of the mistakes they’ll eventually fix. I kind of understand the motivation.. you can make it impossible to effectively steal a device, or access its contents. The device becomes very simple and robust in some ways. But they could come up with a good compromise. Like, sure, keep the concept of not having an SSD controller on the drive, and firmware on the SSD. But sell replacement SSDs with the firmware and a recover OS preloaded. One that lets you provision the new drive with the SOC through your iCloud account. Depending on the on-chip storage and whether it’s fuse/EPROM-based or flash, the number of possible drive replacements might be limited. But that’s an OK compromise.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Likes it
I had one of these. (and a 230, and a 100. I liked small). The localtalk/serial port was not well attached, so if it was used much (like, pluggin in an external modem over and over) it would get loose and detach from the board. The ethernet dock was super fast (for 10bT) in my recollection, possibly because of the PDS attachment. Never had a full sized dock, or to my recollection, ever plugged a floppy into one of my machines. The keyboard wasn't as bad as the 230, but it's not good either. On the other hand, the 140/170 series had unbelievably good keyboards. Compared to other machines of the time, they were a complete pain to disassemble to replace parts. I think I did memory and a modem at one point. The only worse one I can recall is replacing the keyboard on a unibody MBP.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itApple PowerBook: Doesn’t like it
Whoa! I remember experiencing this and just assuming it must be my imagination! I also remember that same laptop getting those pits. No where as dramatic as the pictures in the linked page, but still pronounced. Crazy. It's never happened to my more recent MBPs.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itApple PowerBook: Doesn’t like it
I had this occur with my 2004 PowerBook back in the day, it was pretty bad. At the time I had found a company that made adhesive transparent stickers that you could place on either side of the trackpad that would protect the aluminium from being eaten away by the sweat on your palms. I bought this when I upgraded from my PB to my Core 2 Duo MBP in 2007, fearing that this newer machine would suffer the same fate as my PowerBook, but all is well and that machine didn't experience pitting. Having said that, the pictures in the link are pretty bad, I've never seen pitting that bad before, that looks horrendous!
Apple MacBook Pro: Recommends itApple PowerBook: Likes it
The unibody and shift away from moving parts really did do wonders for Mac laptop durability in day to day usage. This naturally affects the conditions these machines are available in on the used market. Any of the pre-TiBook plastic models are likely to have cracked plastic with bits that have chipped off due to growing brittle with age. PowerBook G3s are likely to have their exteriors scratched up. Fruit flavored iBooks commonly have parts missing. As you noted, TiBooks have big problems with paint chipping and had bad hinges. Once you get into the aluminum models things improve quite a lot… the PowerBook G4s and MacBook Pro’s, both pre and post unibody can easily be found in great condition. The counterpart white plastic iBook G3s/G4s and MacBooks also fared better, but are sometimes subject to yellowing. These generally don’t have mechanical issues and usually just need to have their spinning rust swapped out for an SSD and a thermal paste change to get them running nicely again. That said, the pre-unibody alu Powerbooks and white plastic iBooks/MacBooks are a pain in the butt to work on. So many screws. If one doesn’t have much patience for that kind of thing and doesn’t explicitly need PowerPC one of the unibody MBPs with at least a Core 2 Duo is a no brainer when selecting an old Mac to tinker with.
Apple MacBook Pro: NeutralApple PowerBook: Likes it
There are tradeoffs. (I've owned and used Powerbooks and MacBooks from the beginning -- I had a Powerbook 100, the 16 mhz 68000 with a lead acid battery. Used a 140 and 170 of that era as well. And a Duo230, and a 5300, and a Duo 2300, Tibook G4, White x86 Macbook, 2012 era Air and MBP, 2015 MBPs, a work 2017 MBP, Last x86 Air, M1 Air). Early machines had a lot of flex. The hinges creaked. The trackball gummed up. Some of their keyboards were good (the 140 and 170 especially had _really_ nice mechanical keyboards, and a good trackball as well). And some of the keyboards were mushy goo (the Duos, and the Tibook to a lesser extent. Basically the low point till the 2016 MBP). Despite the magnesium frames in the duo, the whole computer could flex enough that the battery would disconnect while in use. Also, the Duos were a royal pain to repair -- I remmeber an hour or more to disassemble to get to one little piece in the back that needed replaced -- I think it was a serial port. The spring loaded keyboard on the G4 (and the toilet seat ibooks) was great from a maintenance POV, because you could get into the innards really easily to replace memory, drives, etc. But the keyboards on the unibody are soooo much better. The Tibook was an inflection point where the machines started lasting me more than a couple of years. Some of that was probably usage patterns (having a desktop for the heavy lifting), and some was build quality (and possibly, some was buying a top of the line machine f…
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itApple PowerBook: Doesn’t like it
I remember playing with the OS X Beta. We'd install it on a friends Powerbook G3 and after a couple days go back to OS 9 because it was so much faster and it didn't use all your memory. Not too soon after that, I bought a Powerbook G4. 867MHz, and Mac Mall doubled the RAM back then so I had 256 or 512MB, I forget. It was still pretty slow and after fumbling around with it for a few months, I sold it. Was nice for playing with iMovie using a Firewire VHS-C camera, though. Then around 2006, a friend purchased one of the first Intel MacBook models. We had fun trying to get all of his old PowerPC era stuff working on it. It was still slow, and hot. Finally, in 2010 I bought a 13" MacBook Pro and was in love ever since. Not sure how everyone else stuck around so long.
Switched from the Apple PowerBook to the Apple MacBook ProApple MacBook Pro: Likes it
Don't buy it if your only reason for doing so is 'buzz.' Have you considered trying out a "Hackintosh"-type setup first? If that doesn't work for you, you could still sell the PC easily and then buy a Mac. I make very good money in the US, and I still took several weeks to talk myself into buying a new Macbook Pro to replace an '05 Powerbook (in part because I already have a 27" iMac as my main computer.) Apples are expensive. To me, it is the software that makes them a great value, though. If you bought the MBP, would you still have the funds to spend on software and to complete your freelance/startup work without major sacrifices? I think it is ridiculous to ask a question like this on HN since we don't really know your financial circumstances. Are you really just wanting us to help rationalize a decision you've already made? ;-) [And now...my first HN cross-post ever:] RE: Fusion vs. Parallels I just bought a new MB Pro and am getting ready to install Parallels on it for the first time. I've always used Fusion on my Macs (to triple-boot with Win and Linux) in the past. I thought Parallels was currently the leader in the shootouts regarding speed/features? Anyone keep up to date with their VM horse race or have a good reason to use one over the other? I already have licenses for both. Thanks.
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Doesn’t like it
I have a 350MHz Power Mac G4 from 1999, and it’s one of the most thoughtfully designed desktops I’ve used. Not only is it visually appealing, but it is very easy to access its components using its door. Ive was also behind many other innovative desktops, such as the iMac G4 and the Power Mac G4 Cube. I enjoy my “trash can” Mac Pro; it’s just too bad the dual-GPU approach was a dead end. While I believe Ive took his desires for thinness and simplicity too far with the 2016 MacBook Pro, I appreciate the work done on the PowerBook G4 (titanium and aluminum), the original MacBook Pro, the unibody MacBook Pro, and the Retina MacBook Pro. These successive laptops set the standard for laptop design, and they helped make laptops easy to place in a backpack. Laptops used to be quite bulky in the 1990s; I have a PowerBook 5300 I acquired nearly a decade ago that is quite thick and heavy. I don’t agree with all of Ive’s design decisions, but overall I like his designs.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itApple PowerBook: Likes it
My 12" powerbook from 2002 lasted well into 2011 until I formally retired it by giving to a mate. Most of my macbook airs have lasted at least 7 to 8 years. None have actually died and were still intact, but I just gave them away, so I don't know how much longer they lasted. My 2015 macbook pro (pre butterfly) is still going strong today; I did a battery replacement myself which was a huge pain in the arse, so it definitely feels replenished. I have replaced many of my family members laptops with M-series laptops, nay issue, and I have a feeling they'll easily go a decade, though at some point they'll all need the battery replaced (but I will probably just have Apple do it this time - unless it is easy now with the repair manuals being available by Apple).
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Doesn’t like it
> Maybe, just maybe, Apple's characteristic product management results in blatant failures. I know, I went through a couple of real lemons, like the 2nd-hand PowerBook 5400c I had as a kid, or the early MBP with a bad GeForce, and an overheating late Intel MBP with an awful keyboard. I also still have a hockey puck mouse somewhere. And again, Aqua had its excesses and I strongly disliked their turn to flat design. All I am saying is that the concept of liquid glass is interesting and I am sure they will iterate over time to fix issues. All the legibility and readability concerns could be addressed by tweaking the opacity of the buttons whilst keeping the dynamic and kinetics aspects of it without throwing the whole thing away. There are many precedents, it would not be really unexpected. > Not everything has to be history repeating itself, Apple has proven more than adept at inventing new ways to fail. Apple Car and Airpower both come to mind - sometimes it just doesn't work out. Yes indeed. I am not arguing otherwise.
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itApple PowerBook: Likes it
It's funny: there was a time when Apple understood that it could attract customers by making its devices the first choice for developers. And it did a good job, with a real Unix underneath that wasn't overly hidden, with a lot of open source support, and just generally being an ok citizen in the developer world. That strategy, which I think ran from early OSX through until mid-2010's? worked, and you'd see the results, with a sea of glowing Apple logos, even at Linux conferences. I think they've changed since then. It feels now like developers are not a priority, even as they've re-added some power-user features in recent years. As for longevity, I think my current laptop speaks for itself. It's now 11 years old, and going strong. I've carried it around the world, dropped it numerous times, and it's been the best laptop I've every owned. They do artificially force an end-of-life, usually at around 7 years old, for their operating system. I don't really have a problem with that: I appreciate that it's difficult to continue to support old hardware in new releases, and I think that timeframe is reasonable. I'd prefer that it was explicitly stated, and I'd prefer it was longer, but ... it's not bad, really. Over the years I have had many devices: desktop PCs, Unix workstations, Linux workstations, and laptops from 6" to 17". In the early 2000s I bought a 12" Powerbook, which was my first Mac -- the motivation was to get seamless Microsoft Office document support on a Unix…
Apple MacBook Pro: Doesn’t like itApple PowerBook: Doesn’t like it
Another sample, my MBP set itself on fire in the boot of my car (examination revealed, the thunderbolt or whatever chip ignited). My XPS13 is going strong after years of abuse and being lugged around the world in hand luggage. My old powerbook and ibook (remember those?!) Both had live current running through the case screws which caused a stingy shock on bare legs. I've never seen an Apple laptop that didn't look nice but ultimately have weird issues
Apple MacBook Pro: Likes itApple PowerBook: Likes it
The 2012-2015 model was uniquely uncomfortable for me. The Touch Bar first generation with the butterfly keyboard is my gold standard for comfort, if not necessarily reliability, with the current generation of M1 Pro/Max MacBook Pro being a close second. Joint second goes to the aluminum PowerBook.