The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook Pro M1 vs Lenovo ThinkPad

No clear winner: owners rate them about the same.

Apple MacBook Pro M1Lenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion5342732
Positive verdicts76% of 43875% of 2366
Positive/negative since 2024137/47686/273
Happy after 3+ years20281
Longest happy owner6 yrs25 yrs
Praised forperformance and batteryreliability and performance
Criticized forreliabilitybattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook Pro M1: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I've been on the Mac since 2001 for my personal machines, with Windows at work and I've had linux installations on and off since late '92. I have decided that I won't replace my aging M1 MBP. I got an used thinkpad and installed Fedora 41. It's really been a stellar distro. I've been in it full time for a couple months now. Since I'm now retired I don't need to have the latest and greatest. Linux is just fine for me and the remaining development work I do. I guess I've always known I'd end up on Linux.
Apple MacBook Pro M1: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I had a T420 in college. One day in a CS class, I bumped my (uncovered) cup of coffee and it spilled into the keyboard. I knew the laptop had ducts to drain water out, but never tested it (for obvious reasons). I blotted up as much coffee as I could with some napkins and kept taking notes on the soaked keyboard. Worked like a charm. After drying it out, a few keys stopped working so I bought a replacement keyboard for ~$20 and swapping it out was rather fast (from memory). I use an M1 MBP now, but I still have that thing in the basement. It still works, and I loved it. I don't miss carrying it around though (or the hilariously short battery life due to forcing discrete GPU mode so I could dock it for multiple monitors at home).
Apple MacBook Pro M1: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I don't have a medium account so I can only see the first paragraph ish, but I will comment that I used to daily drive a thinkpad T440p that I bought off ebay for ~$140, and ran arch linux on it. I was living the dream every article or think-piece like this seems to believe in. I now (for a laptop) use an M1 pro macbook pro. The reason why I was open to buying a new laptop at all is because I had gotten used to watching youtube videos at 2x speed, and it literally couldn't handle it. The video would freeze and the audio would keep going and the only fix was to refresh the page multiple times per video. I recently went on a week long trip, and needed a linux laptop, so I brought it with me, and was working on an OpenGL project. Practically every time I hit compile, the entire X session would freeze, to the point where the clock in the KDE taskbar wasn't even updating anymore, and the only fix was to hard reset the machine (I have never gotten magic sysreq working on that computer). I now have a framework 16 on preorder to be my linux laptop. I also never got the webcam to be detected by linux (looking in lsusb, lspci, etc) even though it was enabled in the bios, the battery life wasn't enough to make it through a day of classes on one charge, and it ran too hot to be comfortable on my lap. To its credit, the keyboard was nice, the trackpoint was fine, and when the trackpad died entirely, I was able to buy a new one (also on ebay) and swap them out without issue. With an SSD,…
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
> It’s especially on me as my last private intel MBP before my “maxed out” M1 MBP wore out its on-board SSD after only 4 years and that one was large (1TB) with ample memory for the time (16GB). I wonder how that's possible, and whether that's an outlier rather than a case of probable risk to SSDs. I've got the impression that it shouldn't be likely to wear out a modern or semi-modern SSD with any kinds of typical laptop workloads. I daily drove a 500 GB off-the-shelf SSD in a 8 GB ThinkPad for ~8 years, and while it was for personal device, I used it a lot and even played games on it, often ran into swapping, even hibernated semi-regularly at times, etc., and there were never any signs of problems with the SSD. 4 years sounds like pretty bad luck.
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
This is a design flaw of all macbooks at the moment. Basically the keyboard is riveted into the top case and the battery is stuck to that as well. That means they have to pretty much transplant the logic board and the screen into another shell and stick a new battery in it as well. This is the very definition of a shit show. I have a 14" M1 MBP which I am selling next month as I have already switched to a ThinkPad T14 gen 3 running Windows 11. This is the keyboard replacement process for that: https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/Lenovo+ThinkPad+T14+Gen+3+Keybo...
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Recommends it
In the article they (you?) says T480 and explicitly not T470. I own a T470 and have been using it only with Linux since new and would still highly recommend it. Some of the upgrades they did I had ordered from Lenovo upon order (screen, battery, RAM). Mine has a i7-7600U however, which is maybe where the differential he's referring to lies. The newer i5 has double the cores/threads to 4/8 vs 2/4 in the i7 of the T470. Regardless, the T470 is still my daily driver as my personal laptop and everything works as good as the day I bought it. It's still jarring typing on my M1 MBP 16 after spending any time on the T470. Apple still has garbage for keyboards. Have they gotten better? Sure. They're still horrible though.
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
The new Thinkpads are quite a disaster unfortunately, on Linux and elsewhere. I'm sitting in front of a T14 right now, which I regularly have to unplug / reboot as the firmware is faulty and randomly puts the laptop into an extreme power-saving mode where all CPU cores get throttled to 400 MHz. There are a bunch of other issues & glitches that happen randomly, i.e. ethernet not coming up after suspend, trackpad getting really jittery after sleep etc. etc. It's really a shame because most other stuff works well under Linux, but these random issues are wearing me out. I also work on an M1 Macbook Pro and while that's not perfect either it wastes a lot less of my time, and it runs Ubuntu via Parallels as well as the Thinkpad. So I guess for me that will finally be the last straw, unless Apple messes up badly I don't think I'll buy a Thinkpad again.
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
I'm using both a 16'' Macbook Pro (M1) and a 14' Lenovo T14 (Gen 3), the former mostly for work and the latter for personal computing using Linux (Kubuntu). Both machines are great, the new T14 was the first laptop I was happy to replace my T460p with. I tried a few of the earlier Lenovo models but they were terrible and hardly offered any performance improvements over my 5 year old model. The Macbook is of course an amazing device, build quality is great and if you're a fan of MacOS it's the perfect machine. It has a humongous battery as well (almost 100 Wh I think), which really gives it an edge over the T14 (50 Wh), especially since the base power draw is lower (7W vs. 11 W), which itself is ridiculous given the larger screen size. That said the T14 is the perfect Linux machine, everything works out of the box without issues, even the touchscreen and the fingerprint reader. There is still a minor issue when suspending/waking up (touchpad reactivity will degrade), but I hope there will be a fix soon.
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I am using Arch/Asahi Linux on a new MacBook Pro M1 Pro since July as daily driver. I mainly use IntelliJ IDEA for Java and Scala development in KDE (which is installed by default if you choose the UI install). For IntelliJ you have to download the aarch64 JBR yourself and set it in a config file. However upgcoming version 2022.3 will support aarch64/arm OS out of the box... So far it works very very good. Rendering is done by the CPU, but the machine is so fast it's not really an issue (at least compared to my old Thinkpad). However can't wait for the GPU driver to arrive, looking at the posted tweet., I guess that should happen within the next few weeks. For Zoom calls (which I don't have so often) I still have to switch to macOS right now, but AFAIK USB 3 support should work also soon, so I can use my Elgato Facecam soon hopefully. I can listen music/watch youtube with my Pixel Buds Pro via Bluetooth, no problem. Suspending/closing the lid doesn't freeze the userspace yet, but this is already fixed and will arive soon: https://twitter.com/marcan42/status/1582363763617181696 In the last 4 months I only heard the fan once or twice, when opening dozens tabs that run aggressive adds (animations), but with the upcoming GPU driver that will not be an issue anymore. And by "hear" I mean like "what is this quite noice...? or that's the macbook fans..." - when I start my old Thinkpad, it's like a airplane in the runway preparing to start. Battery life is quite good actually, this…
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Yep. Even the 14 & 16" MBP with M1 Pros stay much cooler & quieter than your typical AMD/Intel Windows laptop. Silence is golden, and even on the odd occasion where the fan on the 14" M1 Pro starts spinning (e.g. running Cinebench to purposefully max all cores), it's extremely difficult to notice without your ear right up against the laptop. By comparison, my Windows work laptops (previously an XPS 15, now a ThinkPad T14 Gen2) become plainly audible from 10ft+ away just attending a Teams meeting.
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
For me personally; 1x 13" M1 MBP with 16GB/1TB best device I've ever owned. I do everything on this from dev work, to browsing, photo editing, fiddling around in Logic Pro, and even some light gaming. And I can do all of that (probably at the same time) while running on battery, for hours on end. 1x Windows "gaming" desktop I built a few months ago. i5/16GB/6700XT/2TB NVMe/8TB rust. It's ok, I thought I'd use it a lot more than I do and I'm DEFINITELY not getting my money's worth out of the 6700XT playing HOI and Factorio. 1x Ex-business Optiplex micro, i5/16gb/512SSD + 2x 4TB USB disks running Ubuntu. This is my main linux machine that doubles as a light home server running Plex and a few other little things. 1x iPad mini from last year, mostly just for reading and media. I do use my knockoff Apple Pencil to jot down some notes as well. Also makes a neat little secondary display for the MBP if I'm away from my desk and want some more screen. 1x Heavily refurbished Thinkpad T470 running Arch (btw) i7/16GB/256GB. Barely gets used despite the amount of work I put into refurbishing it. The poor old i7 (dual core version) really struggles with some stuff, even basic things like Youtube over 1080p nearly kills it. I feel like I've hit a good equilibrium of devices, I can fit it all onto one desk with a USB-C monitor and a keyboard/mouse that I can switch between devices (including my work laptop). Nothing other than ye olde Thinkpad ever goes unused for more than a day or two at m…
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I did that. When I bought our first M1 Mac, it was faster in multi-core Rust builds than my Ryzen 3700X workstation. I have since upgraded to an M1 Pro and a Ryzen 5900X. The 5900X is faster (12 cores vs. 8 performance cores and 2 efficiency cores), but not by much. For example, building one of my Rust projects: M1 Pro: ~ % cargo install --force finalfrontier [...] Finished release [optimized] target(s) in 16.25s 5900X: ~ % cargo install --force finalfrontier [...] Finished release [optimized] target(s) in 11.61s If we count the two efficiency cores as being as powerful as a single performance core, the performance, the per-core performance is on-par ((9/12.) * 16.25 = 12.1875). In other tasks, the M1 Pro blows the Ryzen 5900 away. For example, the M1 Pro reaches 2685 GFLOP/s in matrix multiplication, while the Ryzen 5900X peaks at 1555 GFLOP/s [1]. Oh and all of that while the Ryzen CPU alone consumes 120W during builds and needs a big loud fan (Noctua), while the MacBook Pro is inaudible and runs on battery. The MacBook I can throw in my backpack and use everywhere. The best computer is the one that's with you. (And no, mobile Ryzen doesn't even come close. I had a ThinkPad with a high-end Ryzen CPU last year, and builds where much slower than even the vanilla M1.) [1] https://github.com/danieldk/gemm-benchmark#1-to-16-threads
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
I had similar experiences with the T14 AMD that I used for over half a year. On Linux the Trackpad would often not come back after sleep. Also, the battery would drain very quickly in S3 suspend. The laptop would take off during video calls (though the fan noise was definitely not as bad as with many Intel models). In the end it was really a thousand of paper cuts, especially with Linux, despite the laptop being certified with Linux. The hardware itself was pretty ok and worked fairly well with Windows (I just don't like Windows). In the end I went back to MacBooks. First an M1 Air, now a MBP 14" with an an M1 Pro. They are insanely fast, while staying cool. The fan on the Pro only spins up during long builds, but even then it's barely audible. If you don't like macOS, getting an old(er) ThinkPad is probably the best option.
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Being a frequent on /r/thinkpads I was delighted to see a fellow ThinkPad enthusiast! Can't remember how many TP's I've had over the years but I'll attest to the older models being solid laptops. The newer ones, however, are disappointing. My last good ThinkPad was a T470s with an i5, 8GB, 256GB (UNIX/Windows). After several years of (ab)use, I wanted to splurge on a X1 Gen3 and the specs were more than enough for my needs with an i7 (hexa-core), 16GB, 512 GB, 1050TI, 1080p 400nits display. However, when I got it and started to use it hardware issues stared to pile up. I went back to my trusty T470s and sold the X1. Now I have an MBP M1 Pro and it's great.
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Seems like lots of IT folks have fond memories of the T420/T430 (and X220) era. I personally think it was the golden age of the Thinkpad line, going back perhaps to T40/T42, it was some of the best laptops I ever worked on. No other laptop has come close to getting it right since. It was really the perfect combination of build quality, modularity and performance that won me over. I'm now on the new M1 Pro Mac and while the battery life is amazing, I felt a lot more confident working on my T420 back in the day. And yes I tried the X1 Carbon/Extreme lines, and I wasn't sold on them either.
Apple MacBook Pro M1: Recommends itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
I have a 4 years old Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon, it's running windows though, but I also develop only on Ubuntu through WSL2. So my opinion is more about the hardware than the software. I also have a 13" MacBook pro M1. I use the MacBook, because it has a much better battery life, it doesn't get warm, and it's not extremely slow on battery power. The i7 needs to be connected to power to be not annoyingly slow, but then it will cook my legs and genitals. The ThinkPad has a touchscreen, which is a huge plus for me, but I am not sure the user experience will be great on a full GNU/Linux distribution. They are both very good laptops, but the MacBook is much better if you can manage Mac os.