The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook M1 vs Lenovo ThinkPad

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Lenovo ThinkPad.

Apple MacBook M1Lenovo ThinkPad
Owners with an opinion2112732
Positive verdicts73% of 18075% of 2366
Positive/negative since 202458/21686/273
Happy after 3+ years4281
Longest happy owner4.1 yrs25 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityreliability and performance
Criticized forsoftwarebattery
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook M1: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I still have my Thinkpad X201 from 2011 running, and I use it as my personal machine (have an M1 MacBook from/for work). Of course, had to replace the hard drive once or twice, replaced the whole motherboard once[0], and even though it's 64-bit, the CPU arch (Westmere) lacks some instructions that make some things non-functional (MongoDB, some Steam games don't start), and I had to limit the CPU frequency so it doesn't go into thermal shutdown. Nonetheless it's a joy to use still, and I boot it up with pleasure every time... Thinking when will I pull the trigger on a Framework, though at least I don't feel the pressure too much just yet. :) [0]: https://gergely.imreh.net/blog/2022/07/an-open-heart-motherb...
Apple MacBook M1: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
I'm going to purchase a framework just because I value repairability. And honestly, before the m1 macbook I was using a t480s, and I'm okay with compromising on hardware, esp. having been burned with the 2016 butterfly macbook. Apart from the haptic touchpad I wouldn't miss much, other makers are finally ditching low resolution 16:9 screens and you can even find nice oleds. I'm mostly missing the polished software that's only available on macos (things like carbon copy cloner or pixelmator). But with my m1 having degraded battery and having to send it off for a week or two to the nearest service center just to get a new battery, the prospect of a repairable laptop like framework where I can just order a new battery and replace it myself is looking all the more enticing.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
Our Thinkpads are definitely hotter; fans spin up routinely on the Ryzens but never does on the M1. Battery life is infinitely better on the M1. The other thing I hate about the Thinkpads is that the build/screen/trackpad quality sucks in comparison to the Apple stuff. And for all the griping about Mac OS on this site, Windows is way worse - you can tell MS's focus is on linux in the cloud these days. All the ancillary stuff Apple is good at is underappreciated.
Apple MacBook M1: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I just bought a used Thinkpad T470, and with arch linux (btw), hyprland, and neovim, I’m starting to like this machine more than my M1 macbook. The one thing I always thought my M1 couldn’t be beat at by an IBM compatible laptop is battery life, but the T470 actually has very good battery life. I’m not using the T470 for anything CPU intensive, but it’s the same with my MacBook. Just hobby projects, mostly writing code. I’m starting to wonder why I paid > 1k for a MacBook when a $200 used thinkpad is totally fine.
Apple MacBook M1: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Thinkpad x220 checking in, still rocking my Sandy Lake and still enjoying a real keyboard. It's about 12 now. Other laptops have come and gone. I couldn't live with my macbook m1. I hated the keyboard and the desktop - why is there no delete key, pray? UTM crashed a lot. Asahi was lovely but I just didn't like touching the hardware.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
Anecdata, but before going all-in on ThinkPads I though I share my experience. For the ThinkPad x13 2nd gen Ryzen I received for a customer project (with the customer not interested in getting it back after the project was completed) it's too early to say anything about reliability, but somehow the touchpad isn't centered properly and I always hit left click when I want right click - it's unbearable and surprisingly bad for a ThinkPad. Before, I had an ThinkPad E495 Ryzen that worked ok but after two years the touchpad got stuck - the pointless (for me!) construction with touch point and extra mechanical buttons (only acting as barrier) certainly didn't help. Before, I had my beloved Dell XPS 2016 which however had a swollen battery. Still, I consider it one of the best notebooks I had; gnome 2 and Unity also just got it right. In the last four years I got five (!) ThinkPad and Dell Precision notebooks for customer projects having battery or memory problems OOTB (the x13 I mentioned above was a notebook that finally worked). The notebook I used for the longest time (7 years) was a PowerBook G4 2003. I hope my current MacBook M1 will last me about as long, but at least 5 years. In terms of power management, display, and usability, a Mac notebook is in another league compared to Dells and ThinkPads with Linux, it's not even funny. Linux desktops have regressed to the point they have ceased to be usable for me. With the newer MacBooks, I think Apple listened to customers and na
Apple MacBook M1: Doesn’t like itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I also do all of my development on various ThinkPads I've owned throughout my life: T480, T490, P51.. I like cheap, upgradeable laptops over Macs since: * I can put what I want in them. I don't want to pay Apple 200 euros for 8GB of RAM. * It's not a treasure. I take care of it because it would be annoying to have to replace it, but my wallet wouldn't cry over a cheap second-hand machine * They run Linux well * My P51 has a Quadro dGPU that can play basically all games before 2018, which is enough for me (and better than what a M1 can do) I literally don't see an advantage to owning a M1 besides better resolution (why people want a trillion pixels on their screen I don't get also. I can see perfectly fine without 4K) and build quality.
Apple MacBook M1: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Doesn’t like it
A year ago I bought my first Macbook after using Linux as my default for years. I was tired of declining hardware quality from Thinkpad and I kept having to replace them. I also was interested in the M1's battery life and bright screen for doing more work outside. There was also a shortage of builds using new Ryzens that were competitive at the time, so the Apple premium wasn't really that much more. I just really haven't used it much beyond casual use cases (streaming/web). The main, and maybe dumb, reason is that it's been a lot of work to get the keymap to function. I still use Windows/Linux, and relearning everything after having used Emacs layouts for 10+ years just isn't going to work for me. Some of the desktop/windows management stuff also feels clunky as well. I like the hardware quality and everything looks nice, but it might be my last.
Apple MacBook M1: NeutralLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Lenovo ThinkPad X1 or X1 Nano are my favorites. Small, light, but powerful. Before I used the ThinkPad X230 and DELL Latitude 7270, each for many years and bought second hand. The DELL was particularly sturdy. All of these are Ubuntu LTS friendly boxes. Avoid Microsoft Surface Laptops, which require patches to run Linux, Microsoft doesn't offer an Image ready to burn on a stick. And although I'm writing this on an M1 MacBook, I can't recommend that box yet as a primary machine; I use it mostly for making and presenting slides and browsing HN and such, not for serious dev work. In a year's time, this may look different.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
My main Laptop it's a T430, and from time to time I use a T440p. It's amazing how you can disassemble the whole thing with only one screwdriver and upgrade almost everything. The T420 keyboard mod it's what's stopping me from upgrading to a newer model. Don't get me wrong it's not mechanical or anything, but has the comfiest layout I have tried on any laptop so far. There are some drawbacks: * New batteries are rare * The display it's bad * After Covid, it's expensive to get replacements parts like plastics bezels or motherboards. * The GPU or iGPU it's bad. Gonna be a problem in a few years with how demanding web pages are. Forget about video editing or gaming beyond simple things. * New Linux kernels could drop support for some of the drivers in the future. This thing's great, but it's old. In any case, if I upgrade to anything in the future, it will probably be a framework laptop. M1 Macbooks are probably the best cost-benefit laptop out there for a lot of people (battery, display, cpu power), and I kinda want to try one. But I don't feel comfortable voting with my wallet for Apple's practices, especially with how hostile they have been with the "right to repair" movement.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Neutral
When faced with the same issue (optimizing for time wrt computer setup), I moved from a thinkpad with Arch Linux to an M1 MacBook + headless Ubuntu server under my desk. Truly best of both worlds in my experience- incredible battery life and everything ‘just works’ for normal workflows on the MacBook, and can ssh into the headless Ubuntu box directly or from anywhere with internet. Depending on your dev needs, this anecdote may be useful: I’ve exclusively used vim and VS Code with a remote server extension to target the Ubuntu box for builds and I haven’t touched the setup for 6-8 months. Also, if you’re willing to spend some time learning, getting into Nix ends up saving time in the long run as your nix shell definitions should provide replicable user / build environments on top of whatever Linux flavor you happen to be running at the time, for the headless dev box
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
>So maybe the ones you saw are scams as well I bought one already so I know it's not a scam. Scams usually communicate badly and they don't want to meet you in a public space (like a McDonald's with free wifi) Obviously ymmv >Anyway, I wouldn't spend 400 Euros on a used mac with no warranty. This I agree with. I still prefer Thinkpads too but these M1s are also pretty good in almost every sense except for repairability
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
I think it was fine 20 odd years ago. I had a Thinkpad T41p in 2004 and it was a great laptop. Even my Sony Vaio Z was nice in 2008 compared to the competition (although it had serious issues with the screen flexibility causing it to fail multiple times). Since 2012 I've had 3 Macs, a 2012 Air, a 2020 M1 (this was a massive upgrade and the nicest laptop I ever used, even compared to my relatively new work thinkpad). I just cracked the screen on my M1 so bought a discounted M4 air on black friday. I can't tell the difference other than I like having magsafe back and only miss the touch bar slightly.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Hm, I find that comparison a bit off. As a lover of both, Thinkpads (original IBM and Lenovo followups) AND macbooks, I would like to say that it IS possible to maintain macbooks, at least the older ones. My 2012'er MacBook Pro is holding up, parts like the sata-cable and worn out fan were replaced and the ram was upgraded. My Powerbook 530 hat replacable parts, even the G3 Pismo(?) one and an white ibook g3 is also serviceable if you're patient. Same happend for the thinkpads 360, 570, 600, X41t, X61s, T60, T61... hell. We even had chinese colleagues ordering for motherboards for us from china with changed firmware to run 201'er boards in X200 tablets. I became frustrated on thinkpads when Lenovo tried to mimick Apples lightweight AIO design and their first chicklet keyboard frustrated me. I changed all to apple then, because if both do weird things, why not using the more power efficent M1 (imho, maybe that has changed.) Do you remember the old thinkpad bios? Where the pointer was a flying duck? Do you remember opening a thinkpad and everything was labelled with colors and had small handles to change components quickly? Do remember changing ram on a powerbook? And do you remember how hard it was to find a new scsi disc drive for them? Recently, I got an nearly mint T420 at work as I needed something for a mobile job and I just felt my love for the black boxes again. Damn, I miss those days but I also would miss my retina (apple) or 4k screen (Lenovo) if I had to decide bet…
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
Bought an X220 years back and it unintentionally became my main laptop for a few years. Sold it on in much worse condition (I kept the keyboard) at a profit and got an i7 X230T instead, which has also somehow gone up in price since. the X230 didn't last as long, the efficiencies of the M1 macbooks were too good to ignore. Gave it to my mother since because she wanted "an old laptop that just works"
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
It's really very easy, honestly. My laptop is my work life and my personal life. I spend easily 100 hours a week using it not-as-balanced-as-it-should-be between the two. I don't buy them because I need something new, I buy them because in the G4/Intel era, the iterations were massive and even a 20 or 30% increase in speed (which could be memory, CPU, disk -- they all make things faster) results in me being more productive. It's worth it for me to upgrade immediately when apple releases something new, as long as I have issues with my current device and the upgrade is enough of a delta. M1 -> M2 wasn't much of a delta and my M1 was fine. M1 -> M3 was a decent delta, but, my M1 was still fine. M1 -> M4 is a huge delta (almost double) and my screen is dented to where it's annoying to sit outside and use the laptop (bright sun makes the defect worse), so, I'm upgrading. If I hadn't dented the screen the choice would be /a lot/ harder. I love ThinkPads too. Really can take a beating and keep on going. The post-IBM era ones are even better in some regards too. I keep one around running Debian for Linux-emergencies.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itLenovo ThinkPad: Likes it
My mother often breaks computers, due to how where she often uses them (in the kitchen while cooking etc.) I bought her a t420, which cost less than $100. All I did was swap in an SSD. But here’s the thing, I bought two t420s, and when one breaks I cannibalize the other for parts, or just swap the SSD into the old machine. I make sure to always have a spare machine, which is not hard because after you cannibalize one machine, and get a replacement, the parts on the cannibalized machine will often suffice for a while until you need to replace the same part again. For her use cases, and to be honest 90% of people’s use cases, a t420 from 2011 has an excess of power. And the peace of mind knowing that spilling water on the keyboard will be a repair that takes 10 minutes (I could probably repair a t420 blindfolded at this point) and effectively only cost you $10-$20, is wonderful. I’ve been able to walk her through repairs over the phone. I tend to use old various X220/X230 thinkpad as beaters. Used to be big on the X201, but somehow the X201 has been creeping up in price. Yeah, I use and like my big M1 MacBook for work. It’s nice for what I do at my job. But in my personal life I’m 100% happy with Arch Linux and i3wm on a stack of thinkpads. Having swappable batteries might be my favorite part, other than how well Linux runs.