The stuff Hacker News actually recommends.

Laptops

Apple MacBook M1 vs Framework Laptop

Hacker News owners slightly favor the Apple MacBook M1.

Apple MacBook M1Framework Laptop
Owners with an opinion211751
Positive verdicts73% of 18071% of 661
Positive/negative since 202458/21309/139
Happy after 3+ years424
Longest happy owner4.1 yrs5 yrs
Praised forperformance and reliabilityrepairability and reliability
Criticized forsoftwarebattery and build quality
Newest comment

Updated

What owners wrote about both

Apple MacBook M1: NeutralFramework Laptop: Likes it
> The same Gemma 4 MoE model (Q4) As you have so much RAM I would suggest running Q8_0 directly. It's not slower (perhaps except for the initial model load), and might even be faster, while being almost identical in quality to the original model. And just to be sure: you're are running the MLX version, right? The mlx-community quantization seemed to be broken when I tried it last week (it spit out garbage), so I downloaded the unsloth version instead. That too was broken in mlx-lm (it crashed), but has since been fixed on the main branch of https://github.com/ml-explore/mlx-lm . I unfortunately only have 16 GiB of RAM on a Macbook M1, but I just tried to run the Q8_0 GGUF version on a 2023 AMD Framework 13 with 64 GiB RAM just using the CPU, and that works surprisingly well with tokens/s much faster than I can read the output. The prompt cache is also very useful to quickly insert a large system prompt or file to datamine although there are probably better ways to do that instead of manually through a script.
Apple MacBook M1: NeutralFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
TL;dr Framework isn't worth the price. If you put it apples to apples with a great product like the M1, Framework loses everywhere. I had the same conclusion after daily driving both for 2 years; until yesterday, when my water bottle opened in my backpack and soaked them. When I got home, I ripped apart my Framework and dried each piece. I left the M1 by my heater and tried to dry it out. This morning, I put the Framework back together, and everything except the keyboard works. The M1 won't boot. While I did pay a ridiculous amount for my Framework, the keyboard is 50$ to replace. After the M1 design had me feeling it was more premium, it ultimately failed first.
Apple MacBook M1: Doesn’t like itFramework Laptop: Likes it
Based on my framework 13 and macbook m1, I think the only downgrade are the speakers and the trackpad. The keyboard is actually an upgrade, the 2.8k screen has a better size ratio but the contrast is not as good, I'd say it's decent. The trackpad performs well but it's the old hinged design and not haptic. Being able to service my own laptop, replace parts and max out the storage for less money than a mid-spec macbook is just unbelievable.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
Yea I got a FW a few years ago and regret it. For just a few hundred $$$ more I could've gotten an M1. The battery situation makes me never use it. Compare to a macbook when I can just close it and open it up weeks later and it just turns on with plenty of charge still left. Every time I need to use the FW i need to plug it in first or charge it if I want to take it somewhere. Defeats the point of a portable computing device When I travel with it, i need to make sure I shut it down and not just close the lid, or it discharges and cooks my backpack Everything else is fine though
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
I have an i7 Framework and an M1 Macbook that were built around the same time in 2021. I love the _idea_ of the Framework (and I prefer Windows to macOS) but you're right that comparing them isn't really fair. The Macbook has longer battery life, is faster, and is QUIETER. I do a lot of game development and doing it on the Framework, the bottom of it gets so hot that you can't touch it and it feels like it's going to burn my lap. The fan sounds like a small plane taking off and absolutely blasts out hot air. The battery only lasts ~2 hours. Exact same workload on the M1 Macbook and the fan doesn't even spin up. The battery lasts probably 6 hours. You can put it comfortably on your lap. I don't blame Framework here; I love the laptop but I don't think that a Windows/Linux machine can compete with Apple Silicon. ARM is just so much better for a laptop.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itFramework Laptop: Doesn’t like it
I bought a framework just over a year ago. Honestly I wish I just bought an M1 macbook - it's only a few hundred more and it's a superior laptop all around (I have one for work). Yea I can't put Linux on the M1 but honestly OSX is close enough. The battery life in particular is so good - the fact that I can close the laptop for a few weeks and then open it and it starts up just feels amazing
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itFramework Laptop: Likes it
There should be no questioning on matters of personal taste, but I will offer my experience with the 13 FW, which is that build quality is pretty great already, but also you get the option to maintain it longer term, such as changing hinges etc. which gives confidence on longevity. I also have a Macbook M1, and I have found myself reaching for the framework almost exclusively now. It feels great to work on a machine that you feel like you own a bit more than any other. Macbook is also great, I think one of the best machines I ever owned, but it gradually loses first place to Framework.
Apple MacBook M1: Likes itFramework Laptop: Likes it
I use an M1 Macbook for work and I also have a Framework for personal use and... yeah. I adore the Framework but I really wish there was a REAL non-Apple competitor in the laptop space. The M1 is just _so_ quiet and fast, I really have to try hard to get the fan to spin up. Can't really speak for battery life since it never leaves my desk where it's plugged in haha. It's a shame I despise macOS so much or else I'd use this work laptop for personal stuff more often.